Lisa Marie Takes A Look At Survivor 51.9 “Wilder Than A Cat In A Bathtub”


Welcome to Open Era Survivor! This is the era where one of the only likable people in the game can get sent to the jury because they lost a freaking coin flip.

No, I’m not happy that Lewis is gone. I’ve made it pretty clear from the start that Lewis was my favorite, so it’s not easy accepting that he has no chance of winning while wastes of space like Eric, Mike, and Christian remain in the game. Over the past three episodes, Brady, Kristen, Kilby, and now Lewis have been voted out. Now, I’m not a fan of all of those people, but it’s still hard not to feel as if, post-merge, we’ve been losing the most interesting people on the beach.

Now, I will say that Lewis was probably going to go no matter what. He was simply too good at challenges and everyone on the tribe had noticed. It really was one of those cases where I think the majority of the castaways would have said, “If we don’t get rid of him now, we might not get another chance.” I would have been upset if Lewis had been voted out, but at least I could have understood it. But eliminating a player—any player—with a freaking coin toss? No, that sucks.

As a producer as well as a host, Jeff Probst loves his twists and his idols and his gimmicks. I’m not a fan of most of them. I hate the Top 4 firemaking challenge. I’m still pissed off that Chris Underwood won Survivor: Edge of Extinction because he was allowed to re-enter the game at the last minute. I hate the summit meetings and all the rest of the post-COVID era crap that’s been brought into this game. In the future, I predict Jeff will disavow the coin toss in much the same way that he now disavows the hourglass twist from seasons 41 and 42.

Now, I will admit that Lewis did make the choice to flip the coin. It was a dumb decision. Lewis should have let Devin flip it. And if Devin had flipped it and guessed wrong, I might not be as upset as I am about Lewis doing it. Devin is a lot more annoying than Lewis and, despite my distaste for the gimmick, I would be a lot happier today if a coin toss resulted in me not having to listen to any more of his psychobabble for the rest of the season. Then again, Devin isn’t the only person guilty of psychobabble this season. Devin, Jelly, Eric, Christian, Maggie, and Mike all have a tendency to talk a lot without actually saying anything. One could also say the same of Brady, Kristen, and Kilby. This is a season of psychobabble.

You know who doesn’t engage in nonstop psychobabble? Carter. With Lewis gone, I’m now fully on Team Carter.

Woo hoo, Carter!

Don’t screw this up.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.