Film Review: The Prestige (dir. by Christopher Nolan)


“You don’t really want to work it out. You want to be fooled.” — Cutter

The best magic tricks depend on a peculiar agreement between performer and audience: we know we are being deceived, yet we want the deception to succeed. Christopher Nolan’s The Prestige turns that agreement into the foundation of a film about two men who can no longer distinguish the pleasure of creating an illusion from the need to possess its secret. Their rivalry begins on the stage, but it soon consumes everything beyond it. What emerges is more than a mystery built around competing magicians. It is a dark, absorbing examination of obsession, sacrifice, and the terrible distance between earning applause and finding satisfaction.

Adapted by Christopher and Jonathan Nolan from Christopher Priest’s novel, The Prestige follows Alfred Borden (Christian Bale) and Robert Angier (Hugh Jackman), magicians whose professional ambitions become inseparable from a deeply personal feud. Having read the novel, I approached the adaptation with some hesitation. Much of the book’s appeal comes from the way its journals and personal accounts allow characters to reveal information while concealing their intentions. Bringing that experience to the screen requires more than faithfully reproducing the plot. It requires finding a cinematic equivalent for the uncertainty of reading someone else’s carefully constructed version of events.

The Nolan brothers understand that distinction. Rather than presenting the rivalry as a straightforward progression from friendship to hostility, they move among its beginnings, consequences, and apparent resolutions. One scene supplies information that changes our understanding of another; a confession becomes a provocation; an explanation raises a new question. The fractured chronology recalls Christopher Nolan’s narrative experimentation in Memento, but here the structure has a different effect. We are not simply trying to determine what happened. We are trying to decide who controls the story—and what that person gains by telling it.

The film gives us its organizing principle through Cutter, the stage engineer played by Michael Caine. He explains that a magic trick has three parts. In “the pledge,” the magician presents something ordinary. In “the turn,” that ordinary thing undergoes an extraordinary transformation or disappearance. Finally, “the prestige” completes the illusion by bringing back what seemed to be lost. Nolan uses this explanation as both an invitation and a warning. He tells us to watch closely, then trusts that our eagerness to see something extraordinary will distract us from the significance of what we see.

That approach makes The Prestige especially satisfying as a mystery. Its clues are not merely withheld until the screenplay decides to reveal them. Many are placed directly before us, disguised by context or overshadowed by something more immediately dramatic. An attentive viewer may anticipate part of the solution relatively early, but recognizing a secret does not necessarily diminish the film. There is still the question of how it works, what it costs, and how far either magician is willing to go to protect it.

Those costs give the elaborate construction its emotional weight. Borden and Angier begin as colleagues working for Milton the Magician, played by Ricky Jay, with Cutter providing the technical expertise behind the act. Even then, their differences are apparent. Borden is instinctively inventive, impatient with limitations, and willing to take risks in pursuit of a better illusion. Angier understands presentation: the timing, confidence, and theatrical flair that persuade an audience to invest in a performance. Each has a talent the other lacks, and neither can comfortably accept that imbalance.

A tragedy turns those differences into grievances. From that point forward, professional competition becomes a means of assigning blame and exacting punishment. Their efforts to improve their acts increasingly serve another purpose: to deny the other man the satisfaction of success. They interrupt performances, steal information, manipulate loyalties, and endanger the people around them. Eventually, it becomes difficult to separate their desire to achieve greatness from their desire to make the other suffer.

One of the screenplay’s strongest decisions is its refusal to make either man an uncomplicated hero. Angier’s charm does not excuse his cruelty, and Borden’s ingenuity does not make his emotional evasiveness easier to bear. The film allows us to understand their grievances without asking us to endorse their actions. Our sympathies shift because both men remain recognizably human even as their behavior becomes increasingly monstrous.

Jackman is particularly effective at showing how an accomplished public performer can become privately consumed by resentment. Angier knows how to hold an audience, but he cannot enjoy that gift while Borden possesses a secret he cannot explain. Jackman lets the frustration accumulate beneath the polished exterior until the pursuit of an answer becomes more important than the applause that supposedly motivated him.

Bale gives Borden a more guarded, abrasive presence. His confidence in his craft contrasts with his difficulty explaining himself to the people closest to him. At times, he seems capable of extraordinary commitment; at others, he appears maddeningly indifferent to the consequences of that commitment. Bale makes those contradictions compelling without smoothing them away. Together, the two actors turn the rivalry into something more unsettling than a contest between evenly matched opponents. Each man becomes the justification for the other’s worst impulses.

Caine provides an essential counterweight. Cutter understands the labor behind an illusion, but he also recognizes that technical possibility is not the same as moral permission. His practical manner grounds the film whenever its central characters threaten to disappear into their own grand ambitions. He is persuasive as someone who loves the craft while retaining a sense of proportion about what it should demand.

