Film Review: The Prestige (dir. by Christopher Nolan)


“You don’t really want to work it out. You want to be fooled.” — Cutter

The best magic tricks depend on a peculiar agreement between performer and audience: we know we are being deceived, yet we want the deception to succeed. Christopher Nolan’s The Prestige turns that agreement into the foundation of a film about two men who can no longer distinguish the pleasure of creating an illusion from the need to possess its secret. Their rivalry begins on the stage, but it soon consumes everything beyond it. What emerges is more than a mystery built around competing magicians. It is a dark, absorbing examination of obsession, sacrifice, and the terrible distance between earning applause and finding satisfaction.

Adapted by Christopher and Jonathan Nolan from Christopher Priest’s novel, The Prestige follows Alfred Borden (Christian Bale) and Robert Angier (Hugh Jackman), magicians whose professional ambitions become inseparable from a deeply personal feud. Having read the novel, I approached the adaptation with some hesitation. Much of the book’s appeal comes from the way its journals and personal accounts allow characters to reveal information while concealing their intentions. Bringing that experience to the screen requires more than faithfully reproducing the plot. It requires finding a cinematic equivalent for the uncertainty of reading someone else’s carefully constructed version of events.

The Nolan brothers understand that distinction. Rather than presenting the rivalry as a straightforward progression from friendship to hostility, they move among its beginnings, consequences, and apparent resolutions. One scene supplies information that changes our understanding of another; a confession becomes a provocation; an explanation raises a new question. The fractured chronology recalls Christopher Nolan’s narrative experimentation in Memento, but here the structure has a different effect. We are not simply trying to determine what happened. We are trying to decide who controls the story—and what that person gains by telling it.

The film gives us its organizing principle through Cutter, the stage engineer played by Michael Caine. He explains that a magic trick has three parts. In “the pledge,” the magician presents something ordinary. In “the turn,” that ordinary thing undergoes an extraordinary transformation or disappearance. Finally, “the prestige” completes the illusion by bringing back what seemed to be lost. Nolan uses this explanation as both an invitation and a warning. He tells us to watch closely, then trusts that our eagerness to see something extraordinary will distract us from the significance of what we see.

That approach makes The Prestige especially satisfying as a mystery. Its clues are not merely withheld until the screenplay decides to reveal them. Many are placed directly before us, disguised by context or overshadowed by something more immediately dramatic. An attentive viewer may anticipate part of the solution relatively early, but recognizing a secret does not necessarily diminish the film. There is still the question of how it works, what it costs, and how far either magician is willing to go to protect it.

Those costs give the elaborate construction its emotional weight. Borden and Angier begin as colleagues working for Milton the Magician, played by Ricky Jay, with Cutter providing the technical expertise behind the act. Even then, their differences are apparent. Borden is instinctively inventive, impatient with limitations, and willing to take risks in pursuit of a better illusion. Angier understands presentation: the timing, confidence, and theatrical flair that persuade an audience to invest in a performance. Each has a talent the other lacks, and neither can comfortably accept that imbalance.

A tragedy turns those differences into grievances. From that point forward, professional competition becomes a means of assigning blame and exacting punishment. Their efforts to improve their acts increasingly serve another purpose: to deny the other man the satisfaction of success. They interrupt performances, steal information, manipulate loyalties, and endanger the people around them. Eventually, it becomes difficult to separate their desire to achieve greatness from their desire to make the other suffer.

One of the screenplay’s strongest decisions is its refusal to make either man an uncomplicated hero. Angier’s charm does not excuse his cruelty, and Borden’s ingenuity does not make his emotional evasiveness easier to bear. The film allows us to understand their grievances without asking us to endorse their actions. Our sympathies shift because both men remain recognizably human even as their behavior becomes increasingly monstrous.

Jackman is particularly effective at showing how an accomplished public performer can become privately consumed by resentment. Angier knows how to hold an audience, but he cannot enjoy that gift while Borden possesses a secret he cannot explain. Jackman lets the frustration accumulate beneath the polished exterior until the pursuit of an answer becomes more important than the applause that supposedly motivated him.

Bale gives Borden a more guarded, abrasive presence. His confidence in his craft contrasts with his difficulty explaining himself to the people closest to him. At times, he seems capable of extraordinary commitment; at others, he appears maddeningly indifferent to the consequences of that commitment. Bale makes those contradictions compelling without smoothing them away. Together, the two actors turn the rivalry into something more unsettling than a contest between evenly matched opponents. Each man becomes the justification for the other’s worst impulses.

