Film Review: All Quiet on the Western Front (dir. by Edward Berger)


“My son was killed in the war. He doesn’t feel any honor.” — Matthias Erzberger

A clean uniform can hide a terrible history. In Edward Berger’s All Quiet on the Western Front (2022), clothing stripped from a dead soldier is repaired and handed to a new recruit, turning an ordinary military supply process into something chilling. That image captures the film’s outlook before its young protagonist understands what awaits him: the army needs another body, and his will do. This German anti-war film, adapted from Erich Maria Remarque’s 1929 novel of the same name, is the book’s third film adaptation. Berger makes it a harsh, absorbing experience that dismantles the comforting idea that battlefield suffering automatically produces honor. The uniform might look ready for a fresh beginning, but the audience already knows it belongs to a cycle.

The new recruit is Paul Bäumer, played by Felix Kammerer, a teenager who joins the German army alongside his friends during World War I. They are swept up in patriotic excitement and the promise that military service will transform them into men worth admiring. Their eagerness is uncomfortable because it feels so ordinary. They want adventure, acceptance, and a chance to prove themselves. Going together also makes the decision seem less frightening: each boy’s enthusiasm validates the others. Berger treats those desires with sympathy while showing how easily authority figures exploit them. The boys are encouraged to imagine their triumphant return, not the possibility that someone else might eventually wear their uniforms. The recruitment rhetoric works by giving them a flattering picture of themselves and leaving the actual experience of fighting conveniently out of view.

Once they reach the front, the gap between those promises and reality becomes impossible to ignore. There is no graceful transition from innocence to experience, just a violent introduction to mud, shellfire, hunger, and panic. The young men who dreamed of glory and honor quickly become disillusioned with both. Fighting for their country becomes less immediate than finding shelter or keeping a friend alive. This is the foundation of the film’s anti-war message: the grand ideas that make war appealing from a distance become useless to the people forced to endure it up close. What makes that change especially upsetting is that their disillusionment offers no escape. Realizing they have been misled does not release them from service or restore their safety. They must keep participating in something they can no longer understand in the terms they were taught.

Kammerer makes Paul’s changing state of mind visible without relying on long speeches. At first, his face has the openness of someone expecting the world to reward his enthusiasm. Gradually, that expression gives way to shock, exhaustion, and a stare that seems unable to absorb another terrible sight. What works especially well is that Paul never becomes a polished action hero. Learning to survive does not look empowering. It looks like a frightened person adjusting to conditions nobody should have to accept. His growing ability to function in battle comes with a disturbing emotional cost, and the film refuses to present that cost as a badge of maturity. When his fear or compassion breaks through, we see the distance between the soldier he must become and the young man he might otherwise have remained.

The friendship between Paul and the older soldier Stanislaus “Kat” Katczinsky gives that struggle emotional weight. Played by Albrecht Schuch, Kat offers practical knowledge and companionship rather than reassuring speeches. He understands the front better than Paul, but experience does not make him immune to its dangers. Their shared efforts to find food and enjoy brief moments of normality are among the film’s most affecting scenes. These passages show that the soldiers still have appetites, humor, and a need for company; they are not simply faces waiting for the next catastrophe. Kat’s care also provides a revealing contrast with the authority figures who encouraged Paul to enlist. Where those men offered abstract promises about duty, Kat responds to immediate human needs. His loyalty means something because it involves helping an actual person rather than praising an idea.

Those quieter moments are also essential to the film’s rhythm. Relentless violence can eventually become numbing, especially when each sequence seems determined to surpass the last in brutality. By allowing the characters to eat, talk, and briefly relax, Berger gives the audience something beyond suffering to hold onto. We understand what the soldiers are trying to preserve, even when their hopes have become very small. A meal matters because hunger is constant; companionship matters because isolation would make the fear harder to bear. The film is most emotionally convincing when it recognizes that ordinary comforts do not become trivial during a catastrophe. They become more precious.