The women caught in the rivalry make its consequences harder to dismiss. Scarlett Johansson’s Olivia is more than a glamorous addition to the stage act. Her shifting loyalties reveal how readily both magicians turn intimacy into strategy. She may be drawn to their talent, but neither man can reliably separate affection from advantage. The film is at its most painful when their need to preserve a secret prevents them from responding honestly to another person.

The production design reinforces the divide between public enchantment and private effort. Onstage, an illusion appears graceful and instantaneous. Backstage, it depends on cramped spaces, concealed mechanisms, repetition, and people whose work the audience never sees. Nathan Crowley’s Victorian settings give those hidden processes a persuasive physical presence. The theaters and workshops belong to the same world, but they offer very different views of what constitutes magic.

That world expands with the arrival of Nikola Tesla, played by David Bowie. Bowie’s restrained, enigmatic performance makes Tesla feel distinct from the showmen seeking his help. He has little need to command a room, yet his work promises something more astonishing than anything their theatrical ingenuity can produce. The machinery surrounding him introduces a steampunk atmosphere and pushes the story toward science fiction without abandoning its central concerns.

For me, this shift works because the film has already established the dangerous appeal of an impossible solution. Tesla’s experiments offer another way to pursue the same ambition that drives the rivalry: to accomplish something so extraordinary that no competitor can answer it. The question is no longer simply whether an illusion can be perfected. It is whether either magician would recognize a point at which perfection demands too much.

There is a risk that such an intricately constructed film will seem more interested in concealing its mechanism than in developing its characters. Some viewers will undoubtedly regard The Prestige as an elaborate gimmick, and its screenplay certainly invites admiration for its engineering. Yet the revelations matter because they change our understanding of the behavior that precedes them. What first appears to be stubbornness, inconsistency, or theatrical bravado acquires a darker significance. The solution does not erase the drama; it exposes the full extent of it.

What stayed with me after The Prestige was not simply the satisfaction of learning how its tricks were done. It was the realization that neither magician could accept a life in which the other remained beyond his understanding. Nolan delivers the pleasures of a cleverly concealed mechanism, but the final revelation leaves something less comfortable than admiration in its wake. We can finally see what these men have made of themselves, even if they never fully can. The secrets are impressive, but the human wreckage behind them is what gives the illusion its lasting power.

Join #TubiThursday For Enter The Ninja!


Hi, everyone!  Tonight, on Mastodon, I will be hosting the #TubiThursday watch party!  Join us for Enter The Ninja!

You can find the movie on Tubi and YouTube and you can join us on Mastodon at 9 pm central time!  (That’s 10 pm for you folks on the East Coast.)  We will be using #TubiThursday hashtag!  See you then!

Scenes I Love: How is Tommy DeVito funny from Goodfellas


Today’s scene that I love comes from 1990’s Goodfellas.  This iconic scene was largely improvised by Joe Pesci and Ray Liotta.  Reportedly, Pesci based the scene on an actual incident that he observed.

It’s also interesting to note that Tommy’s comment of “you might fold under pressure” turns out to be true.

4 Shots From 4 Odd Films


4 Shots From 4 Films is just what it says it is, 4 shots from 4 of our favorite films.  As opposed to the reviews and recaps that we usually post, 4 Shots From 4 Films is all about letting the visuals do the talking.

Today, we take a moment to honor films that leave you wondering what’s real and what’s merely a dream.  It’s time for….

4 Shots From 4 Surreal Films

Inland Empire (2006, dir by David Lynch)

Inland Empire (2006, dir by David Lynch)

Borgman (2013, dir by  Alex van Warmerdam)

Borgman (2013, dir by Alex van Warmerdam)

A Field in England (2013, dir by Ben Wheatley)

A Field in England (2013, dir by Ben Wheatley)

Goodbye to Language (2014, dir by Jean-Luc Godard)

Goodbye to Language (2014, dir by Jean-Luc Godard)

Film Review: Warfare (dir. by Ray Mendoza & Alex Garland)


“Just hang in there. You’re not alone, man.” — Mac

In Warfare, staying alive is a full-time job, and nobody gets a moment off. Ray Mendoza and Alex Garland’s 2025 film builds its tension around that exhausting reality, stripping away most of the familiar comforts of a Hollywood war movie. There are no reassuring pauses for personal revelations, no grand speeches that suddenly make the suffering meaningful, and little room to admire the action from a safe emotional distance. Instead, the film concentrates on the relentless effort of getting through one disastrous situation. It is gripping, frequently overwhelming, and much more interested in the cost of survival than the excitement of combat.

The story follows members of two American Navy SEAL teams during a 2006 operation in Ramadi, Iraq. After occupying a civilian home and establishing surveillance positions, the men come under attack and find themselves struggling to evacuate their wounded. Mendoza participated in the actual incident, and his collaboration with Garland gives the film a tightly restricted perspective. Rather than explaining the war or constructing an elaborate military adventure, Warfare recreates what these men experienced and endured in real time. The assignment, the attack, and the effort to get out become almost the entire world of the movie.

