Horror On TV: The Paul Lynde Halloween Special (dir by Sid Smith)


Tonight, from 1976, we have The Paul Lynde Halloween Special.  

In this special, actor and comedian Paul Lynde celebrates Halloween with Betty White, KISS, Donny and Marie Osmond, Florence Henderson, Billy Barty, Margaret Hamilton (the original Wicked Witch of the West), and I’m going to guess a mountain of cocaine that was probably sitting backstage.

This special is definitely a product of a very certain era in America’s cultural history.

Horror Icarus File No. 36: Mindhunter (by Joe Penhall)


“Butchering people is hard work. Physically and mentally.” — Ed Kemper

The scariest thing in Mindhunter isn’t a crime scene. It’s how quickly a conversation with a murderer can start to feel normal. Someone makes a joke, offers an observation, or answers a question with surprising thoughtfulness, and for a moment you settle into the exchange. Then comes a detail that makes your stomach turn, delivered in exactly the same conversational tone. Across its two seasons, the Netflix series repeatedly catches you making that adjustment. You become comfortable listening to people whose actions should make comfort impossible. That’s where the show finds its particular kind of horror: not in making monsters seem alien, but in showing how easily they can sound like anyone else.

Created by Joe Penhall, with David Fincher serving as an executive producer and a defining directorial presence, Mindhunter draws from John E. Douglas and Mark Olshaker’s book Mindhunter: Inside the FBI’s Elite Serial Crime Unit. It follows the early development of criminal-profiling research within the FBI’s Behavioral Science Unit through agents Holden Ford and Bill Tench and psychologist Wendy Carr. We’ve watched countless investigators study killers and connect behavioral patterns, but what feels different here is the uncertainty. These characters aren’t applying an established formula. They’re trying to determine whether their questions can produce anything useful at all.

That gives the procedural material an unusual texture. Holden and Bill travel, negotiate access, conduct interviews, and deal with colleagues who don’t necessarily see the value in their work. Wendy wants to turn their encounters into research rather than a collection of gruesome anecdotes. The process can be repetitive, awkward, and bureaucratic, which makes it convincing. Instead of treating profiling as a supernatural gift possessed by the smartest person in the room, Mindhunter presents it as a developing discipline shaped by observation, disagreement, and mistakes. Getting someone to talk is only the beginning. Knowing what to do with the answers is another problem entirely.

Unlike Se7en, Mindhunter doesn’t surround its characters with a grimy, nihilistic atmosphere that makes the entire world feel rotten. Nor is its main driving force the obsessive, cat-and-mouse pursuit that consumes the investigators in Zodiac. Its horror comes from somewhere quieter: the suggestion that beneath everyday normalcy lurks a darker, much darker world. Ed Kemper, Dennis Rader—the BTK killer—Wayne Williams, and Charles Manson weren’t inventions designed to populate a nightmare. They existed and walked among the masses. Their histories aren’t interchangeable, but their presence throughout the series punctures the comforting idea that dangerous people must somehow announce themselves as dangerous.

Calling Mindhunter a crime thriller or police procedural, then, only gets you so far. It has horror in its DNA and both feet firmly planted in the genre. That isn’t simply because it deals with murder and sexual violence. It makes normalcy itself feel unreliable. A calm voice, a familiar routine, or an apparently reasonable explanation tells you remarkably little about the person behind it. These people occupied ordinary spaces, held conversations, and participated in a world that didn’t always recognize what they were. There’s no supernatural threat to identify and no reassuring boundary separating their world from ours.

The use of the killers’ own recorded words makes that realization harder to shake. Although Mindhunter dramatizes its encounters rather than reconstructing them as a documentary, portions of its interview dialogue draw from actual statements. You aren’t simply hearing a screenwriter invent something horrible for a villain to say. There’s a real person behind the language, someone who found ways to describe, explain, or rationalize appalling acts. The matter-of-fact presentation makes it worse. The show rarely needs to insist that you be disturbed. It simply gives you enough time to understand what you’ve just heard.

Cameron Britton’s Ed Kemper is the clearest expression of that approach. He’s articulate, conversational, and seemingly pleased that someone wants to listen. Britton doesn’t play every exchange as a warning that violence is about to erupt. He lets Kemper be engaging, which creates a more uncomfortable response than constant menace would. You understand Holden’s fascination even while recognizing the danger in it. Kemper’s willingness to talk doesn’t mean he has surrendered control. Sometimes it means he has found another way to exercise it. Britton makes the difference between access and understanding frighteningly easy to miss.

Fincher’s influence is apparent in how patiently these encounters unfold. The controlled framing, subdued interiors, and measured pacing encourage you to notice small changes: a pause, a look, a shift in posture. A room can remain physically unchanged while the balance of power inside it moves somewhere unpleasant. These are horror sequences built around conversation. Nobody needs to jump out of the shadows. The tension comes from proximity and the possibility that the investigators have become more exposed than they realize. They can leave the room, but that doesn’t mean everything they heard stays behind.