Berger’s handling of combat is forceful and often terrifying. Soldiers appear painfully exposed against artillery, tanks, and weapons that kill on a scale individual bravery cannot overcome. The battlefield rarely feels like a place where determination guarantees success. More often, survival seems arbitrary. That choice matters because war films can condemn violence in dialogue while making it exhilarating to watch. Here, the confusion and physical ugliness usually overwhelm any excitement. You might admire how a sequence is constructed, but the film gives you little reason to wish you were inside it. Courage does not make the machinery less merciless, and one person’s resolve cannot turn an overwhelming assault into a fair contest. The imbalance between vulnerable bodies and industrial weapons makes the earlier promises of individual glory seem particularly dishonest.

The visual polish does create a complication, though. Some images are so striking that their beauty briefly competes with the horror they contain. Ruined landscapes and carefully composed shots can pull attention toward the filmmaking itself. That does not cancel the film’s message, but it raises a question about how to show war without making it visually seductive. Berger does not completely solve that problem. At times, the scale and precision invite admiration when the emotional situation seems to demand revulsion. Still, the overall effect is exhausting rather than glamorous. The images may be impressive, but the lives within them look miserable, precarious, and increasingly stripped of choice. There is little sense that participating in this spectacle would offer the excitement that watching its construction might briefly suggest.

The film becomes most devastating when it narrows its focus to Paul and a French soldier he has stabbed in a crater. Suddenly, the enemy is not a distant shape or a threatening uniform. He is a suffering person Paul cannot escape looking at. Kammerer’s panic and remorse make the scene difficult to sit through, precisely because the violence has already happened and cannot be undone. Paul’s attempts to help are heartbreaking because they expose a contradiction he cannot resolve: the person he was expected to attack is also someone he desperately wants to save. The scene brings the film’s argument out of the realm of mass destruction and into an intimate encounter. One man’s suffering becomes enough to reveal the moral damage that enormous casualty figures can leave strangely abstract.

It also complicates any easy division between innocent victim and violent participant. Paul has been manipulated and traumatized, but he is still capable of inflicting terrible harm. The film does not need to deny either truth to make him sympathetic. Instead, it shows how war places people in situations where survival and conscience can pull in opposite directions. The patriotic language that brought Paul here has nothing useful to say about the man dying beside him. There is no satisfying victory in the encounter, no emotional reward for having overcome an enemy. There is only the awful discovery that doing what the battlefield demands can leave a person unable to live comfortably with himself.

A separate storyline involving armistice negotiations expands the perspective beyond Paul’s experience. Daniel Brühl plays German representative Matthias Erzberger, and these scenes emphasize the distance between discussions about ending the war and the continuing deaths on the battlefield. The contrast is effective because peace is not merely a historical outcome for the soldiers; its timing determines whether they survive. Every delay has a different meaning for someone under fire than it does for someone seated at a negotiating table. Still, the shifts sometimes interrupt the intense connection with Paul. The film gains a broader view of power and responsibility, but loses some of the confinement that makes the trench scenes so immediate.

A commander’s obsession with glory near the ceasefire is similarly blunt. His decisions sharpen the criticism of military authority, but he can feel more like the embodiment of an argument than a fully developed person. By this point, the audience hardly needs another demonstration that prestige matters more to some leaders than their soldiers’ lives. Even so, his role completes a bitter connection with the recruitment scenes. The young men have abandoned their fantasies of honor because experience has exposed those fantasies as empty. The authority figure can continue believing in them because others bear the consequences. What sounded inspiring at the beginning becomes openly grotesque when used to justify further deaths.

Even with those weaknesses, All Quiet on the Western Front leaves a powerful impression because it never offers suffering as adequate compensation for lost youth. Paul’s experience is not an inspiring journey toward greatness; it is the destruction of possibilities he barely had time to imagine. By the end, that recycled uniform feels like more than an effective opening image. It represents a system capable of replacing a soldier without confronting the person it has erased. Berger’s film is angry, sometimes overly emphatic, and deeply upsetting. Its strongest accusation is also its simplest: the people selling war’s rewards are rarely the ones required to discover how empty those rewards can be.