That narrow focus takes some getting used to. The early scenes offer little of the character-building shorthand audiences might expect: nobody needs to display a family photograph or explain what brought him into the military. Instead, the men reveal themselves through routines, exchanges, and the way they work together. It can initially be difficult to tell everyone apart, which is both a deliberate feature and a genuine drawback. The film wants us to understand a functioning unit before we understand its individual members. That makes sense for its approach, although it occasionally keeps the characters at arm’s length.

What comes through clearly, however, is how much effort goes into simply maintaining control. Watching a street, monitoring a window, listening to instructions, and staying ready all become sources of tension. The quieter passages are not empty space before the “real movie” begins. They establish the concentration required before anything has visibly gone wrong. Garland and Mendoza make waiting feel active without constantly forcing suspense through obvious tricks. You start scanning the frame because the soldiers are scanning their surroundings, and the longer that continues, the more you realize that being prepared is not the same thing as being safe.

Once the attack begins, the film makes that distinction brutally clear. Training gives the men ways to respond, but it does not protect them from confusion, injury, or the limits of their own bodies. Plans become harder to carry out, information becomes difficult to process, and ordinary movements demand frightening amounts of effort. There is very little of the satisfying clarity that turns a complicated action sequence into an impressive display of competence. Here, competence matters precisely because everything is becoming unmanageable. The soldiers keep working, but the movie never suggests that doing everything correctly guarantees a good outcome.

The staging gives those struggles a physical weight. Rooms that seemed useful become cramped holding areas; doorways become dangerous thresholds; short stretches of exposed ground become enormous obstacles. The audience gradually learns enough about the location to appreciate why moving an injured person is not a simple matter of picking him up and running. Every action depends on other actions happening first. Someone has to communicate, someone has to provide cover, and someone has to make a decision with incomplete information. Survival becomes collective labor, and the film is strongest when it shows just how difficult that labor can be.

Sound does much of the heavy lifting. Gunfire, explosions, radio chatter, strained voices, and cries of pain create an atmosphere that feels crowded even when the image itself is relatively contained. Without a conventional musical score guiding every emotional shift, the audience has to sit with those sounds rather than receive an easy cue about how to process them. The wounded soldiers’ suffering is particularly hard to hear because it does not conveniently disappear between dramatic beats. Pain remains present while other people issue instructions and try to solve practical problems. That persistence makes the violence feel consequential rather than decorative.

The performances support this approach. D’Pharaoh Woon-A-Tai, playing Mendoza, provides an important point of connection without turning the film into a one-man showcase. Cosmo Jarvis, Will Poulter, Charles Melton, and the rest of the ensemble fit into the same collective rhythm. Their best moments often involve listening, struggling to respond, or concentrating on something that has suddenly become terribly difficult. The actors make cooperation believable without leaning on speeches about loyalty. Concern shows up in what the men do for each other, particularly when helping somebody requires them to stay focused through fear and distress.

The Iraqi family whose home becomes the soldiers’ position adds another layer of unease. For the Americans, the building is a place from which to carry out an assignment. For the family, it is their living space, now occupied by armed men and exposed to violence. The film does not need to step away from the central incident to make that distinction register. Their frightened presence changes how we see the rooms and the activity inside them. Although they remain less developed than the soldiers, they prevent the location from feeling like an anonymous battlefield built only to contain American suffering.

The same restraint applies to the wider political circumstances. Explaining the Iraq War is not what Warfare sets out to do, and treating that absence as a failure would mean judging it against a different film. Its purpose is to reconstruct the teams’ experience as it unfolds, not interrupt it with hindsight or historical explanation. The more useful question is whether that reconstruction feels coherent and immediate. For the most part, it does. The restricted perspective keeps us alongside the men as their options narrow, making the next instruction, movement, or decision more urgent than anything outside the moment.

Even with some emotional distance between the audience and individual characters, Warfare is an impressive piece of filmmaking. Its precision, ensemble performances, and punishing sound design make survival feel like something achieved through exhausting, imperfect effort rather than heroic inevitability. The lack of conventional backstories sometimes limits our attachment, but the men’s dependence on one another gives the film its emotional center. Mendoza and Garland refuse the easy satisfaction of turning endurance into triumph. When the fighting finally loosens its grip, the film leaves behind no comfortable sense that anyone has won. Getting out alive is the ending, not the happy ending.

