Welcome to Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past! On Mondays, I will be reviewing Crime Story, which ran on NBC from 1986 to 1988. The entire show can be found on Tubi!
This week, Torello and Luca are looking for the same person.
Episode 2.7 “Little Girl Lost”
(Dir by James Quinn, originally aired on November 24th, 1987)
On a rainy night, Torello goes to a diner and meets with a somewhat unsavory private eye named Charlie Green (Jack Nance, of Eraserhead and Twin Peaks fame). Charlie explains that he’s been working a missing persons case. He says he witnessed a crime but, before he can go to the police about it, he needs a guarantee that he’ll be given immunity for his own unspecified crimes. Torello uses the diner’s phone to call the U.S. Attorney. While Torello is making the call, a gunman walks up to the diner’s window and shoots and kills Charlie.
Torello and the members of the Task Force investigate Charlie’s murder. They discover that his last client was a young man from New York named Vince Romero (Tim Guinee). Vince hired Charlie to track down his ex-girlfriend, Rachel Fine (Wendy Gazelle). It also turns out that Vince and Charlie were not the only people looking for Rachel. Rachel is the granddaughter of Manny Weisbord and, as a result, both Luca and Max Goldman are searching for her so that they can bring her back to her grandfather.
When Rachel’s ex-roommate is discovered murdered, Torello realizes that Charlie probably witnessed the crime. He also discovers that Charlie knew where Rachel was but he spent weeks pretending that he didn’t so that he could get more money out of Vince. No one’s innocent in this episode.
Eventually, both Torello and Luca learn that Rachel is making movies for a pornographer named Gary Holiday (played, in a wonderfully sleazy turn, by Steven Weber). Torello arrives at the set just before Luca and arrests Gary before the mob can kill him. Gary, being an idiot, doesn’t realize how close he came to being killed. Once he’s in jail, he also doesn’t realize that Weisbord has arranged for him to be defended by the best lawyer around because he wants Gary to be free so that he can get his own revenge. This story ends with Rachel being reunited with her grandfather and a recently acquitted Gary being tossed in the backseat of a car so that he can take a ride to nowhere. Torello watches with grim satisfaction.
Meanwhile, David Abrams has become a peyote addict and is living in a trailer in the desert. Luca visits him and offers to hire him. Abrams takes him up on the offer. Somehow, David resigning from the Justice Department and getting hooked on peyote is the least surprising thing that has ever happened on Crime Story.
This was a good episode. The search for Rachel had plenty of twists and turns and it was interesting to see both Torello and Luca pursuing the same goal. (Not surprisingly, it turns out that there’s not much difference between their methods. Torello and Luca are equally brutal. It’s just that one is protected by the law and one isn’t.) This episode has atmosphere, style, an engrossing story, and a strong roster of guest stars. It’s definitely the best episode of the second season so far.

When high school student Dan Bartlett (John Cusack) is late arriving at the airport, he finds himself watching as the plane taking his girlfriend (Wendy Gazelle) and her parents (Monte Markham and Shelley Fabares) to the Caribbean takes off without him. Dan catches the next available flight and tries to track down his girlfriend and her family. Helping him out is a Ganja-smoking islander (Keith David) and a crusty sea captain (Robert Loggia). Complicating matters is that Dan’s girlfriend has been kidnapped by pirates (Jerry Stiller and his son, Ben)!