Film Review: Rescue Dawn (dir. by Werner Herzog)


“The jungle is the prison.” — Lt. Duane Martin

Werner Herzog’s Rescue Dawn (2006) is a war movie that gets more interesting once the machinery of war falls away. Forget sweeping battlefield victories or speeches about duty. This is a film about hunger, filthy clothes, damaged feet, and the stubborn belief that tomorrow might still be worth reaching. Based on the true story of Dieter Dengler, a German-born American Navy pilot shot down over Laos during the Vietnam War, it turns an extraordinary survival ordeal into something painfully physical. It’s tense, occasionally funny, and often exhausting in exactly the way it should be. Herzog makes survival feel less like destiny than hard, miserable work.

Christian Bale plays Dengler as a man whose enthusiasm hasn’t caught up with the danger around him. Flying is his dream, and military service provides the opportunity to do it. That distinction matters: he comes across less as a born warrior than as someone whose private obsession has delivered him into a geopolitical nightmare. When his aircraft goes down, the movie abruptly strips away the protection of technology, training, and military belonging. He’s a stranded body in unfamiliar territory. Herzog doesn’t need to oversell that reversal. The distance between controlling a plane and struggling through undergrowth is dramatic enough.

Herzog had already explored Dengler’s experiences as a prisoner of war in his earlier documentary, Little Dieter Needs to Fly (1997). That film featured the real Dengler recounting his life and returning with Herzog to revisit and reenact parts of his captivity and escape. Rescue Dawn, then, isn’t a filmmaker discovering a remarkable story so much as returning to one he clearly couldn’t shake. The documentary approaches the ordeal through memory and the personality of its survivor; the dramatic feature pushes us into the immediate business of enduring it. They complement each other without feeling interchangeable, even when they cover the same terrible ground.

Bale is excellent, particularly because he doesn’t make Dengler’s determination entirely comfortable to watch. His optimism can seem inspiring one minute and almost irritating the next. You understand why a refusal to surrender might keep someone alive, but you also understand why exhausted fellow prisoners wouldn’t always welcome another bright idea. Bale gives that confidence an awkward, boyish energy rather than the polished authority of a conventional action hero. His physical commitment is obvious, but the performance works because there’s a recognizable personality beneath the deterioration. We aren’t just watching an actor become thinner and dirtier. We’re watching someone fight to preserve his sense of possibility.

The prison-camp scenes are where the film really tightens its grip. Confinement isn’t presented as one continuous burst of dramatic suffering. It’s repetition, boredom, discomfort, and the effort of living alongside people whose nerves have already been rubbed raw. Conversations circle around escape, food, and whether any plan has a realistic chance of working. Small disagreements acquire enormous weight because nobody has the space or freedom to walk away. Herzog understands that suspense can come from waiting as much as action. A whispered discussion or a moment of hesitation can feel more dangerous than a loud confrontation, because everything depends on people who are already close to breaking.

Steve Zahn, playing fellow prisoner Duane, supplies much of the film’s emotional force. There’s something devastating about how little protection the performance gives him. He looks frightened, depleted, and increasingly dependent on the fragile connection he forms with Dieter. Their companionship never becomes a sentimental buddy-movie routine; it’s more basic and more moving than that. Having another person beside you means there’s still someone to speak to, help, and keep going for. Jeremy Davies brings a different kind of strain to Gene, whose resistance to Dieter’s plans makes the group dynamic prickly. Together, the performances prevent captivity from becoming merely a showcase for Bale.

Then there’s the jungle, which Herzog films without turning it into either a postcard or a supernatural villain. It’s beautiful, certainly, but that beauty offers absolutely no reassurance. Water, thick vegetation, steep ground, and the simple difficulty of finding a way forward make every movement costly. Escape doesn’t suddenly open the movie into freedom; it exchanges one form of imprisonment for another. That’s the nasty little truth at the center of Rescue Dawn: getting beyond the guards doesn’t mean getting beyond danger. The landscape has no interest in rewarding courage, and Herzog is very good at making that indifference feel enormous.

What I like most is how practical the film remains. Survival isn’t an abstract test of the human spirit conducted somewhere above ordinary bodily needs. It means finding something to eat, deciding when to move, and scraping together enough strength for another stretch of ground. Even the more startling moments work because they belong to that material world. Herzog doesn’t constantly stop to announce how profound it all is. He lets the accumulation of discomfort do the talking. The result is an adventure film in which adventure has been stripped of most of its glamour, leaving ingenuity, terror, and occasional absurdity behind.

That said, the film’s narrow focus has limitations. The surrounding war receives far less attention than Dieter’s ordeal, and the people holding him captive rarely gain the interior complexity granted to the Americans. That imbalance makes the survival narrative direct and accessible, but it also leaves parts of its human landscape frustratingly thin. There’s a difference between sticking closely to one man’s experience and allowing everyone outside it to remain a threatening outline. Rescue Dawn doesn’t always negotiate that difference gracefully. Its emotional clarity comes partly from simplification, and viewers wanting a broader reckoning with the conflict may find that approach restrictive.