Review: Frankenstein (dir. by Guillermo Del Toro)


“An idea, a feeling became clear to me. The hunter did not hate the wolf. The wolf did not hate the sheep. But violence felt inevitable between them. Perhaps, I thought, this was the way of the world. It would hunt you and kill you just for being who you are.” — the Creature

Guillermo del Toro’s long-awaited take on Frankenstein finally lumbers to life after years of speculation and teases, and it’s every bit the dark, hypnotic fever dream you’d expect from his imagination. The film, a Netflix-backed production running close to two and a half hours, stars Oscar Isaac as the guilt-ridden Victor Frankenstein and Jacob Elordi as his tragic creation. The result lands somewhere between Gothic melodrama and spiritual lament—a lush, melancholy epic about fathers, sons, and the price of neglect. It’s both a triumph of aesthetic world-building and a case study in overindulgence, the kind of movie that leaves you haunted even when it occasionally tests your patience.

From the very first frame, del Toro plunges us into a Europe steeped in rot and beauty. His world feels more haunted than alive—every misty street lamp and echoing corridor loaded with centuries of decay. Victor, introduced as both a visionary and a failed son, is shaped by years of cruelty at the hands of his domineering father, played with aristocratic venom by Charles Dance. That upbringing lingers in every decision he makes, especially when he turns to science to defy death. Del Toro shoots his laboratory scenes as though they were sacred rituals: the flicker of candlelight reflecting off glass jars, the close-up of trembling hands threading sinew into flesh. When the Creature awakens, lightning cracks like some divine act of punishment. It’s a birth scene that feels more emotional than monstrous—Elordi’s raw, wordless confusion gives it a painful tenderness that lingers longer than the horror. Del Toro discards the usual clichés of flat heads and neck bolts, opting for something far more human: an imperfect body full of scars and stitched reminders of mortality.

One of the most striking choices del Toro makes is reframing Victor and the Creature as mirror images rather than opposites. Instead of playing Victor as a simple mad scientist, del Toro paints him as a broken man desperate to reclaim the control he never had as a child. That fear and obsession ripple through the Creature, who becomes his unacknowledged shadow—an extension of Victor’s failure to love or take responsibility. The movie often frames the two in parallel shots, their movements synchronized across different spaces, suggesting that creator and creation are locked in a tragic loop. The audience watches both sides of the story—Victor’s guilt and the Creature’s anguish—without clear moral lines. This emotional split gives the film its heartbeat: the Creature isn’t a villain so much as a rejected child, articulate and lonely, begging to know why he was made to suffer.

Jacob Elordi’s performance is revelatory. He channels something hauntingly human beneath the layers of prosthetics and makeup. There’s a fragility to the way he moves—those long, uncertain gestures feel less like a monster testing its strength and more like someone trying to exist in a world that never wanted him. His eyes carry the movie’s emotional weight; the moment he sees his reflection for the first time is quietly devastating. Oscar Isaac, meanwhile, leans hard into Victor’s manic idealism, all sweat-soaked ambition and buried grief. He makes the character compelling even at his most despicable, though at times del Toro’s dialogue spells out Victor’s torment too bluntly. Still, the scenes between them—particularly their tense reunion in the frozen north—achieve the Shakespearean tragedy that del Toro clearly aims for.

Visually, Frankenstein is pure del Toro—sumptuous, grotesque, and alive in every corner of its composition. Each frame looks painted rather than filmed: flickers of gaslight reflecting on wet marble, glass jars filled with organs that seem to breathe, snow settling gently on slate rooftops. The film feels drenched in the texture of another century, yet vibrates with modern energy. Costume designer Kate Hawley, longtime collaborator of del Toro, deserves special recognition here. Her work helps define the story’s emotional tone, dressing Victor in meticulously tailored waistcoats that hint at obsession through precision, and the Creature in tattered fabrics that seem scavenged from several lives. Elizabeth’s gowns chart her erosion from warmth to mourning, using color and texture as silent narration. Hawley’s palette moves from opulent golds and creams to bleak greys and winter blues—visually tracing how ambition and grief drain the light from these characters’ worlds. The costumes, much like del Toro’s sets, feel alive with history, heavy with stories stitched into every seam.