Film Review: All Quiet on the Western Front (dir. by Edward Berger)


“My son was killed in the war. He doesn’t feel any honor.” — Matthias Erzberger

A clean uniform can hide a terrible history. In Edward Berger’s All Quiet on the Western Front (2022), clothing stripped from a dead soldier is repaired and handed to a new recruit, turning an ordinary military supply process into something chilling. That image captures the film’s outlook before its young protagonist understands what awaits him: the army needs another body, and his will do. This German anti-war film, adapted from Erich Maria Remarque’s 1929 novel of the same name, is the book’s third film adaptation. Berger makes it a harsh, absorbing experience that dismantles the comforting idea that battlefield suffering automatically produces honor. The uniform might look ready for a fresh beginning, but the audience already knows it belongs to a cycle.

The new recruit is Paul Bäumer, played by Felix Kammerer, a teenager who joins the German army alongside his friends during World War I. They are swept up in patriotic excitement and the promise that military service will transform them into men worth admiring. Their eagerness is uncomfortable because it feels so ordinary. They want adventure, acceptance, and a chance to prove themselves. Going together also makes the decision seem less frightening: each boy’s enthusiasm validates the others. Berger treats those desires with sympathy while showing how easily authority figures exploit them. The boys are encouraged to imagine their triumphant return, not the possibility that someone else might eventually wear their uniforms. The recruitment rhetoric works by giving them a flattering picture of themselves and leaving the actual experience of fighting conveniently out of view.

Once they reach the front, the gap between those promises and reality becomes impossible to ignore. There is no graceful transition from innocence to experience, just a violent introduction to mud, shellfire, hunger, and panic. The young men who dreamed of glory and honor quickly become disillusioned with both. Fighting for their country becomes less immediate than finding shelter or keeping a friend alive. This is the foundation of the film’s anti-war message: the grand ideas that make war appealing from a distance become useless to the people forced to endure it up close. What makes that change especially upsetting is that their disillusionment offers no escape. Realizing they have been misled does not release them from service or restore their safety. They must keep participating in something they can no longer understand in the terms they were taught.

Kammerer makes Paul’s changing state of mind visible without relying on long speeches. At first, his face has the openness of someone expecting the world to reward his enthusiasm. Gradually, that expression gives way to shock, exhaustion, and a stare that seems unable to absorb another terrible sight. What works especially well is that Paul never becomes a polished action hero. Learning to survive does not look empowering. It looks like a frightened person adjusting to conditions nobody should have to accept. His growing ability to function in battle comes with a disturbing emotional cost, and the film refuses to present that cost as a badge of maturity. When his fear or compassion breaks through, we see the distance between the soldier he must become and the young man he might otherwise have remained.

The friendship between Paul and the older soldier Stanislaus “Kat” Katczinsky gives that struggle emotional weight. Played by Albrecht Schuch, Kat offers practical knowledge and companionship rather than reassuring speeches. He understands the front better than Paul, but experience does not make him immune to its dangers. Their shared efforts to find food and enjoy brief moments of normality are among the film’s most affecting scenes. These passages show that the soldiers still have appetites, humor, and a need for company; they are not simply faces waiting for the next catastrophe. Kat’s care also provides a revealing contrast with the authority figures who encouraged Paul to enlist. Where those men offered abstract promises about duty, Kat responds to immediate human needs. His loyalty means something because it involves helping an actual person rather than praising an idea.

Those quieter moments are also essential to the film’s rhythm. Relentless violence can eventually become numbing, especially when each sequence seems determined to surpass the last in brutality. By allowing the characters to eat, talk, and briefly relax, Berger gives the audience something beyond suffering to hold onto. We understand what the soldiers are trying to preserve, even when their hopes have become very small. A meal matters because hunger is constant; companionship matters because isolation would make the fear harder to bear. The film is most emotionally convincing when it recognizes that ordinary comforts do not become trivial during a catastrophe. They become more precious.

Berger’s handling of combat is forceful and often terrifying. Soldiers appear painfully exposed against artillery, tanks, and weapons that kill on a scale individual bravery cannot overcome. The battlefield rarely feels like a place where determination guarantees success. More often, survival seems arbitrary. That choice matters because war films can condemn violence in dialogue while making it exhilarating to watch. Here, the confusion and physical ugliness usually overwhelm any excitement. You might admire how a sequence is constructed, but the film gives you little reason to wish you were inside it. Courage does not make the machinery less merciless, and one person’s resolve cannot turn an overwhelming assault into a fair contest. The imbalance between vulnerable bodies and industrial weapons makes the earlier promises of individual glory seem particularly dishonest.

The visual polish does create a complication, though. Some images are so striking that their beauty briefly competes with the horror they contain. Ruined landscapes and carefully composed shots can pull attention toward the filmmaking itself. That does not cancel the film’s message, but it raises a question about how to show war without making it visually seductive. Berger does not completely solve that problem. At times, the scale and precision invite admiration when the emotional situation seems to demand revulsion. Still, the overall effect is exhausting rather than glamorous. The images may be impressive, but the lives within them look miserable, precarious, and increasingly stripped of choice. There is little sense that participating in this spectacle would offer the excitement that watching its construction might briefly suggest.

