
“The best sword is kept in its sheath.” — chamberlain’s wife
Toshiro Mifune spends much of Sanjuro looking like the last person you’d ask to set an example. He slouches, scratches himself, and talks to nine young samurai as though their company were a nuisance he’d been too polite to avoid. Actually, he’s not even that polite. Naturally, they start looking up to him. This turns out to be a mixed blessing, and it’s the joke that gives Akira Kurosawa’s 1962 film its shape. Sanjuro is exactly the man these young samurai need in a crisis, but the more impressed they are by what he can do, the easier it is for them to miss what he knows. The fun of the movie is that we’re right there with them. Who wouldn’t want to be that sure of themselves, at least for an afternoon?
Sanjuro was one of Kurosawa’s rare productions to follow up an earlier film. It brings back Mifune’s wandering, masterless samurai from 1961’s Yojimbo, though the story stands on its own. The project began as an adaptation of a Shūgorō Yamamoto story and was reworked for the returning character after Yojimbo’s success. That history helps explain why the sequel doesn’t feel like a second helping. In Yojimbo, Sanjuro figures out what two rival gangs want and lets their self-interest do much of his work for him. Here, the people he has the most trouble managing are on his side. A crook looking out for himself is predictable. Nine decent men who want to prove they’re useful can talk themselves into just about anything.
We see the problem at the young men’s secret meeting about corruption in their clan. They’ve agreed on who looks guilty and which official seems trustworthy, and Sanjuro, listening from the next room, tells them they’ve read it backward. Mifune doesn’t play it as a grand entrance. He sounds like somebody who’d rather have minded his own business but can’t listen to another minute of this. Better still is the way he shifts from irritation to alertness without straightening up. You notice how closely he’s been listening only when he decides to speak. The young men are judging people by how convincingly they carry themselves. The first person to give them good advice looks as though he couldn’t be bothered to pass their test.
Kurosawa makes their inexperience visible without asking all nine actors to play nine different kinds of fool. Their heads turn together. They crowd into spaces already too small for them. They look ready to move before anyone has settled on a direction. Mifune gets laughs by staying where he is, but the other actors deserve some credit: their earnestness gives his stillness something to play against. In the wide frame, you can watch an idea spread through the group before anybody has stopped to consider whether it’s any good. The downside is that most of the nine don’t make much of an impression individually. I mind that less than the early tangle of officials and allegiances, which takes a while to sort out even when Kurosawa’s staging tells you exactly where to look.
Once rescuing the kidnapped chamberlain becomes the immediate goal, the comedy grows more affectionate. The young men’s mistakes are funnier because the consequences are clearer, but also because their impulse to help is plainly sincere. Sanjuro can tell them to hold back; he can’t make holding back feel honorable to men eager to prove themselves. The camellia signal is a lovely answer to that problem. Instead of having someone charge into the next scene, Kurosawa lets a bunch of flowers carry the message downstream. He gives us time to watch the blossoms move rather than cutting straight to their arrival. You catch yourself wanting them to hurry up, which is a ridiculous thing to want from flowers and not far off what Sanjuro has been dealing with all along.
The chamberlain’s wife, played by Takako Irie, is the one person who can make Sanjuro look as impatient as his pupils. She suggests that the finest sword is the one that stays in its sheath, and there’s a small comic pleasure in how little he has to say back. Irie’s composure keeps the moment from feeling like a lecture. She talks to him as though he’s perfectly capable of understanding her, which is more disarming than treating him as either a savior or a brute. Mifune doesn’t give us an emphatic pause or a look that says he’s a changed man. He just lets her finish. For a film that gets so much pleasure out of watching its hero be right, it gets a surprising amount out of watching him listen.
What keeps her advice interesting is that the movie gives us plenty of reasons to be glad Sanjuro can draw his sword. People need rescuing, and patience doesn’t always get him the whole way there. But it’s one thing to be grateful for that skill and another to make it the measure of a man. Mifune makes the distinction harder by being such good company when he takes charge. Even his habitual grumbling makes a kind of promise: whatever the others have gotten wrong, he’s already spotted it. There’s real comfort in that, especially after a stretch of plot in which nobody seems to know whom to trust. It’s easy to carry that trust a step too far and assume that whatever he does next must be right because he does it better than anyone else.
Tatsuya Nakadai’s Hanbei Muroto is the rare person who can look at Sanjuro without either underrating him or wanting to be him. Nakadai has a watchfulness that pairs beautifully with Mifune’s apparent indifference. With the nine samurai, Sanjuro can see a mistake coming and practically wait for it to arrive. With Muroto, he has to pay attention to a man who’s paying just as much attention back. That makes their scenes satisfying in a way that has little to do with who might win a fight. You get the sense that each enjoys being spared the usual work of explaining himself. By the time they face each other with swords, I’d almost rather hear what they could say to one another than see what they can do. Almost.
Kurosawa holds them in silence long enough that you start to crave movement, and the fight is over practically before you register that it has begun. The burst of blood is startling, but the pause beforehand gives it its bite. Kurosawa has used this kind of timing to get laughs: let the young men tense up, give Mifune an extra beat, then let him puncture their seriousness. The duel uses that timing without offering the same relief. What makes the shift convincing is that Mifune hasn’t suddenly made Sanjuro sinister. The efficiency we’ve been enjoying is still there. This time there’s no rescue to make it feel good, just an opponent who understood him unusually well and a group of young men watching to see what he’ll do.
I still prefer the nasty little town in Yojimbo to the clan intrigue in Sanjuro, but I prefer what this film asks of Mifune. He has to be magnetic enough that nine young men would want to follow him and honest enough to tell them what a poor ambition that is. If I could check in on those nine later, I wouldn’t especially want to see them draw a sword as fast as he can. I’d rather see one of them interrupt a meeting where everyone agrees too quickly, or recognize good advice from somebody who doesn’t look the part. Neither would make much of a story to tell afterward. But it would mean they’d been watching something besides his hands.
Kurosawa-Mifune Collaborations