Mia Goth gives a strong, if underused, turn as Elizabeth, Victor’s doomed fiancée. Her early scenes bring a spark of warmth to the story’s coldness; her later ones turn tragic in ways that push Victor toward his final breakdown. Minor characters—the townspeople, the academics, the curious aristocrats who toy with Victor’s discovery—carry familiar del Toro trademarks: grotesque faces, eccentric manners, glimmers of compassion buried in callousness. The composer’s score matches this tone perfectly, alternating between aching melodies on piano and surging orchestral crescendos that make even the quiet scenes feel mythic. Combined, the sound and visuals give Frankenstein a grandeur that most modern horror films wouldn’t dare attempt.

Still, not every gamble lands cleanly. Del Toro’s interpretation leans so hard into empathy that it dulls the edges of the original story’s moral conflict. Shelley’s Creature grows into a murderous intellect, acting out of vengeance as much as sorrow; here, his violence is softened or implied, as though del Toro can’t quite bring himself to stain the monster’s purity. The effect is powerful emotionally but flattens some of the tension—Victor becomes the clear villain, and the Creature, the clear victim. It fits del Toro’s worldview but leaves the viewer missing some ambiguity. The pacing also falters in the middle third. There are long, ornate monologues about divinity, creation, and guilt that blur together into a swirl of purple prose. The visuals never lose their grip, but the script occasionally does, especially when it slows down to explain what the imagery already tells us.

Those fits of overexplanation aside, del Toro’s Frankenstein stays deeply personal. The story connects directly to the themes he’s mined for years: innocence cursed by cruelty, love framed in pain, beauty stitched from the broken. The Creature isn’t just man made from corpses; he’s a kind of prayer for grace—a plea for understanding in a world defined by rejection. Victor’s failure to nurture becomes an act of spiritual cowardice rather than scientific arrogance. The parallels between them give the film its emotional voltage. Every time one character suffers, the other feels it by proxy, as if their bond transcends life and death.

By the final act, all the grand tragedy is distilled into the silence between two beings who can’t forgive each other—but can’t let go, either. The closing image of the Creature, trudging across a barren arctic plain beneath a rising sun, borders on mythic. His tear-streaked face and quiet acceptance of solitude bring the story full circle: a being born of man’s arrogance chooses forgiveness when his maker couldn’t. It’s sad, tender, and surprisingly spiritual, hinting at del Toro’s constant fascination with mercy in a cruel universe.

As a whole, Frankenstein feels like the culmination of del Toro’s career obsessions condensed into one sprawling film. It’s not perfect—it wanders, it sermonizes, and it sometimes sacrifices fear for sentiment—but it’s haunted by sincerity. You can see del Toro’s fingerprints in every gothic curve and crimson hue, and even when he overreaches, you believe in his conviction. Isaac anchors the film with burning intensity, Elordi gives it wounded humanity, and Goth tempers the heaviness with grace.

In the end, this version of Frankenstein isn’t about horror in the traditional sense. It’s not there to make you jump—it’s there to make you ache. The film trades sharp scares for bruised hearts, replacing terror with empathy. Del Toro reanimates not just flesh but feeling, dragging one of literature’s oldest monsters into our modern reckoning with parenthood, grief, and the burden of creation. It’s daring, messy, and undeniably alive. For better or worse, it’s exactly the Frankenstein Guillermo del Toro was always meant to make.

Horror Trailer: Frankenstein


The official trailer for Guillermo Del Toro’s take on the Mary Shelley’s classic gothic horror Frankenstein has finally been released.

An earlier teaser was sent out months ago, but that was mostly played off like sizzle reel of what Del Toro had been up to with this latest adaptation. This official trailer gives us a much more closer look at the type of adaptation Del Toro decided to take with Shelley’s novel of the tortured scientist and his creation.

