Retro Television Review: St. Elsewhere 4.21 “Cheek to Cheek”


Welcome to Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past! On Fridays, I will be reviewing St. Elsewhere, a medical show which ran on NBC from 1982 to 1988.  The show can be found on YouTube!

This week, Westphall’s reign of do-gooder terror continues.

Episode 4.21 “Cheek to Cheek”

(Dir by Helaine Head, originally aired on March 12th, 1986)

A few things happen over the course of this week’s episode of St. Elsewhere.

As his OB/GYN rotation comes to a close, Ehrlich is freaked out at the prospect of giving Ellen Craig a pelvic exam. He desperately tries to get out of it. Afterwards, he tries to deliver the results to Dr. Craig without revealing that he was the one who did the exam. As for the results of the exam, it turns out that Ellen’s pain is her body’s reaction to the stress of Stephen’s death and also having to deal with Dr. Craig on a regular basis. Dr. Craig finally realizes that he’s been a controlling jerk. Will it make any difference? Probably not. Dr. Craig has come to this realization in the past, and it hasn’t changed his behavior yet.

Dr. Novino is upset when she has to tell her favorite cartoonist (Eric Christmas) that he is terminally ill.

Dr. Westphall is in a good mood because he’s having sex for the first time in 10 years. Westphall is sleeping with Novino, and everyone is happy about it. As for me, I would wonder about the ethics of Westphall sleeping with one of the residents, but I really don’t want to spend too much time thinking about depressing old Donald Westphall having sex.

And, finally, Dr. Morrison does his Westphall-mandated community service by working in a prison infirmary. He meets Stephen McAllister (Jack Bannon), who has been serving time in prison ever since he shot and killed a terrorist (played by Tim Robbins, as seen in a flashback during this episode) during the show’s first season. McAllister explains that he’s now the prag of another prisoner. When a riot breaks out, McAllister and the other prisoner corner Morrison in the infirmary and rape him off-screen. The episode ends with a dazed Morrison being brought into the emergency room….

Yeah, this episode’s ending was difficult to watch. Ever since this series began, Morrison’s life has been one tragedy after another. First his wife died. Then his best friend turned out to be the ski mask rapist. Then his new girlfriend nicknamed him Boomer. Then he nearly lost his job because it turned out that he really hadn’t gone to a real medical school. Then his son got kidnapped. In between all of that, he’s lost countless patients. And now, he’s been raped in prison. David Morse is one of the great character actors, and I’m sure that played a role in the decision to give Morrison so many dramatic storylines, but c’mon, St. Elsewhere — GIVE THE MAN A BREAK!

We should remember that Morrison wouldn’t have even been at the prison if not for Westphall’s stupid community service requirement. This is all Westphall’s fault. First, Chandler nearly got blown up while working at an abortion clinic. Now, Morrison’s been assaulted in prison. You notice who never volunteers for any of these dangerous assignments? Westphall! Dr. Craig has often complained about Westphall’s bleeding-heart liberalism, and you know what? Craig was right! Westphall’s going to get someone killed.

Anyway, this episode was all about tonal whiplash. We started out with Ehrlich acting like Ehrlich and ended with Morrison in a daze, talking about his dead wife. This episode was St. Elsewhere at its darkest and its most shocking. It was also the show at its best. Few shows balanced melodrama, comedy, and horror quite as effectively as St. Elsewhere.

Will Westphall take responsibility for the damage wrought by his community service madness? We’ll find out next week!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.