Film Review: Breaker Morant (dir. by Bruce Beresford)


“They have to apologize for their damned war. They’re trying to end it now, so they need scapegoats.” — Harry Morant

The most disturbing thing about Breaker Morant isn’t that soldiers commit terrible acts during wartime. It’s how smoothly the people running the war can turn those soldiers into a problem to be disposed of. Bruce Beresford’s 1980 film looks at what happens when military necessity stops being a useful excuse and starts becoming a political embarrassment. It’s a courtroom drama, a war film, and a bitter examination of loyalty, held together by performances that keep its arguments from becoming abstract. What makes it compelling is the uncomfortable possibility that the men on trial are both responsible for their actions and being betrayed by their commanders.

Set during the Boer War, the story follows Harry “Breaker” Morant, Peter Handcock, and George Witton, three lieutenants facing a British military court over the killing of prisoners and a German missionary. Their defense is that they operated under orders that encouraged taking no prisoners, although those instructions conveniently lack the documentation needed to protect them. Assigned to defend them, Major J. F. Thomas finds himself fighting more than the prosecution’s evidence. He’s up against a military establishment whose political interests seem to require a particular outcome. The suspense comes less from discovering what happened than from wondering whether the court will acknowledge the circumstances surrounding it.

Beresford handles that material with an understated confidence. He doesn’t turn every exchange into a grand confrontation or bury the drama beneath swelling emotion. Instead, he lets the courtroom’s procedures become quietly suffocating. Questions, objections, and carefully phrased answers gradually reveal how much power rests with whoever controls the terms of the discussion. The flashbacks open up the film visually while complicating the testimony. Outside the courtroom, decisions emerge from exhaustion, anger, retaliation, and uncertainty. Inside it, those same decisions are discussed as though they occurred under conditions of perfect clarity. The contrast exposes the distance between fighting a war and explaining one afterward.

Edward Woodward gives Morant the combination of charisma and severity that the role needs. His Morant is articulate, proud, and capable of bitter humor, but there’s something stubbornly closed off about him too. Woodward never makes him so agreeable that the audience can comfortably overlook what he has done. At times, his confidence feels like courage; at others, it looks like a refusal to face the full meaning of his choices. That tension makes the performance work. We can sympathize with his predicament without being asked to believe that intelligence, charm, or mistreatment automatically makes someone morally right.

Bryan Brown’s Handcock is more openly irreverent, and his blunt humor gives the film some welcome breathing room. He has little patience for the court’s dignified performance of fairness, and Brown makes that contempt entertaining without removing the character’s darker edges. Lewis Fitz-Gerald brings a more exposed, youthful quality to Witton, emphasizing how differently the three men experience their situation. Jack Thompson, meanwhile, gives Thomas a decency that never feels sugary. His growing frustration becomes our way into the proceedings. He keeps searching for an argument that will make the court listen, even as it becomes increasingly doubtful that listening is the point.

The film’s central concern is the relationship between obedience and abandonment. Commanders demand that men finish the mission, crush resistance, and do whatever the situation supposedly requires. The practical message is that results matter more than restraint. But when those methods become difficult to defend publicly, the men carrying them out discover that their superiors’ expectations are much harder to prove than their own actions. In the film’s telling, the chain of command becomes a one-way arrangement: authority flows downward, but responsibility never travels back up. The soldiers are expected to understand what their commanders want without expecting those commanders to stand beside them afterward.

That betrayal is especially ugly because it exploits the loyalty military service depends on. Men are trained to trust their superiors and act decisively under pressure, yet afterward they may be judged as though they acted entirely independently. Breaker Morant captures the cruelty of that switch. The institution can encourage brutality through implication, tolerate it while it remains useful, and then present punishment as proof of its own moral seriousness. Discarding a few men allows everyone above them to look cleaner. Justice becomes less a full accounting of responsibility than a way of drawing a protective line around the people who still have power.

Still, the defense that the men followed orders cannot settle everything, and the film is most interesting when it leaves that discomfort intact. Killing prisoners doesn’t become acceptable because a superior encouraged it. Personal responsibility matters, even within a corrupt or hypocritical system. The troubling question is why that responsibility should stop with the men closest to the victims. Beresford makes a strong case that condemning individual crimes and examining command responsibility belong together. The defendants don’t need to be innocent for the proceedings to be compromised. Their guilt, where established, shouldn’t function as an excuse to stop asking who created the conditions in which they acted.

The film does, however, lean so heavily toward the accused that the people they killed receive much less attention. Their suffering can become background to the more fully developed suffering of the defendants. That imbalance limits the film’s moral reach, even as it strengthens its emotional pull. Its account of disputed orders and political scapegoating also needs to be understood as a dramatic interpretation rather than an unquestionable historical verdict. Yet those reservations don’t diminish the skill of the filmmaking. They make it worth watching critically, recognizing both the force of its argument and the places where its sympathies narrow our view.

