Retro Television Review: Decoy 1.38 “First Arrest”

Posted on July 16, 2026 by Lisa Marie Bowman

Welcome to Retro Television Reviews, a feature where we review some of our favorite and least favorite shows of the past! On Thursdays, I will be reviewing Decoy, which aired in Syndication in 1957 and 1958. The show can be viewed on Tubi!

This week, it’s the next-to-last episode Decoy!

Episode 1.38 “First Arrest”

(Dir by Arthur H. Singer, originally aired on June 30th, 1958)

Casey meets with a new, rookie policewoman (Ellen Madison) at Coney Island. The rookie just made her first arrest and is now in tears because she’s worried that she’s ruined someone’s life. Casey tells the story of her first assignment and what it was like to make her first arrest.

Flashback time!

The NYPD believes that a fencing operation is being run out of a Coney Island carnival sideshow. Young and eager, Casey gets a job as an exotic dancer at the carnival. (Calm down, boys. She wears one of the least-revealing costumes of all time.) Shy and insecure Willie Graff (Joshua Shelley) develops a crush on Casey. Casey, suspecting that Willie is the fence, plays along but she starts to feel guilty as she realizes that Willie isn’t some sort of dangerous criminal. He’s just a down-on-his-luck guy who is cutting a few corners. He even introduces Casey to his mother (Ruth McDevitt).

When Willie gives Casey a diamond necklace, she assumes that it must be stolen but it turns out that it’s his mother’s necklace and that Mrs. Graff wants Casey to have it. Casey is actually relieved because it seems like Willie isn’t the fence that she’s looking for. However, then Willie gives her a mink coat and admits that he bought it from someone who had stolen it. Though saddened, Casey forces herself to arrest Willie.

In the present, Casey assures the rookie that she will soon get used to arresting people and she won’t care about them anymore. Yikes!

As you may have guessed, I didn’t really care much for this episode. That idea of Casey being someone who doesn’t care about the people who she arrests pretty much goes totally against everything we’ve seen over the past 37 episodes. The thing that always set Casey apart was that she does care. She has to do her job but she also understands that sometimes, people just make mistakes. Unless it’s case in which she was threatened, Casey usually doesn’t take any joy in slapping the handcuffs on someone.

As much as I hate to say it, Beverly Garland is not particularly convincing in the flashback scenes. Young Casey is written as being continually breathless and unsure of herself. There’s nothing about Beverly Garland’s screen presence that suggests insecurity.

This was a disappointing episode. Next week, we’ll be finishing up Decoy and I hope it goes out on a better note than this.

Retro Television Review: Decoy 1.22 “Reasonable Doubts”

Posted on February 26, 2026 by Lisa Marie Bowman

This week, Casey deals with two brothers who may or may not be guilty of a crime.

Episode 1.22 “Reasonable Doubts”

(Dir by Teddy Sills, originally aired on March 10th, 1958)

An office is robbed and the manager is shot. As Casey Jones tells us in her narration, the difference between this robbery and countless others is that someone got a good look at the robber. Lawrence Osler (Joe Warren) is arrested for the crime. However, Lawrence’s sister, Julia (Anna Minot), is convinced that Lawrence is innocent and she thinks that Lawrence’s younger brother, John (Thomas A. Carlin), can prove it. Casey agrees to go undercover as a friend of Julia’s who has agreed to pay Lawrence’s bail. Her assignment is to get John to talk. Julia thinks that Casey is going to exonerate both the brothers but, in reality, Casey is trying to put John in jail with Lawrence.

“It wasn’t very nice,” Casey ruefully tells us. But, Casey goes on to note, neither is robbing an office and putting a man in the hospital.

Casey discovers that Lawrence is innocent. It was John and his shady buddy Oscar (Edward Walsh) who robbed the place. John was willing to let Lawrence take the fall because he thought Lawrence would be acquitted in court. But now, Oscar is trying to frame Lawrence. Will John take responsibility for his own actions?

This episode probably sounds more interesting than it is. With only a 30 minute running time, there’s not much room to generate any sort of suspense as to which brother is guilty. Lawrence is obviously innocent from the start and John is obviously guilty. It doesn’t take Casey long to figure this out but she can’t really do anything about it until Oscar shows up unexpectedly and casually reveals that truth about what happened. This is one of those episodes where the viewer feels like Casey just got lucky. As well, most of the action too place indoors so there weren’t any of the 1950s New York location shots that so often added life to this series.

That said, Beverly Garland was great as always. Her regret over manipulating Julia added an extra dimension to the story. As Casey said, “It wasn’t nice.” In the end, Julia saves one brother but loses another.

Retro Television Review: Decoy 1.9 “Necklace of Glass”

Posted on October 23, 2025 by Lisa Marie Bowman

This week, Casey discovers that New York can be a lot of fun when you know the right people.

Episode 1.9 “Necklace of Glass”

(Dir by Teddy Sills, originally aired on December 9th, 1957)

Casey goes undercover as a rich socialite in order to investigate a spree of jewelry thefts. Unfortunately, Casey isn’t very good at her job in this episode. Not only does she suspect the wrong person, a shady gigolo named Larry Babson (Martin E. Brooks), she also comes on too strong while trying to trick Larry into confessing. Larry figures out that she’s a cop, finds the microphone that Casey hid in the apartment, and then storms out. Fortunately, Larry’s wife (Rita Grapel) then shows up shortly afterwards and, not having had a chance to talk to Larry, reveals that she’s the one who has been masterminding the jewelry thefts. Casey, who had been feeling pretty bad up until that point, promptly pulls out her badge.

I actually appreciated the fact that Casey basically blew her assignment in this episode. Characters who are flawless and who never make mistakes are boring. In the episode, Casey says that she was distracted by how much fun it was to pretend to be rich and it makes perfect sense. Why wouldn’t the working class Casey enjoy the chance to live the high life for once?

The important thing is, even though she initially screwed up, Casey solved the case. This was a good episode. Casey wasn’t flawless but, in the end, luck was on her side.