Jonathan Groff makes Holden’s confidence both understandable and irritating. His curiosity opens doors, but he starts confusing his ability to provoke a response with an ability to control the encounter. Groff preserves the earnestness beneath that arrogance. Holden wants the work to matter, but he also wants to be right. His frightening encounter with Kemper exposes how little professional enthusiasm can do when intellectual curiosity becomes physical vulnerability. Understanding danger isn’t the same thing as feeling another person take control of your safety.

Holt McCallany’s Bill Tench supplies the weary perspective Holden lacks. He’s practical, skeptical, and more aware that a useful interview can still leave damage behind. His dry humor keeps the series from becoming suffocatingly solemn, but exhaustion always feels close to the surface. The second-season situation involving his adopted son and a toddler’s death brings his professional anxieties home. The parallel sometimes feels overly arranged, yet McCallany grounds it in a father’s helplessness. Anna Torv’s Wendy provides another necessary counterweight, insisting on methods and conclusions that can withstand scrutiny. Her personal story integrates less smoothly, but her presence keeps the project from becoming a celebration of Holden’s instincts.

The Atlanta child-murder investigation pushes those instincts against a reality that refuses to accommodate them. Behavioral patterns collide with racial distrust, political pressure, institutional priorities, and families whose grief cannot be answered by an interesting theory. Holden’s certainty becomes harder to admire when the stakes extend beyond proving his approach works. Meanwhile, the glimpses of BTK quietly undermine any comforting sense of progress. Whatever knowledge the team acquires, other lives continue beyond its awareness. Understanding some offenders doesn’t mean the investigators can recognize or stop them all.

The lack of a third season makes that expanding scope especially frustrating. Fincher has declared Mindhunter finished, citing the difficulty of justifying its production costs against its audience. Instead of reaching a deliberate conclusion, the series stops with important threads still hanging. The recurring glimpses of BTK suggest a longer game that never gets played out, while the futures of Holden, Bill, Wendy, and their developing work remain unresolved. For fans and critics who championed the series, that’s more than the disappointment of losing a favorite show. It’s the frustration of watching something grow more ambitious only to have its possibilities cut short. There’s a difference between deliberately withholding easy answers and losing the opportunity to continue asking the questions.

Still, its unfinished state doesn’t erase what those two seasons accomplished. You can admire the performances, the filmmaking, and the intelligence of its procedural detail, but its lasting effect is less comfortable than admiration. It leaves you thinking about pleasant exchanges and ordinary faces that gave nothing away. Other crime shows let the solution create distance between us and the horror. Mindhunter keeps taking that distance back. By the end, the troubling question isn’t how anyone could sit across from these men and listen. It’s how many people sat across from them before anyone knew what they had done.

Previous Icarus Files:

  1. Cloud Atlas
  2. Maximum Overdrive
  3. Glass
  4. Captive State
  5. Mother!
  6. The Man Who Killed Don Quixote
  7. Last Days
  8. Plan 9 From Outer Space
  9. The Last Movie
  10. 88
  11. The Bonfire of the Vanities
  12. Birdemic
  13. Birdemic 2: The Resurrection
  14. Last Exit To Brooklyn
  15. Glen or Glenda
  16. The Assassination of Trotsky
  17. Che!
  18. Brewster McCloud
  19. American Traitor: The Trial of Axis Sally
  20. Tough Guys Don’t Dance
  21. Reach Me
  22. Revolution
  23. The Last Tycoon
  24. Express to Terror
  25. 1941
  26. The Teheran Incident
  27. Con Man
  28. Looker
  29. 1776
  30. Here
  31. The Adventures of Brisco County, Jr.
  32. The Cable Guy
  33. A Chorus Line
  34. Carrie
  35. Millenium

Retro Television Review: The Love Boat 8.18 “Love on the Line/Don’t Call Me Gopher/Her Honor, the Mayor”


Welcome to Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past!  On Wednesdays, I will be reviewing the original Love Boat, which aired on ABC from 1977 to 1986!  The series can be streamed on Paramount Plus!

And love won’t hurt anymore …. unless your nickname is Gopher.

Episode 8.18 “Love on the Line/Don’t Call Me Gopher/Her Honor, the Mayor”

(Dir by Richard A. Wells, originally aired on January 26th, 1985)

Poor Gopher.

All he wants is for the crew to not call him by his nickname for one cruise.  His friend Janet (Katherine Moffat) is going to be on the boat and she only knows him as Burl.  Burl, to put it simply, wants to get laid.  He suspects that he’ll have a better chance of getting laid if Janet doesn’t know that his nickname is Gopher.  He’s probably correct about that, though Burl isn’t much of an improvement.