The film becomes most devastating when it narrows its focus to Paul and a French soldier he has stabbed in a crater. Suddenly, the enemy is not a distant shape or a threatening uniform. He is a suffering person Paul cannot escape looking at. Kammerer’s panic and remorse make the scene difficult to sit through, precisely because the violence has already happened and cannot be undone. Paul’s attempts to help are heartbreaking because they expose a contradiction he cannot resolve: the person he was expected to attack is also someone he desperately wants to save. The scene brings the film’s argument out of the realm of mass destruction and into an intimate encounter. One man’s suffering becomes enough to reveal the moral damage that enormous casualty figures can leave strangely abstract.

It also complicates any easy division between innocent victim and violent participant. Paul has been manipulated and traumatized, but he is still capable of inflicting terrible harm. The film does not need to deny either truth to make him sympathetic. Instead, it shows how war places people in situations where survival and conscience can pull in opposite directions. The patriotic language that brought Paul here has nothing useful to say about the man dying beside him. There is no satisfying victory in the encounter, no emotional reward for having overcome an enemy. There is only the awful discovery that doing what the battlefield demands can leave a person unable to live comfortably with himself.

A separate storyline involving armistice negotiations expands the perspective beyond Paul’s experience. Daniel Brühl plays German representative Matthias Erzberger, and these scenes emphasize the distance between discussions about ending the war and the continuing deaths on the battlefield. The contrast is effective because peace is not merely a historical outcome for the soldiers; its timing determines whether they survive. Every delay has a different meaning for someone under fire than it does for someone seated at a negotiating table. Still, the shifts sometimes interrupt the intense connection with Paul. The film gains a broader view of power and responsibility, but loses some of the confinement that makes the trench scenes so immediate.

A commander’s obsession with glory near the ceasefire is similarly blunt. His decisions sharpen the criticism of military authority, but he can feel more like the embodiment of an argument than a fully developed person. By this point, the audience hardly needs another demonstration that prestige matters more to some leaders than their soldiers’ lives. Even so, his role completes a bitter connection with the recruitment scenes. The young men have abandoned their fantasies of honor because experience has exposed those fantasies as empty. The authority figure can continue believing in them because others bear the consequences. What sounded inspiring at the beginning becomes openly grotesque when used to justify further deaths.

Even with those weaknesses, All Quiet on the Western Front leaves a powerful impression because it never offers suffering as adequate compensation for lost youth. Paul’s experience is not an inspiring journey toward greatness; it is the destruction of possibilities he barely had time to imagine. By the end, that recycled uniform feels like more than an effective opening image. It represents a system capable of replacing a soldier without confronting the person it has erased. Berger’s film is angry, sometimes overly emphatic, and deeply upsetting. Its strongest accusation is also its simplest: the people selling war’s rewards are rarely the ones required to discover how empty those rewards can be.

Film Review: Breaker Morant (dir. by Bruce Beresford)


“They have to apologize for their damned war. They’re trying to end it now, so they need scapegoats.” — Harry Morant

The most disturbing thing about Breaker Morant isn’t that soldiers commit terrible acts during wartime. It’s how smoothly the people running the war can turn those soldiers into a problem to be disposed of. Bruce Beresford’s 1980 film looks at what happens when military necessity stops being a useful excuse and starts becoming a political embarrassment. It’s a courtroom drama, a war film, and a bitter examination of loyalty, held together by performances that keep its arguments from becoming abstract. What makes it compelling is the uncomfortable possibility that the men on trial are both responsible for their actions and being betrayed by their commanders.

Set during the Boer War, the story follows Harry “Breaker” Morant, Peter Handcock, and George Witton, three lieutenants facing a British military court over the killing of prisoners and a German missionary. Their defense is that they operated under orders that encouraged taking no prisoners, although those instructions conveniently lack the documentation needed to protect them. Assigned to defend them, Major J. F. Thomas finds himself fighting more than the prosecution’s evidence. He’s up against a military establishment whose political interests seem to require a particular outcome. The suspense comes less from discovering what happened than from wondering whether the court will acknowledge the circumstances surrounding it.

Beresford handles that material with an understated confidence. He doesn’t turn every exchange into a grand confrontation or bury the drama beneath swelling emotion. Instead, he lets the courtroom’s procedures become quietly suffocating. Questions, objections, and carefully phrased answers gradually reveal how much power rests with whoever controls the terms of the discussion. The flashbacks open up the film visually while complicating the testimony. Outside the courtroom, decisions emerge from exhaustion, anger, retaliation, and uncertainty. Inside it, those same decisions are discussed as though they occurred under conditions of perfect clarity. The contrast exposes the distance between fighting a war and explaining one afterward.