Caine provides an essential counterweight. Cutter understands the labor behind an illusion, but he also recognizes that technical possibility is not the same as moral permission. His practical manner grounds the film whenever its central characters threaten to disappear into their own grand ambitions. He is persuasive as someone who loves the craft while retaining a sense of proportion about what it should demand.

The women caught in the rivalry make its consequences harder to dismiss. Scarlett Johansson’s Olivia is more than a glamorous addition to the stage act. Her shifting loyalties reveal how readily both magicians turn intimacy into strategy. She may be drawn to their talent, but neither man can reliably separate affection from advantage. The film is at its most painful when their need to preserve a secret prevents them from responding honestly to another person.

The production design reinforces the divide between public enchantment and private effort. Onstage, an illusion appears graceful and instantaneous. Backstage, it depends on cramped spaces, concealed mechanisms, repetition, and people whose work the audience never sees. Nathan Crowley’s Victorian settings give those hidden processes a persuasive physical presence. The theaters and workshops belong to the same world, but they offer very different views of what constitutes magic.

That world expands with the arrival of Nikola Tesla, played by David Bowie. Bowie’s restrained, enigmatic performance makes Tesla feel distinct from the showmen seeking his help. He has little need to command a room, yet his work promises something more astonishing than anything their theatrical ingenuity can produce. The machinery surrounding him introduces a steampunk atmosphere and pushes the story toward science fiction without abandoning its central concerns.

For me, this shift works because the film has already established the dangerous appeal of an impossible solution. Tesla’s experiments offer another way to pursue the same ambition that drives the rivalry: to accomplish something so extraordinary that no competitor can answer it. The question is no longer simply whether an illusion can be perfected. It is whether either magician would recognize a point at which perfection demands too much.

There is a risk that such an intricately constructed film will seem more interested in concealing its mechanism than in developing its characters. Some viewers will undoubtedly regard The Prestige as an elaborate gimmick, and its screenplay certainly invites admiration for its engineering. Yet the revelations matter because they change our understanding of the behavior that precedes them. What first appears to be stubbornness, inconsistency, or theatrical bravado acquires a darker significance. The solution does not erase the drama; it exposes the full extent of it.

What stayed with me after The Prestige was not simply the satisfaction of learning how its tricks were done. It was the realization that neither magician could accept a life in which the other remained beyond his understanding. Nolan delivers the pleasures of a cleverly concealed mechanism, but the final revelation leaves something less comfortable than admiration in its wake. We can finally see what these men have made of themselves, even if they never fully can. The secrets are impressive, but the human wreckage behind them is what gives the illusion its lasting power.

The TSL Horror Grindhouse: The Phantom of the Opera (dir by Dwight H. Little)


1989’s The Phantom of the Opera opens in what was then-modern day Manhattan.

Christine Day (Jill Schoelen) is a young opera singer who is searching for the perfect audition piece.  Her friend, Meg (Molly Shannon), suggests that she use an obscure opera piece called Don Juan Triumphant.  The opera was written by Erik Destler, a mysterious composer who was accused of murdering several opera singers in the 1800s.  That morbid fact only makes Christine all the more convinced that she should use the piece in her audition and you know what?  I would probably feel the same way.  If nothing else, it would certainly appeal to my subversive side.

Even after Christine imagines seeing blood seeping off the pages of the opera, she remains committed to auditioning with it.  Unfortunately, at the audition, a sandbag falls on her head.  She’s knocked unconscious and, when she wakes up, she finds herself in 1885 London.  She’s an understudy for a diva named La Carlotta (Sharon Lawrence).  Carlotta has skill and technique but her singing lacks emotion.  She hits each note perfectly but she brings no deeper meaning to her performances.  Christine may lack Carlotta’s polish but she sings with emotion.  For that reason, Carlotta is jealous of Christine.  Meanwhile, Erik Destler (Robert Englund), who lives in the sewers of London’s opera house and who wears a mask over his disfigured face, feels that Christine is the only one who can do his work justice and he’s willing to go to any length to make sure that she’s the one who performs on stage.

