Film Review: Breaker Morant (dir. by Bruce Beresford)


“They have to apologize for their damned war. They’re trying to end it now, so they need scapegoats.” — Harry Morant

The most disturbing thing about Breaker Morant isn’t that soldiers commit terrible acts during wartime. It’s how smoothly the people running the war can turn those soldiers into a problem to be disposed of. Bruce Beresford’s 1980 film looks at what happens when military necessity stops being a useful excuse and starts becoming a political embarrassment. It’s a courtroom drama, a war film, and a bitter examination of loyalty, held together by performances that keep its arguments from becoming abstract. What makes it compelling is the uncomfortable possibility that the men on trial are both responsible for their actions and being betrayed by their commanders.

Set during the Boer War, the story follows Harry “Breaker” Morant, Peter Handcock, and George Witton, three lieutenants facing a British military court over the killing of prisoners and a German missionary. Their defense is that they operated under orders that encouraged taking no prisoners, although those instructions conveniently lack the documentation needed to protect them. Assigned to defend them, Major J. F. Thomas finds himself fighting more than the prosecution’s evidence. He’s up against a military establishment whose political interests seem to require a particular outcome. The suspense comes less from discovering what happened than from wondering whether the court will acknowledge the circumstances surrounding it.

Beresford handles that material with an understated confidence. He doesn’t turn every exchange into a grand confrontation or bury the drama beneath swelling emotion. Instead, he lets the courtroom’s procedures become quietly suffocating. Questions, objections, and carefully phrased answers gradually reveal how much power rests with whoever controls the terms of the discussion. The flashbacks open up the film visually while complicating the testimony. Outside the courtroom, decisions emerge from exhaustion, anger, retaliation, and uncertainty. Inside it, those same decisions are discussed as though they occurred under conditions of perfect clarity. The contrast exposes the distance between fighting a war and explaining one afterward.

Edward Woodward gives Morant the combination of charisma and severity that the role needs. His Morant is articulate, proud, and capable of bitter humor, but there’s something stubbornly closed off about him too. Woodward never makes him so agreeable that the audience can comfortably overlook what he has done. At times, his confidence feels like courage; at others, it looks like a refusal to face the full meaning of his choices. That tension makes the performance work. We can sympathize with his predicament without being asked to believe that intelligence, charm, or mistreatment automatically makes someone morally right.

Bryan Brown’s Handcock is more openly irreverent, and his blunt humor gives the film some welcome breathing room. He has little patience for the court’s dignified performance of fairness, and Brown makes that contempt entertaining without removing the character’s darker edges. Lewis Fitz-Gerald brings a more exposed, youthful quality to Witton, emphasizing how differently the three men experience their situation. Jack Thompson, meanwhile, gives Thomas a decency that never feels sugary. His growing frustration becomes our way into the proceedings. He keeps searching for an argument that will make the court listen, even as it becomes increasingly doubtful that listening is the point.

The film’s central concern is the relationship between obedience and abandonment. Commanders demand that men finish the mission, crush resistance, and do whatever the situation supposedly requires. The practical message is that results matter more than restraint. But when those methods become difficult to defend publicly, the men carrying them out discover that their superiors’ expectations are much harder to prove than their own actions. In the film’s telling, the chain of command becomes a one-way arrangement: authority flows downward, but responsibility never travels back up. The soldiers are expected to understand what their commanders want without expecting those commanders to stand beside them afterward.

That betrayal is especially ugly because it exploits the loyalty military service depends on. Men are trained to trust their superiors and act decisively under pressure, yet afterward they may be judged as though they acted entirely independently. Breaker Morant captures the cruelty of that switch. The institution can encourage brutality through implication, tolerate it while it remains useful, and then present punishment as proof of its own moral seriousness. Discarding a few men allows everyone above them to look cleaner. Justice becomes less a full accounting of responsibility than a way of drawing a protective line around the people who still have power.

Still, the defense that the men followed orders cannot settle everything, and the film is most interesting when it leaves that discomfort intact. Killing prisoners doesn’t become acceptable because a superior encouraged it. Personal responsibility matters, even within a corrupt or hypocritical system. The troubling question is why that responsibility should stop with the men closest to the victims. Beresford makes a strong case that condemning individual crimes and examining command responsibility belong together. The defendants don’t need to be innocent for the proceedings to be compromised. Their guilt, where established, shouldn’t function as an excuse to stop asking who created the conditions in which they acted.

The film does, however, lean so heavily toward the accused that the people they killed receive much less attention. Their suffering can become background to the more fully developed suffering of the defendants. That imbalance limits the film’s moral reach, even as it strengthens its emotional pull. Its account of disputed orders and political scapegoating also needs to be understood as a dramatic interpretation rather than an unquestionable historical verdict. Yet those reservations don’t diminish the skill of the filmmaking. They make it worth watching critically, recognizing both the force of its argument and the places where its sympathies narrow our view.