Edward Woodward gives Morant the combination of charisma and severity that the role needs. His Morant is articulate, proud, and capable of bitter humor, but there’s something stubbornly closed off about him too. Woodward never makes him so agreeable that the audience can comfortably overlook what he has done. At times, his confidence feels like courage; at others, it looks like a refusal to face the full meaning of his choices. That tension makes the performance work. We can sympathize with his predicament without being asked to believe that intelligence, charm, or mistreatment automatically makes someone morally right.

Bryan Brown’s Handcock is more openly irreverent, and his blunt humor gives the film some welcome breathing room. He has little patience for the court’s dignified performance of fairness, and Brown makes that contempt entertaining without removing the character’s darker edges. Lewis Fitz-Gerald brings a more exposed, youthful quality to Witton, emphasizing how differently the three men experience their situation. Jack Thompson, meanwhile, gives Thomas a decency that never feels sugary. His growing frustration becomes our way into the proceedings. He keeps searching for an argument that will make the court listen, even as it becomes increasingly doubtful that listening is the point.

The film’s central concern is the relationship between obedience and abandonment. Commanders demand that men finish the mission, crush resistance, and do whatever the situation supposedly requires. The practical message is that results matter more than restraint. But when those methods become difficult to defend publicly, the men carrying them out discover that their superiors’ expectations are much harder to prove than their own actions. In the film’s telling, the chain of command becomes a one-way arrangement: authority flows downward, but responsibility never travels back up. The soldiers are expected to understand what their commanders want without expecting those commanders to stand beside them afterward.

That betrayal is especially ugly because it exploits the loyalty military service depends on. Men are trained to trust their superiors and act decisively under pressure, yet afterward they may be judged as though they acted entirely independently. Breaker Morant captures the cruelty of that switch. The institution can encourage brutality through implication, tolerate it while it remains useful, and then present punishment as proof of its own moral seriousness. Discarding a few men allows everyone above them to look cleaner. Justice becomes less a full accounting of responsibility than a way of drawing a protective line around the people who still have power.

Still, the defense that the men followed orders cannot settle everything, and the film is most interesting when it leaves that discomfort intact. Killing prisoners doesn’t become acceptable because a superior encouraged it. Personal responsibility matters, even within a corrupt or hypocritical system. The troubling question is why that responsibility should stop with the men closest to the victims. Beresford makes a strong case that condemning individual crimes and examining command responsibility belong together. The defendants don’t need to be innocent for the proceedings to be compromised. Their guilt, where established, shouldn’t function as an excuse to stop asking who created the conditions in which they acted.

The film does, however, lean so heavily toward the accused that the people they killed receive much less attention. Their suffering can become background to the more fully developed suffering of the defendants. That imbalance limits the film’s moral reach, even as it strengthens its emotional pull. Its account of disputed orders and political scapegoating also needs to be understood as a dramatic interpretation rather than an unquestionable historical verdict. Yet those reservations don’t diminish the skill of the filmmaking. They make it worth watching critically, recognizing both the force of its argument and the places where its sympathies narrow our view.

By the end, the courtroom’s formalities feel more chilling than reassuring. Everyone has a role, the procedures have been observed, and the machinery can keep moving once these particular men are gone. That is what gives Breaker Morant its lasting sting. Beresford doesn’t simply show soldiers discovering that war is cruel; he shows them discovering that their own side’s loyalty has limits they were never told about. With its measured direction and deeply felt performances, the film leaves behind a bitter question: when commanders demand dirty work but refuse to own the consequences, what exactly is the honor they claim to defend?

Scene That I Love: Martin Sheen in Apocalypse Now


In this scene from 1979’s Apocalypse Now, Martin Sheen shows the intensity that not only nearly killed him when he suffered a heart attack during filming but which also served to make Francis Ford Coppola’s Vietnam epic a true classic.

I have to say that I definitely prefer this Martin Sheen to the one who shows up every few years to lecture us about democracy.

 

4 Shots From 4 Film: Special Grace Kelly Edition


4 Shots From 4 Films is just what it says it is, 4 shots from 4 of our favorite films.  As opposed to the reviews and recaps that we usually post, 4 Shots From 4 Films is all about letting the visuals do the talking.

Tomorrow would have been Grace Kelly’s 97th birthday!  It’s time for….

4 Shots From 4 Grace Kelly Films

Fourteen Hours (1951, directed by Henry Hathaway)

Fourteen Hours (1951, directed by Henry Hathaway)

Rear Window (1954, directed by Alfred Hitchcock)

Rear Window (1954, directed by Alfred Hitchcock)

To Catch A Thief (1955, directed by Alfred Hitchcock)

To Catch A Thief (1955, directed by Alfred Hitchcock)

High Society (1956, directed by Charles Walters)

High Society (1956, directed by Charles Walters)

Film Review: Paths of Glory (dir. by Stanley Kubrick)


“One way to maintain discipline is to shoot a man now and then.” — Maj. Gen. Georges Broulard

Stanley Kubrick’s Paths of Glory (1957) is a war movie with very little interest in making war look heroic. Its real target is the language that turns suffering into something supposedly noble: duty, sacrifice, honor, and, of course, glory. Those words sound impressive until you notice who gets to say them and who gets killed because of them. Starring Kirk Douglas as Colonel Dax, the film turns a failed military attack into a furious examination of institutional cruelty. What makes it so upsetting is not simply that innocent men suffer. It is that their suffering becomes useful to people who know how to make selfish decisions sound like necessary ones. Kubrick shows a world where authority protects itself first and then calls that protection patriotism.