For some reason, the crew takes it personally.  They act as if Burl is being arrogant by not wanting to be called by a nickname that brings to mind a hairy and destructive rodent.  Eventually, Janet does discover that “Gopher” is Burl’s nickname and, just as Burl suspected, she finds it impossible to kiss him without laughing.

And yet, somehow, Burl is the one who ends up apologizing to the crew and accepting that he will always be known as Gopher.  Listen, if the guy wants to be known by his actual legal name, that’s his right.  Of course, Gopher does get laid after he accepts his nickname so maybe the crew had a point.  Who knows?

Meanwhile, newly-elected Mayor Frances Hardy (Shelley Fabares) boards the boat with her campaign manager, Barry Singer (David Hedison).  Barry is in love with Frances and wants to marry her.  However, Frances ends up falling in love with the man she defeated in the election, Phil Haines (Robert Fuller).  It’s nice to see that political differences don’t have to stand in the way of love.  Imagine how different the country would be today if Hillary and Donald would just admit that they’re in love with each other.

Finally, businessman John Stockton (Cesar Romero) meets a mysterious woman named Marcy (Jane Wyatt).  Mary encourages John to shake off his old routine and learn to love life.  How will John react when he discovers that Marcy actually works in his office?  If you guessed that John will fall in love with her, you’re right.  This is the Love Boat!

This wasn’t a bad episode.  The guest stars were likable.  The stories were pleasant in that way that the Love Boat usually is.  That said, I do feel bad for Gopher.  All he wanted was a better nickname.

 

Late Night Retro Television Review: Pacific Blue 5.3 “Blue Hawaii: Part One”


Welcome to Late Night Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past! On Tuesdays, I will be reviewing Pacific Blue, a cop show that aired from 1996 to 2000 on the USA Network!  It’s currently streaming everywhere, though I’m watching it on Tubi.

This week, the bike cops go to Hawaii!

Episode 5.3 “Blue Hawaii: Part One”

(Dir by Michael Levine, originally aired on August 1st, 1999)

TC, Cory, Bobby, and Granger are sent to Hawaii so that they can spend five days training other bicycle cops.  If there’s anything that this show has shown over the past five seasons, it’s that it takes a lot of training to be a bicycle cop.  For instance, you have to know how to look smugly self-satisfied while holding up traffic.  That’s not a natural skill.  That’s something you have to learn.  Whenever Cory responds to a legitimate question by yelling and shoving someone into a wall, you’re seeing years of training.  Whenever Chris runs a bystander over with her bicycle and then says, “Just doing my job,” that’s her way of sayin, “Your taxes paid for this!”

Bobby and Granger spend their first Hawaiian night at a strip club.  A drug dealer (Dax Griffin) mistakes Bobby for a buyer.  This leads to Bobby and Granger getting involved in an undercover operation.  We meet the other members of Hawaii’s special undercover task force.  There’s Sgt. Aikau (Andy Bumatai), a surfer who puts a curse on TC.  There’s Matt Cho (Lorenzo Callender), who acts just like Bobby.  There’s an Australian cop (played by Corey Page) who acts just like Granger.  And then there’s Officer Claire Keene (Kristanna Loken) who acts just like Cory.

As you probably already guessed, this episode was a backdoor pilot for a series that was didn’t end up happening.  (This episode aired the same year that Baywatch became Baywatch Hawaii.)  It’s also a two-parter, which means this episode ends with Bobby and Granger still working undercover, the drug dealers still on the loose, and the Hawaiian cops in need of some lessons on how to work undercover.  Bobby is also falling for Claire and is thinking about transferring permanently to Hawaii.

Like a lot of backdoor pilots, this episode fails because it asked us to get emotionally invested in a bunch of new, poorly-drawn characters.  The fact that all of the Hawaiian cops had the same personality tics as their California counterparts didn’t help matters.  That said, I enjoyed this episode just because it was shot in Hawaii and the scenery was lovely.

Next week, we’ll conclude our trip to paradise with Part Two of Blue Hawaii!

A Scene That Erin Loves From Major League


I know this isn’t Halloween-related but I’m still buzzing over the baseball game that I just watched.  I’m so exited that I’m going to stay up late and watch my favorite baseball movie!  Here’s one of my favorite scenes from Major League.  Listen as Tom Berenger tells you, me, and everyone else what to do whenever anyone says you don’t have a chance at winning!

The Rays Win Game 4!


Holy crap, that was one of the best baseball games that I’ve ever seen!

Congratulations to the Tampa Bay Rays, who came back from what everyone thought was certain doom in the final extra inning and who just won their first World Series game!

