Film Review: Run Silent, Run Deep (dir. by Robert Wise)


“That’s strange, Jim. I never even thought of failing.” — Commander Richardson

There’s barely enough room to turn around aboard the submarine in Run Silent, Run Deep, but two enormous egos manage to squeeze inside. Robert Wise’s 1958 war film puts Clark Gable and Burt Lancaster in close quarters and lets their competing ideas about leadership drive the action. Enemy ships supply the immediate danger, but the real hook is watching two capable officers work together when neither fully trusts the other. It’s a gripping movie about control, especially what happens when a captain’s personal ambitions start steering a military mission. The confined setting gives their disagreement an edge: nobody can walk away.

Gable plays Commander Richardson, who returns to sea after losing his previous submarine to a Japanese destroyer. His new command, the USS Nerka, comes with a complication: executive officer Jim Bledsoe, played by Lancaster, expected the promotion himself. Bledsoe knows the crew and has their confidence; Richardson brings seniority and unfinished business. The captain orders exhausting drills while keeping his intentions to himself. Before long, Bledsoe suspects that Richardson is preparing not simply for combat but for another encounter with the enemy responsible for his earlier defeat. What looks like demanding leadership begins to resemble a personal campaign.

Richardson works as a character because he isn’t an obvious fool. Gable gives him authority and convincing tactical confidence, making it easy to understand why the crew would follow him. That competence also makes his obsession harder to challenge. His troubling decisions come wrapped in the assurance of a man who usually knows what he’s doing. Gable communicates the danger through impatience, secrecy, and stubbornness rather than theatrical outbursts. Richardson doesn’t suddenly become incapable of command. Instead, he starts confusing what he wants with what his command needs, and the distinction becomes harder for everyone around him to ignore.

Lancaster makes Bledsoe an effective counterweight without turning him into an uncomplicated voice of reason. His concerns are legitimate, but his disappointment over losing command complicates every objection. Is he protecting the crew, defending his pride, or doing both? Lancaster allows those motives to overlap without making Bledsoe seem petty. He remains dependable, yet his frustration gives that professionalism an edge. You can feel the effort involved in showing respect to a superior whose decisions he distrusts. He also understands that challenging Richardson could damage the discipline he wants to preserve.

The scenes between them work because neither actor needs to dominate every exchange. Gable can make an order sound final while Lancaster’s reaction quietly keeps the argument alive. Their different kinds of authority are part of the appeal: Richardson expects obedience because he holds command, while Bledsoe draws strength from his connection to the crew. Those positions aren’t necessarily incompatible, but wounded pride makes cooperation difficult. The movie gives both men enough credibility that their disagreement remains uncomfortable. It’s much more interesting than watching an obviously reckless captain get corrected by an obviously sensible subordinate.

Wise folds that conflict into the submarine’s daily work. Drills, preparations, and clipped orders show how leadership becomes action: Richardson makes a decision, and everyone else must execute it. The procedural detail does more than establish a naval setting. It shows how completely these men depend on one another, making their divided loyalties dangerous. Some exercises become repetitive, but that repetition has a purpose. Richardson wants coordinated movement to become instinctive, and the film makes us appreciate how little margin for error the crew has. When combat tests that preparation, the earlier emphasis on timing pays off.

The black-and-white photography strengthens the enclosed atmosphere. Narrow passages and crowded equipment leave little room for privacy, much less escape from a strained relationship. Wise doesn’t need to make every shot claustrophobic; the arrangement of bodies within the boat already suggests how closely everyone lives and works. A disagreement between officers can affect men who aren’t participating in it but still have to carry out the consequences. The submarine becomes more than a backdrop. It’s a shared space where uncertainty spreads quickly and even a small loss of confidence can become difficult to contain.

Outside the hull, the enemy remains difficult to locate and anticipate. Wise builds suspense around decisions—when to move, when to wait, when to attack—rather than relying entirely on destruction. Faces listening for information can be as compelling as weapons firing. There’s a tension between the crew’s disciplined movements and how little they can know about what awaits them. The action is exciting because it tests judgment as much as nerve. Richardson’s determination might produce a tactical advantage, but that doesn’t automatically settle whether pursuing it was responsible. Success and sound leadership aren’t quite the same thing.