The story takes place on the French front during World War I, where General Broulard encourages General Mireau to attack a heavily defended German position known as the Anthill. Mireau initially recognizes that the operation is unlikely to succeed. His soldiers are exhausted, the enemy is well positioned, and the expected losses are enormous. Then Broulard introduces the possibility of career advancement, and Mireau’s assessment becomes noticeably more optimistic. Nothing about the battlefield has changed. The only new factor is what Mireau might personally gain. It is an especially effective introduction because Kubrick does not need a dramatic confession of corruption. We watch a man talk himself into believing that his ambition and his military duty are conveniently the same thing.

Dax must lead the assault despite understanding how unrealistic the objective is. When the attack falls apart, the generals do not seriously reconsider the judgment that produced it. Instead, they turn the failure into a question of the soldiers’ courage. Three men are selected to face a court-martial for cowardice, with their punishment supposedly restoring discipline and defending the army’s reputation. Dax, a criminal lawyer before the war, takes on their defense. At that point, Paths of Glory shifts from a battlefield story into a courtroom drama, but the underlying conflict stays the same. The men have very little control over their lives in either setting. Whether they are ordered toward enemy guns or brought before military judges, decisions made above them determine their chances of survival.

The selection of three men for execution brings to mind the Roman military practice of decimation, in which one in ten soldiers from a disgraced unit was chosen by lot and killed to punish the group and frighten the survivors into obedience. The punishment in Paths of Glory is not literally decimation, but it operates through a similar logic: make a few men pay so everyone else gets the message. What matters is not establishing each soldier’s responsibility but demonstrating the power of command. That connection makes the court-martial feel less like a search for justice than an old form of intimidation wearing a modern uniform. The paperwork and formal proceedings do not remove the brutality. They give it an official appearance.

The story becomes even harder to dismiss when you consider its historical foundation. The film adapts Humphrey Cobb’s 1935 novel Paths of Glory, which was inspired by the Souain corporals affair. In March 1915, four French corporals were executed following a failed attack near Souain. The film uses three condemned soldiers and fictionalized characters, so it should not be treated as a literal reconstruction of that event. Still, the connection matters because it prevents the premise from feeling like cruelty invented purely for dramatic effect. The story grows out of a real example of military authority turning against its own men. Its anger is not based only on the idea that such injustice could happen, but on the knowledge that something like it did.

Honor and glory are the film’s central targets, although Kubrick is careful to separate genuine courage from the official language used to celebrate it. Dax accepts danger alongside his men and later risks his standing by defending them. Mireau, by contrast, treats honor as something that belongs to his rank and must be protected from embarrassment. Once the assault fails, the soldiers’ deaths become a way to preserve his version of events. If the men were cowards, then perhaps the plan was not the problem. Punishment offers a convenient explanation that leaves his judgment intact. The soldiers become expendable twice: first when their lives might purchase him advancement, and again when their deaths might protect him from blame.

That is what makes the film’s criticism more pointed than a general statement that war is terrible. It examines how institutions can reward the people who transfer the consequences of their decisions onto others. Mireau can describe the assault as a matter of national importance while privately responding to the possibility of promotion. He can demand executions in the name of discipline while avoiding an honest examination of his own conduct. The gap between his public explanations and personal motives is where the film finds much of its fury. Kubrick is not suggesting that ideals are automatically meaningless. He is showing how easily powerful people can borrow the language of ideals to make their own interests harder to challenge.

Broulard is arguably even more disturbing because he does not share Mireau’s obvious bluster. Adolphe Menjou plays him with a relaxed charm that makes his moral emptiness seem almost ordinary. He can discuss terrible outcomes with the ease of someone settling a minor professional disagreement. Where Mireau becomes defensive and angry, Broulard remains adaptable. He understands that careers can survive ugly situations as long as the right people are blamed and the necessary arrangements are made. His composure is frightening because it suggests experience. This is not a man overwhelmed by an exceptional moral crisis; he seems perfectly comfortable managing one.

His misunderstanding of Dax brings that attitude into sharp focus. Broulard assumes that Dax’s objections must conceal a professional ambition, as though defending the condemned men were simply an indirect way of seeking a better position. He cannot easily recognize outrage that is not part of a negotiation. That assumption tells us how thoroughly his world has been shaped by self-interest. He does not just behave cynically; he expects everyone else to do the same. Dax’s refusal to accept that logic creates a deeper conflict than a disagreement over military procedure. One man believes there are limits to what a person should do for advancement. The other barely seems to understand why anyone would impose those limits.