12 innings, six and a half hours of baseball, and tomorrow, we’re doing it all over again! Games likes this are what I was talking about when I said that being a baseball fan means staying until the final episode.  You never know when the entire game might be turned around.

Congratulations to the Rays!  Keep it going tomorrow!

Horror on Television: One Step Beyond 1.1 “The Bride Possessed” (dir by John Newland)


 One Step Beyond was a supernatural-themed anthology show that claimed every story that it told was based on an actual incident.  This show ran on ABC from 1959 to 1961 and was scheduled to air opposite of Twilight Zone.

The very first episode of One Step Beyond aired on January 20th, 1959.  In this episode, a young bride (Virginia Leith) on her honeymoon suddenly starts to act differently.  (Not only does she become more outspoken but she also loses her Southern accent.)  Is it possible that she’s been possessed by the spirit of a murdered woman and now, she’s going to solve her own murder?

Watch to find out!

Retro Television Review: Saved By The Bell: The New Class 2.24 “Belding’s Prize”


Welcome to Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past!  On Tuesdays, I will be reviewing Saved By The Bell: The New Class, which ran on NBC from 1993 to 2o00.  The show is currently on Prime.

This week, Screech screws up again.

Episode 2.24 “Belding’s Prize”

(Dir by Don Barnhart, originally aired on December 24th, 1997)

Mr. Belding is super excited about joining the National Society of Principals!  Except — uh-oh! — Screech forgot to mail in the application.  What an idiot.  Actually, what a pair of idiots.  Screech may have screwed up but Belding shouldn’t have been depending on him in the first place.  Mail your own application, Belding!

Screech could tell Belding the truth or he could lie and hire James The Actor (Mark Blankfield) to pretend to be the Grand Master of the Society and they could have a big fake ceremony at the school.  Screech goes with the latter.  It never seems to occur to Screech that, when he gave Belding a fake letter telling him that his application had been accepted, he could have just left it that.  Instead, he decides to do a fake ceremony at the school.  And he decides to hire James the Actor, despite the fact that Belding has met James in three other episodes.

This was the final time that Mark Blankfield plays James the Actor on Saved By The Bell.  This is also his weakest outing as James, largely because the character is totally different here than he was in his previous appearances.  Previously, James was quirky but good-hearted and determined to help the Bayside Gang out, whether the gang was led by Zack or Scott.  This time, James is portrayed as being so self-absorbed and stupid that he literally leaves the fake ceremony after he gets a call telling him that he’s been hired for Broadway Show.  He accidentally  pulls off his fake beard.  He accidentally pulls off the fake label that Tommy put on the trophy that James presented to Belding.  James screws everything up and Mark Blanfield plays the role as if James acquired a cocaine addiction between appearances.

In the end, Belding forgives Screech.  I have no idea why.

Meanwhile, the Gang wants to order the millionth burger at the Max so they’ll win tickets to the MTV Music Video Awards.  Unfortunately, other students are ordering burgers too so the Gang spreads a rumor that Max burgers are actually bad for your stomach.  That’s a great way to support your favorite hangout.  Spread a food poisoning rumor and get the place shut down.  Way to go, Gang, ya mooks!

When Tommy buys 200 burgers but still fails to order the millionth one, the Gang sells the burgers back to their fellow students and then use the money to buy more Max burgers.  Eventually, the grill gets shut down and Mr. Belding ends up winning the contest.

This episode featured Dustin Diamond at his worse.  He was never particularly good but at least he seemed to be trying for the first half of the second season.  But, in this episode, he speaks in his falsetto voice, he’s cartoonishly broad in his movements, and he goes all wide-eyed whenever he pretends to be sad or serious.  This is the Screech who showed up for the rest of Saved By The Bell: The New Class.

This wasn’t a great episode but it did remind me that the MTV Music Video Awards used to be a big deal.  It’s amazing how things change.

 

Happy Birthday To It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown!


Sixty years ago today, on October 27, 1966, It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown first aired on CBS!

I used to love watching It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown every October and I still haven’t forgiven CBS for selling it and all of the other Peanuts specials to Apple TV.  We do subscribe to Apple TV so I can still watch the special every year but it just feels unfair to me.  Watching Linus wait for the Great Pumpkin and Charlie Brown getting a rock while trick-or-treating is something that brought people together.  It was a shared experience and now, it’s not.  That still really bothers me.  Where’s the sincerity in taking away a beloved communal experience and making people pay to enjoy it?  No wonder the Great Pumpkin never shows up.

(Even though it’s not in the same league, I’m also not happy with Disney for yanking Toy Story of Terror! off the air either.  Sometimes, I feel like we’re heading towards a world without holidays or any celebrations whatsoever.)

Here are some of my favorite scenes from It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown.  I’ll have at least two more to share on Halloween!