By the end, the courtroom’s formalities feel more chilling than reassuring. Everyone has a role, the procedures have been observed, and the machinery can keep moving once these particular men are gone. That is what gives Breaker Morant its lasting sting. Beresford doesn’t simply show soldiers discovering that war is cruel; he shows them discovering that their own side’s loyalty has limits they were never told about. With its measured direction and deeply felt performances, the film leaves behind a bitter question: when commanders demand dirty work but refuse to own the consequences, what exactly is the honor they claim to defend?

Music Video of the Day: I Didn’t Mean To Turn You On by Robert Palmer (1986, directed by Terence Donovan)


Today’s music video of the day is for Robert Palmer’s cover of I Didn’t Mean To Turn You On, a song that was originally recorded by Cherelle in 1984.  Palmer, whose songs epitomized the 80s, would have been 71 years old today.

If this video looks familiar, that may be because it shares the same concept behind Palmer’s videos for Addicted To Love and Simply Irresistible, both of which were also directed by photographer Terence Donavon.  Once again, Palmer, looking like he should be trading commodities on Wall Street, performed while a group of statuesque models “played” his band behind him.   The video, however, added another group of models, dressed in white, who danced to the music and who had better rhythm than the models who made up Palmer’s band.

Enjoy!

Music Video of the Day: Addicted To Love by Robert Palmer (1986, dir. Terence Donovan)


It’s obligatory to do legendary music videos like this one. The problem is finding something to write about when it comes to them.

We like things that look alike moving in unison. It’s as old as entertainment in general. You can swap them out for guys, or even toothbrushes, and it works just as well.

What seems to have some people slightly miffed is that they were stripped down to form rather than shown as a living breathing human being. According to Wikipedia, this is similar to what artist Patrick Nagel would do in his artwork. He happened to design the cover for Duran Duran’s album Rio.

duranrio

What I can do is a where-are-they-now on this music video because we actually know who all these girls are in the video.

The women go like this: Julie Pankhurst (keyboard), Patty Kelly (guitar), Mak Gilchrist (bass guitar), Julia Bolino (guitar), Kathy Davies (drums).

You can find some of them on Twitter. You can also find numerous articles on them since they appear to have been tracked down fairly recently.

Mak Gilchrist posted a reunion of four of the five girls.

There’s also an interesting video where some of the girls are interviewed. I wish I could embed said video, but it’s on Yahoo!, and WordPress.com does not allow that for security reasons, so you’ll have to follow the link. It’s worth it because it provides background information on what has happened to them since the music video.

https://uk.screen.yahoo.com/robert-palmer-girls-today-173805406.html?format=embed&player_autoplay=false

I particularly like Kathy Davies’ story about mostly watching Robert Palmer’s butt off-camera.

There’s also a humorous quote from Mak Gilchrist over on Wikipedia from Q magazine:

“I was 21 and got the part on the strength of my modeling book. We were meant to look and ‘act’ like showroom mannequins. Director Terence Donovan got us tipsy on a bottle of wine but as we were having our make-up retouched, I lost balance on my heels and knocked the top of my guitar into the back of Robert’s head, and his face then hit the microphone.”

The girls were miming five musicians that were off-camera. I agree with Mak Gilchrist in the video that they should be tracked down too because they probably have interesting stories to add about the shoot.

Enjoy!

Music Video of the Day: Simply Irresistible by Robert Palmer (1988, dir. Terence Donovan)


We like people who are made up to look the same while they do the same thing next to each other. There really isn’t anything else to say here except that it took an age old formula a la Busby Berkeley, and fed it to us once again.

Robert Palmer didn’t like making music videos, so when Addicted To Love turned out to be amazing, he just said let’s do that again. Hence we got the same thing only with more girls. That’s not quite as good seeing as five girls that are easy to look up, find out their names, and discover they have reunions. However, I have looked through the comment section and there are several people who write that one of the girls is either their sister, girlfriend, wife, or somebody they know in general. Doesn’t surprise me.

As for the song, it’s Robert Palmer. He does good work. I have yet to come across a song of his that I don’t like, but I’m sure it will happen eventually. The music video is actually perfect for him specifically because while the girls behind him do their thing, it let’s Palmer stay simple. He’s there with his good looks, nice suit, and sings to us like he is onstage in a 30s-40s musical.

Director/Producer Terence Donovan also did Addicted To Love and a handful of other music videos while being a well-known fashion photographer.

I can’t find any other music video work done by choreographer Jeff Thacker, but he certainly continued to work afterwards. His main thing is being one of the producers on the TV Show So You Think You Can Dance.

Enjoy!