The ending also nudges toward a more familiar kind of uplift than the preceding ordeal seems to promise. After so much uncertainty and physical misery, the movement toward celebration feels almost too tidy. Still, it would be unfair to mistake the film for an uncomplicated victory lap. What lingers is not military triumph but the unsettling distance between a person’s determination and the world’s complete lack of concern. Rescue Dawn is gripping because Herzog respects both sides of that equation. Dieter’s will matters enormously, but it doesn’t magically make him safe. As a survival drama, the film is tough, absorbing, and deeply humane; as a portrait of optimism under unbearable pressure, it’s even better.

Film Review: Rescue Dawn (dir by Werner Herzog)


Dieter Dengler (Christian Bale) has been obsessed with flying ever since he was a child in Germany.  Towards the end of World War II, while his native country burned around him, Dieter would stare up at the skies and watch the American planes fly overhead and he knew that was not only what he wanted to do someday but also who he wanted to do it for.  Jump forward two decades, to 1966.  Dengler is now a lieutenant in the U.S. Air Force, an always smiling optimist who is considered to be something of a wild man.  When Dengler is reported as having been shot down over Loas, his fellow pilots are not only convinced that Dengler survived but that he’ll also eventually escape captivity.  Why?  Because they now Dieter Dengler is not the type to give up.

And they’re right.  Dengler not only survives the crash but he also survives in the wild.  After growing up in the rubble of Germany, Dengler is confident that he can survive anything.  Even when he’s finally captured by communist rebels, Dengler remains optimistic that he’ll make it back home.  When he’s told that he can go free if he signs a statement denouncing the United States, he refuses.  Dengler’s not going to turn on the country that allows him to fly.  Dengler soon finds himself being held in a POW camp with four other men, including two other Americans (played by Jeremy Davies and Steve Zahn).  The guards are determined to break Dengler but he’s just as determined to escape.  Hearing that it’s impossible to do so only makes Dengler more determined.

The story of Dieter Dengler and his eventual escape from captivity was originally told, by Dengler himself, in Werner Herzog’s 1997 documentary, Little Dieter Needs To Fly.  That Herzog saw Dengler as a kindred spirit is evident in the fact that, 9 years after the documentary, Herzog again told Dengler’s story in the 2006 film, Rescue Dawn.

On the face of it, a story about a group of Americans escaping from a POW camp might sound like an unlikely topic for a Werner Herzog film but it doesn’t take long for Herzog to put his own distinctive stamp on the project.  As played by Bale, Dengler is another one of Herzog’s obessessive heroes.  Dengler’s obsession is not just with flying but also with being free.  For Dengler, that’s what being an American means and that’s why he would rather be tortured than sign a simple piece of paper denying the existence of that freedom.  Much as how Grizzly Man portrayed Timothy Treadwell as being a man who would rather be eaten by a bear than live a life that’s been dictated by others, Dengler would rather suffer than betray his adopted country.

Rescue Dawn also centers around another common Herzog theme, the pitilessness of nature.  Watching Dengler trying to make his way through the jungle, we’re reminded that nature will always win in the end.  In Herzog’s world, neither nature nor the universe as a whole has any ideology.  Long after every warrior has died, the film tells us, nature will still be there.  The one thing that the POWs and their captors have in common is that they’re all at the mercy of the chaos of nature.  Just as the jungle threatens to swallow up Dengler and the other prisoners, their captors are slowly starving to death due to a drought.  As filmed by Herzog, the jungle is both beautiful and overwhelming.  Even at the film’s triumphant conclusion, it’s hard not to feel that, for all the planning, Dengler’s escape and survival was due to the random chaos of the universe.  How much can we control and how much must we simply leave up to the whim of nature?

Bale, Davies, and Zahn all give excellent performances and Herzog keeps the story moving quickly.  It’s probably one of his most emotionally accessible films and it’s impossible not to shed a tear at that final scene.  That said, I’d be remiss if I didn’t acknowledge that there’s a good deal of controversy about the way that Rescue Dawn portrays Gene DeBruin, the POW played by Jeremy Davies.  The film often contrasts Dengler with DeBruin.  If Dengler is always hopeful and determined, DeBruin is portrayed as being unstable and unreliable.  However, by most accounts — including the one given by another one of the prisoners — DeBruin was actually the exact opposite of how he was portrayed in the film.  Instead of being selfish, he was a source of strength for the POWs and he actually refused to take advantage of a previous chance to escape because it would have meant abandoning the rest of the prisoners.  Herzog has said that he wasn’t aware of DeBruin’s heroism when he wrote and directed the film and that he now regrets the way that DeBruin was portrayed.  (DeBruin’s brother has said that Herzog refused to talk to the family while the film was in poduction.)  Rescue Dawn is a well-made and wonderfully acted film and it’s one that always brings tears to my mismatched eyes but, while watching it, it’s impossible not to regret the injustice that was done to Gene DeBruin.