Film Review: Run Silent, Run Deep (dir. by Robert Wise)


“That’s strange, Jim. I never even thought of failing.” — Commander Richardson

There’s barely enough room to turn around aboard the submarine in Run Silent, Run Deep, but two enormous egos manage to squeeze inside. Robert Wise’s 1958 war film puts Clark Gable and Burt Lancaster in close quarters and lets their competing ideas about leadership drive the action. Enemy ships supply the immediate danger, but the real hook is watching two capable officers work together when neither fully trusts the other. It’s a gripping movie about control, especially what happens when a captain’s personal ambitions start steering a military mission. The confined setting gives their disagreement an edge: nobody can walk away.

Gable plays Commander Richardson, who returns to sea after losing his previous submarine to a Japanese destroyer. His new command, the USS Nerka, comes with a complication: executive officer Jim Bledsoe, played by Lancaster, expected the promotion himself. Bledsoe knows the crew and has their confidence; Richardson brings seniority and unfinished business. The captain orders exhausting drills while keeping his intentions to himself. Before long, Bledsoe suspects that Richardson is preparing not simply for combat but for another encounter with the enemy responsible for his earlier defeat. What looks like demanding leadership begins to resemble a personal campaign.

Richardson works as a character because he isn’t an obvious fool. Gable gives him authority and convincing tactical confidence, making it easy to understand why the crew would follow him. That competence also makes his obsession harder to challenge. His troubling decisions come wrapped in the assurance of a man who usually knows what he’s doing. Gable communicates the danger through impatience, secrecy, and stubbornness rather than theatrical outbursts. Richardson doesn’t suddenly become incapable of command. Instead, he starts confusing what he wants with what his command needs, and the distinction becomes harder for everyone around him to ignore.

Lancaster makes Bledsoe an effective counterweight without turning him into an uncomplicated voice of reason. His concerns are legitimate, but his disappointment over losing command complicates every objection. Is he protecting the crew, defending his pride, or doing both? Lancaster allows those motives to overlap without making Bledsoe seem petty. He remains dependable, yet his frustration gives that professionalism an edge. You can feel the effort involved in showing respect to a superior whose decisions he distrusts. He also understands that challenging Richardson could damage the discipline he wants to preserve.

The scenes between them work because neither actor needs to dominate every exchange. Gable can make an order sound final while Lancaster’s reaction quietly keeps the argument alive. Their different kinds of authority are part of the appeal: Richardson expects obedience because he holds command, while Bledsoe draws strength from his connection to the crew. Those positions aren’t necessarily incompatible, but wounded pride makes cooperation difficult. The movie gives both men enough credibility that their disagreement remains uncomfortable. It’s much more interesting than watching an obviously reckless captain get corrected by an obviously sensible subordinate.

Wise folds that conflict into the submarine’s daily work. Drills, preparations, and clipped orders show how leadership becomes action: Richardson makes a decision, and everyone else must execute it. The procedural detail does more than establish a naval setting. It shows how completely these men depend on one another, making their divided loyalties dangerous. Some exercises become repetitive, but that repetition has a purpose. Richardson wants coordinated movement to become instinctive, and the film makes us appreciate how little margin for error the crew has. When combat tests that preparation, the earlier emphasis on timing pays off.

The black-and-white photography strengthens the enclosed atmosphere. Narrow passages and crowded equipment leave little room for privacy, much less escape from a strained relationship. Wise doesn’t need to make every shot claustrophobic; the arrangement of bodies within the boat already suggests how closely everyone lives and works. A disagreement between officers can affect men who aren’t participating in it but still have to carry out the consequences. The submarine becomes more than a backdrop. It’s a shared space where uncertainty spreads quickly and even a small loss of confidence can become difficult to contain.

Outside the hull, the enemy remains difficult to locate and anticipate. Wise builds suspense around decisions—when to move, when to wait, when to attack—rather than relying entirely on destruction. Faces listening for information can be as compelling as weapons firing. There’s a tension between the crew’s disciplined movements and how little they can know about what awaits them. The action is exciting because it tests judgment as much as nerve. Richardson’s determination might produce a tactical advantage, but that doesn’t automatically settle whether pursuing it was responsible. Success and sound leadership aren’t quite the same thing.

Later submarine films would revisit that captain-and-executive-officer friction. Crimson Tide (1995) turns it into a showdown between Gene Hackman and Denzel Washington over a nuclear launch, while U-571 (2000) echoes Bledsoe’s frustration through Matthew McConaughey’s resentment of a captain who questions his readiness for command. Neither relationship duplicates Gable and Lancaster’s, but all three films draw suspense from the divide between obedience and independent judgment. They also recognize that ambition can complicate a legitimate objection: wanting command doesn’t make a subordinate wrong, but it can make his motives harder to trust. Danger outside the hull becomes more frightening when authority inside it is unsettled.

Wise’s film has limitations. The supporting sailors register mostly through quick impressions, and some dialogue carries the familiar snap of an older Hollywood service picture. Its focus on the two officers leaves less room for the crew as individuals. Still, Gable and Lancaster give the central conflict enough weight to make that narrow focus worthwhile. Command emerges as a burden, not merely a promotion, and confidence alone doesn’t justify the decisions made in its name. The submarine warfare delivers, but the lasting suspense comes from a harder question: when does loyalty require an officer to stop following and push back?