At the time he made The Phantom of the Opera, Robert Englund was still regularly playing Freddy Krueger.  The film’s version of Erik Destler does owe a bit to Krueger.  Erik is as ruthless as Freddy, he’s good with a quip, he’s just as willing to kill, and, needless to say, he also has a face that will haunt your nightmares.  That said, Erik is also a creative artist, which is something that Freddy never was.  If Freddy was motivated by revenge, Erik is motivated by a desire to see his work come to life the way that he’s always imagined it.  Erik murders to help Christine (regardless of whether or not Chrsitine actually wants the help) whereas Freddy killed because he enjoyed it.  Englund gives a good performance as Erik, occasionally playing the role with the type of broadness that is to expected from a B-horror film but also still offering hints of the artist that Erik once was.  Englund is well-matched with Jill Schoelen, who brings a likable energy to Christine.

Produced by Menahem Golan and Harry Alan Towers, The Phantom of the Opera is an entertaining B-movie, one that is obviously not meant to be taken too seriously.  Director Dwight H. Little keeps the action moving at a steady pace, the sets and the costumes are to die for, the kills are unapologetically bloody, and the film even manages to put an interesting twist on the whole “it was all dream!” thing.  The Phantom of the Opera is an enjoyably macabre showcase for two of the best horror performers of the 80s and 90s, Jill Schoelen and Robert Englund.

 

Horror On TV: Hammer House Of Horror #9: Carpathian Eagle (dir by Francis Megahy)


Tonight’s episode of Hammer House of Horror is Carpathian Eagle.

Men are being murdered in bed by a woman who removes their heart.  Inspector Clifford (Anthony Valentine) investigates with the help of a true crime historian named Natalie (Suzanne Danielle).  Natalie tells the story of an ancient Carpathian countess who murdered men in the same way and suggests that the murders might be the work of a modern-day descendant.  The truth turns out to be a bit more complicated, if also a bit predictable.

This is not my favorite episode Hammer House of Horror but still, it’s worth watching to catch a young Pierce Brosnan in an early small role.  This episode originally aired on November 8th, 1980.

Guilty Pleasure No. 21: Hawk the Slayer (dir. by Terry Marcel)


HawktheSlayer

Tonight was the season finale of Game of Thrones season 4. It was another great piece of storytelling that managed to juggle several subplots and giving each one their own time to shine.

The latest “Guilty Pleasure” is the 1980 epically mind-numbing fantasy film Hawk the Slayer starring the great Jack Palance in the the villainous role of Voltan the evil elder brother to the film’s title character, Hawk the Slayer. This film is in the other side of the quality spectrum of tonight’s Game of Thrones season finale.

Hawk the Slayer was part of the 80’s flood of sword and sorcery films that included such titles as Conan the Barbarian, Beastmaster and Ladyhawke. To say that this film was bad would be an understatement. Yet, I’m quite drawn to it whenever I see it on TV. In fact, it was on syndication that I first saw this when I was just a wee lad. I might have been around 9 or 10 when I came across it halfway through.

Maybe it was the fact that I was just discovering Advanced Dungeons & Dragons, but this film  spoke to me. It had that timeless story of brother against brother. The evil tyrant with legions of evil ne’er do wells against a small band of class-specific heroes and rogues. I mean this had it all. We had the hero of the film who I would probably place in the swordsman class. Then we had Ranulf with his repeating crossbow that would be the band’s rogue. Of course, there’s Gort the giant with his mighty hammer and Baldin the dwarf skilled in the art of the whip. But the one character that really shouted RPG for me throughout this film was Crow the Elf who could fire his bow as fast as any machine gun I’ve ever seen.

I think it’s very awfulness is why I keep returning to it whenever I see it on TV. The acting is atrocious with special effects that even in 1980 would be seen as laughable. The characters themselves were so one-note that one wonders if the person who wrote the screenplay was actually a trained monkey. Yet, the film was fun for all those reasons. It’s one of those titles that one would express as being so bad it’s good. Even now, with childhood several decades past, I still enjoy watching Hawk the Slayer and always wonder when they plan to get the sequel set-up and made.

Oh, the synth-heavy disco-fantasy-western soundtrack was also something to behold.

  1. Half-Baked
  2. Save The Last Dance
  3. Every Rose Has Its Thorns
  4. The Jeremy Kyle Show
  5. Invasion USA
  6. The Golden Child
  7. Final Destination 2
  8. Paparazzi
  9. The Principal
  10. The Substitute
  11. Terror In The Family
  12. Pandorum
  13. Lambada
  14. Fear
  15. Cocktail
  16. Keep Off The Grass
  17. Girls, Girls, Girls
  18. Class
  19. Tart
  20. King Kong vs. Godzilla