Douglas gives Dax the force needed to stand against these men without turning him into an unbeatable hero. His physical confidence makes him convincing as an officer, but there is also frustration beneath his authority. In the courtroom, his anger comes from recognizing that the proceedings are dishonest while still having to work within them. He argues as though evidence and reason should matter, even as the trial makes their irrelevance increasingly obvious. A more reassuring movie might allow his intelligence, courage, and powerful speeches to change the outcome. Kubrick denies us that comfort. Being able to expose an injustice is not the same as being able to stop it, especially when the people listening benefit from leaving it in place.

The courtroom scenes are devastating because the trial has the outward shape of fairness without its substance. The defendants are present, a defense is permitted, and officers sit in judgment, but those formalities do not create a meaningful opportunity for justice. Instead, they help the institution describe punishment as the result of a legitimate process. That distinction is essential to the film. The army does not simply seize three men and openly announce that their lives are convenient sacrifices. It gives their deaths a procedural explanation. Kubrick makes us watch how an institution can use the appearance of reason to conceal a decision that reason would never justify.

The condemned soldiers also keep the film from becoming only an argument between powerful officers. For the generals, they are examples, disciplinary problems, or pieces of an embarrassing situation. For the audience, they are frightened people trying to understand what is happening to them. Their reactions do not fit a single heroic pattern, and that makes their predicament more affecting. Fear does not become less real because someone wears a uniform, and facing death does not automatically produce dignity or clarity. By giving space to their distress, the film restores the individuality that the military process tries to erase. These are not interchangeable representatives of a failed attack. Each man has a life that cannot be replaced by an official explanation.

Kubrick’s visual choices reinforce these divisions without needing to announce them. The trenches are cramped, muddy spaces where bodies crowd together and danger feels close. The officers’ grand interiors offer room to walk, talk, and consider other people’s deaths at a comfortable distance. Those settings create two different experiences of the same war. For the soldiers, war is immediate and physical. For the generals, it can become a matter of reports, reputation, and carefully managed conversations. The contrast is especially bitter because the people with the most room to maneuver are the ones deciding the fate of those who have almost none.

The tracking shots through the trenches make that hierarchy feel physical. As Dax moves past his men, the camera gives a sense of the crowded human reality behind military plans. An order that sounds neat in a spacious room must eventually pass through these bodies. The assault then strips away any possibility of treating the operation as an exciting adventure. Moving forward is exhausting and dangerous, and determination cannot make the conditions less impossible. The sequence challenges the easy assumption that sufficient bravery can overcome any obstacle. Sometimes an order is simply disastrous, and blaming the men who cannot carry it out becomes another form of dishonesty.

Mireau’s attempt to have artillery fire on his own troops when they cannot advance is the clearest expression of that dishonesty. In his mind, the soldiers stop being people he is responsible for and become obstacles to his authority. Their inability to fulfill his expectations feels to him like an offense deserving punishment. The moment collapses the comforting distinction between danger from the enemy and protection from one’s own commanders. It also exposes the emptiness of his concern for military honor. If maintaining the appearance of obedience requires destroying the very men under his command, he is willing to consider it. His reputation has become more important than the purpose his authority supposedly serves.

If the film has a limitation, it is that its moral divisions can feel extremely sharp. The generals’ corruption leaves little uncertainty about where our sympathies should fall, and some dialogue makes explicit what the images and performances have already established. At times, the characters function as clear expressions of opposing moral positions. Still, that directness largely suits the material. The film is not asking us to puzzle over whether sacrificing innocent men for professional convenience might be defensible. It is asking us to sit with the fact that obvious injustice can continue even when someone names it accurately. Its bluntness gives that argument an anger that a more detached treatment might lose.

Then the final scene changes the emotional register. A frightened German woman sings before a roomful of French soldiers who initially respond with jeers. Gradually, their behavior changes. They grow quiet, listen, and begin humming along. After watching military authority reduce people to categories—cowards, officers, examples, casualties—we see a moment in which those divisions briefly loosen. The woman belongs to the enemy nation, but her vulnerability and her song reach the men in a way that official speeches have not. The scene does not suggest that suffering automatically makes people compassionate. Their first response is cruel. What matters is that they remain capable of moving beyond it.

That ending is tender without pretending to repair anything. The condemned men are not restored, the army has not become just, and Dax has not defeated the machinery around him. The song offers a brief experience of shared feeling rather than a solution. That restraint is what makes Paths of Glory so powerful. Kubrick tears apart the grand language used to justify sacrifice while refusing to treat ordinary human feeling as foolish or irrelevant. The film leaves honor looking less like a medal, a title, or a successful career than the difficult act of recognizing another person’s humanity when the institution around you finds it convenient not to.