Horror on TV: The Twilight Zone 5.3 “Nightmare at 20,000 Feet”


TheTwilightZoneLogo


Wow. It’s hard to believe that is going to be my final televised horror of the year. (Though I imagine this feature will return in October of 2016 — just in time for election season!) Well, let’s get right to it!


For our final televised horror, I have selected a classic episode of The Twilight Zone. In Nightmare at 20,000 Feet, William Shatner is a man who, though being scared of flying, finds himself on an airplane. And guess what he sees out on the wing?


This episode was written by one of Arleigh’s favorite writers, the great Richard Matheson. It was directed by Richard Donner and originally aired on October 11th, 1963.


Enjoy Nightmare at 20,000 Feet! And here’s hoping that all of our readers have had a wonderful, safe, and happy Halloween!


Insomnia File #1: The Story of Mankind (dir by Irwin Allen)


Story of Mankind

What’s an Insomnia File?  You know how some times you just can’t get any sleep and, at about three in the morning, you’ll find yourself watching whatever you can find on cable?  This feature is all about those insomnia-inspired discoveries!

If, last night, you were suffering from insomnia at 3 in the morning, you could have turned on TCM and watched the 1957 faux epic, The Story of Mankind.

I call The Story of Mankind a faux epic because it’s an outwardly big film that turns out to be remarkably small on closer inspection.  First off, it claims to the tell the story of Mankind but it only has a running time of 100 minutes so, as you can imagine, a lot of the story gets left out.  (I was annoyed that neither my favorite social reformer, Victoria C. Woodhull, nor my favorite president, Rutherford B. Hayes, made an appearance.)  It’s a film that follow Vincent Price and Ronald Colman as they stroll through history but it turns out that “history” is largely made up of stock footage taken from other movies.  The film’s cast is full of actors who will be familiar to lovers of classic cinema and yet, few of them really have more than a few minutes of screen time.  In fact, it only takes a little bit of research on the imdb to discover that most of the film’s cast was made up of performers who were on the verge of ending their careers.

The Story of Mankind opens with two angels noticing that mankind has apparently invented the “Super H-Bomb,” ten years ahead of schedule.  It appears that mankind is on the verge of destroying itself and soon, both Heaven and Hell will be full of new arrivals.  One of the angels exclaims that there’s already a housing shortage!

A celestial court, overseen by a stern judge (Cedric Hardwicke) is convened in outer space.  The court must decide whether to intervene and prevent mankind from destroying itself.  Speaking on behalf on humanity is the Spirit of Man.  The Spirit of Man is played by Ronald Colman.  This was Colman’s final film.  In his heyday, he was such a popular star that he was Margaret Mitchell’s first choice to play Rhett Butler in Gone With The Wind.  However, in The Story of Mankind, Colman comes across as being a bit bored with it all and you start to get worried that he might not be the best attorney that mankind could have hired.

Even more worrisome, as  far as the future of mankind is concerned, is that the prosecutor, Mr. Scratch, is being played by Vincent Price.  Making his case with his trademark theatrics and delivering every snaky line with a self-satisfied yet likable smirk on his face, Vincent Price is so much fun to watch that it was impossible not to agree with him.  Destroy mankind, Mr. Scratch?  Sure, why not?  Mankind had a good run, after all…

In order to make their cases, Mr. Scratch and the Spirit of Man take a tour through history.  Mr. Scratch reminds us of villains like the Egyptian pharaoh Khufu (John Carradine) and the Roman Emperor Nero (Peter Lorre, of course).  He shows how Joan of Arc (Hedy Lamarr) was burned at the stake.  The Spirit of Man argues that, despite all of that, man is still capable of doing good things, like inventing the printing press.

And really, the whole point of the film is to see who is playing which historical figure.  The film features a huge cast of classic film actors.  If you watch TCM on a semi-regular basis, you’ll recognize a good deal of the cast.  The fun comes from seeing who tried to give a memorable performance and who just showed up to collect a paycheck.  For instance, a very young Dennis Hopper gives a bizarre method interpretation of Napoleon and it’s one of those things that simply has to be seen.

And then the Marx Brothers show up!

They don’t share any scenes together, unfortunately.  But three of them are present!  (No, Zeppo does not make an appearance but I imagine that’s just because Jim Ameche was already cast in the role of Alexander Graham Bell.)  Chico is a monk who tells Christopher Columbus not to waste his time looking for a quicker way to reach India.  Harpo Marx is Sir Isaac Newton, who plays a harp and discovers gravity when a hundred apples smash down on his head.  And Groucho Marx plays Peter Miniut, tricking a Native American chief into selling Manhattan Island while leering at the chief’s daughter.

And the good thing about the Marx Brothers is that their presence makes a strong argument that humanity deserves another chance.  A world that produced the Marx Brothers can’t be all bad, right?

Anyway, Story of Mankind is one of those films that seems like it would be a good cure for insomnia but then you start watching it and it’s just such a weird movie that you simply have to watch it all the way to the end.  It’s not a good movie but it is flamboyantly bad and, as a result, everyone should see it at least once.