Even though it will be show up on Netflix on November 7, 2025, I do believe that this film needs to be seen on the big screen when a select cities get them on October 17, 2025.

International Film Review: All Quiet On The Western Front (dir by Edward Berger)


From the first scene of Germany’s All Quiet On The Western Front, it’s made clear that there is no glamour or romance to war.

The year is 1917 and the Great War (or World War I as future historians will call it) has been underway for three years.  On the Western Front, soldiers hide in trenches and wait for the inevitable order to try to advance to the next set of trenches.  Most of the soldiers are cut down by machine gun fire and explosions as soon as they go over the top.  Many more are killed as they try to run across the killing field.    We are introduced to one soldier who has been ordered to charge.  Within a few minutes, he is dead and his uniform has been taken, washed, and sewn up so that it can be given to whoever will be the next to enlist.  The whole process plays out with a disturbing efficiency.  That several men have just died in a attack that seems to lack any strategic purpose does not matter.  What matters is that the uniform be ready to be worn by whoever follows.

The uniform is next handed to Paul (Felix Kammerer), a 17 year-old who not only enlists in the Imperial Germany Army but who plays a key role in convincing his friends to enlist as well.  Paul has been moved by the patriotic speeches that he heard from his teachers.  He expects war to be an adventure.  Upon their arrival on the Western Front, Paul and his friends are surrounded by death.  With their uniforms on and their gas masks over their faces, they are nearly unrecognizable as individuals.  Instead, they look like what they are, cogs in the war machine.  Paul spends his first night in the trenches while bombs explode all around him.  His friend, Ludwig (Adrian Grunewald), cries that he wants to return home.  By the next morning, Ludwig is one of the many who is now dead.  Only Kat (Albrecht Schuch) is willing to look after Paul and his friends.  Kat is considered to be a weathered veteran because he has managed to survive for nearly a year on the Western Front.

All Quiet On The Western Front is based on the classic anti-war novel by Erich Maria Remarque.  (A previous adaptation won the Oscar for Best Picture in 1930 and is generally considered to be the first truly “good” Best Picture winner.)  Th film takes some liberties with the book’s plot while still remaining faithful to Remarque’s theme of the futility of war.  One change is that, along with following Paul’s day-to-day life on the Western Front, the film also details the efforts of diplomat Mattias Erzberger (Daniel Bruhl) to negotiate Germany’s surrender.  It’s a fairly big departure from Remarque’s narrative but one that definitely stays true to the spirit of the book.  Despite the fact that Germany knows that it has been defeated and that it will have to surrender, Paul and his friends are still expected to fight and sacrifice their lives for a victory that is no longer attainable.  Indeed, the closer that Erzberger comes to signing a cease fire, the more determined General Friedrichs (Devid Striesow) becomes to launch one final, great offensive before the war ends.  The soldier have no idea what is going on during Erzberger’s negotiations and Erzberger has no idea that Paul has lost the majority of his friends and has been forced to do things that will forever haunt him.  They may not know about each other but Paul’s fate depends on Erzberger’s decisions and the legacy of Erzberger and all the other diplomats and commanders is to be found in what happens to soldiers like Paul.

All Quiet On The Western Front is a brutally effective anti-war film.  Director Edward Berger puts the viewer right in the middle of combat and it is absolutely terrifying.  Paul goes from being an enthusiastic patriot to a hollow-eyed cynic, one who knows that he is considered expendable by both the enemy and his commanders.  The viewer, like Paul, quickly realizes that there is no way to win this war, other than to somehow survive long enough to return home.  But even the soldiers who do survive understand that they won’t have much of a home to return to.  (In a particularly shocking scene, one solder stabs himself in the neck with a fork rather than return home crippled.)  While the the commanders negotiate in luxury, the soldiers live in mud and die almost randomly.  The commanders may talk about strategy but the soldier know that survival comes down to luck.

It’s a harrowing film but it’s also exactly what an anti-war film should be.  There’s a chance that this film could be the second adaptation of All Quiet On The Western Front to receive a nomination for Best Picture and it would certainly be deserved.