Later submarine films would revisit that captain-and-executive-officer friction. Crimson Tide (1995) turns it into a showdown between Gene Hackman and Denzel Washington over a nuclear launch, while U-571 (2000) echoes Bledsoe’s frustration through Matthew McConaughey’s resentment of a captain who questions his readiness for command. Neither relationship duplicates Gable and Lancaster’s, but all three films draw suspense from the divide between obedience and independent judgment. They also recognize that ambition can complicate a legitimate objection: wanting command doesn’t make a subordinate wrong, but it can make his motives harder to trust. Danger outside the hull becomes more frightening when authority inside it is unsettled.

Wise’s film has limitations. The supporting sailors register mostly through quick impressions, and some dialogue carries the familiar snap of an older Hollywood service picture. Its focus on the two officers leaves less room for the crew as individuals. Still, Gable and Lancaster give the central conflict enough weight to make that narrow focus worthwhile. Command emerges as a burden, not merely a promotion, and confidence alone doesn’t justify the decisions made in its name. The submarine warfare delivers, but the lasting suspense comes from a harder question: when does loyalty require an officer to stop following and push back?

Late Night Retro Television Review: Highway to Heaven 2.11 “The Monster Part II)


Welcome to Late Night Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past!  On Thursdays, I will be reviewing Highway to Heaven, which aired on NBC from 1984 to 1989.  The entire show is currently streaming on Freevee and several other services!

This week, the story of Julian and Scotty continues!

Episode 2.11 “The Monster Part II”

(Dir by Victor French, originally aired on December 11th, 1985)

This week’s episode of Highway to Heaven begins where last week’s episode ended.

Julian (Jeff Kober) has been charged with attempting to murder Rachel McCullough (Annabella Price) and the whole town is ready to convict him because he has a birthmark on his face and a bratty kid named Ridley (Peter Billingsley) claims that he saw Julian push Rachel.  Rachel, having hit her head, is in a coma and not expected to survive.  Julian is pressured to accept a plea bargain but he protests that he’s innocent and that he loves Rachel.  He would never had hurt her, no matter what the ignorant townspeople believe.

Only Jonathan and Scotty (James Troesch) believe that Julian is innocent.  After Jonathan saves the depressed Scotty from drowning in his swimming pool, Scotty agrees to put off suicide so that he can defend Julian at his trial.  Scotty does so from his motorized wheelchair and, as he explains to the jury, he knows what its like to be treated a certain way because you look different.  With ease, Scotty demolishes Ridley’s testimony and puts the smug prosecutor in his place.  All of the reporters in the courtroom are shocked when Julian is acquitted but the prosecution really didn’t have a case, beyond Julian having a birthmark on his face.  Scotty gets back together with his wife (Margie Impert) and Rachel not only wakes up but she wakes up with her sight restored.  Despite Julian’s fear, Rachel loves him even more when she can see his face.

Awwwwwww!

(Where is Mark during all this?  He doesn’t show up until the final few minutes, probably because Victor French was busy directing this episode.)

Even if one sets aside that this episode is nearly 40 years old, it still feels old-fashioned.  This is the type of courtroom drama where the trial watchers gasp at each piece of testimony.  As far a courtroom procedurals go, this episode went more for melodrama than realism but that’s to expected with this show.  It was heartfelt and earnest and Jeff Kober gave a touching performance as Julian.

Probably the most interesting thing about this episode was the number of times Jonathan got mad at people.  He got mad at Julian’s original lawyer.  He got mad at Scotty for trying to drown himself.  He called Scotty’s wife a “jerk” to her face.  He gave the prosecutor a dirty look during the latter’s opening statement.  He even got annoyed with Julian’s overly protective mother (Ann Doran).  Jonathan may be an angel but this episode suggests that even angels lose their patience.