By the end, the courtroom’s formalities feel more chilling than reassuring. Everyone has a role, the procedures have been observed, and the machinery can keep moving once these particular men are gone. That is what gives Breaker Morant its lasting sting. Beresford doesn’t simply show soldiers discovering that war is cruel; he shows them discovering that their own side’s loyalty has limits they were never told about. With its measured direction and deeply felt performances, the film leaves behind a bitter question: when commanders demand dirty work but refuse to own the consequences, what exactly is the honor they claim to defend?

I Watched Molokai: The Story of Father Damien (1999, Dir. by Paul Cox)


In the late 19th Century, a leper colony was established on the Hawaiian island of Molokai.  Officially, the Kalaupapa Leprosy Settlement was said to be for the care of people with leprosy, which was then raging across Asia.  Unofficially, it was a prison where lepers were isolated from the rest of society and left to die.  Any leper who tried to leave the colony would be shot on sight.  Father Damien, a Belgian priest, was one of the few people willing to walk amongst the lepers.  When he was first sent to the colony, he was ordered to only administer last rites to the dying and to not allow himself to be touched.  Instead, Damien stayed and ministered to the lepers, knowing that he would probably never be allowed to leave.  For 16 years, Damien ministered to the colony.  Even after he himself grew sick, he continued his ministry and continued to be an advocate for his fellow lepers until he died.

Molokai: The Story of Father Damien is a wonderful film about the life and ministry of Father Damien.  The movie features a lot of familiar actors in small roles, like Sam Neill, Kris Kristofferson, Peter O’Toole, Tom Wilkinson, and Alice Krige.  But the star of the film is David Wenham, who portrays the kindness and dedication of Father Damien without ever making him seem idealized or boring.  Father Damien is guided by both his faith and his belief that no one should be abandoned.  It’s not always easy to watch.  The horrors of leprosy are unflinchingly portrayed.  But, by the end of the movie, it doesn’t matter if you’re Catholic or not.  You’re just thankful for men like Father Damien.

Saint Damien of Molokai was canonized by Pope Benedict XVI in 2009.

International Horror: The Cars That Ate Paris (dir by Peter Weir)


Taking place in a vaguely futuristic world, the 1974 Australian film, The Cars That Ate Paris, opens with an attractive and impossibly happy couple going for a drive in the countryside and getting killed in a truly horrific car accident, one that apparently was deliberately set up.

Meanwhile, two brothers — Arthur (Terry Camilleri) and George (Rick Scully) — are traveling across Australia, in search of work.  Everywhere they go, they see long lines of desperate people looking for a way to make money, suggesting that the economy has basically collapsed.  George does the driving, largely because Arthur’s license was taken away after he accidentally killed a pedestrian.  Arthur is struggling with both the guilt and a phobia of cars in general.

That phobia only gets worse after Arthur and George are involved in a automotive accident of their own.  George is killed but Arthur survives.  Taken to the small, rural town of Paris, Arthur is adopted as a bit of a mascot by the town’s seemingly friendly mayor, Len Kelly (John Mellion).  At first, Arthur is relieved to have survived but he soon comes to realize that the residents of Paris have no intention of ever letting him leave.

Paris, it turns out, is a bit of a strange place.  The entire economy is based on collecting scrap metal from the many cars that crash within the city limits.  The local hospital is full of car crash victims, the majority of whom end up getting lobotomized and used as test subjects for the local doctor.  Indeed, the only thing that kept Arthur from a similar fate was that the mayor assured everyone that Arthur’s phobia of driving has rendered him “harmless.”  (And just to make sure that Arthur doesn’t lose that phobia, he’s sent to a psychologist who spends nearly the entire session showing him grotesque pictures of car accident victims.)  Though the mayor continually talks about how Paris represents the “pioneer spirit” that made Australia great, the town’s teenagers don’t seem to be too impressed with the place.  They spend all of their time driving around in cars that they’ve modified into small tanks.  (Their leader drives a compact car that has been covered in metal spikes, transforming it into a motorized porcupine.)  Arthur wants to escape the town but can he conquer not only his own fears but also avoid being killed by the citizens who have adopted him?

The Cars That Ate Paris is a rather uneven film.  It gets off to a good start and the town is memorably creepy but, once Arthur had been adopted by the mayor, it starts to drag and not much happens until the teens finally get around to turning on their elders during the final fifteen minutes of the film.  Arthur is a frustratingly passive character and his car phobia never really feels credible.  The film attempts to mix horror, science fiction, and satire but it comes across as being rather disjointed.  Thematically, it’s probably most interesting as a precursor to the Mad Max films, having been inspired by the same Australian car culture that inspired George Miller.  In fact, The Cars That Ate Paris almost feels like a prequel to the Mad Max films.  One half expects a young Mel Gibson to pop up at the end, wearing Max’s patrolman uniform and shaking his head at the madness of it all.

That said, the film features a few striking images and Paris is a memorably desolate town.  This really isn’t that surprising, given that The Cars That Ate Paris was directed by Peter Weir.  This was Weir’s first feature film, though he had previously directed several shorts, and the film very much comes across as being the work of a talented artist who was still learning how to use those talents to tell a compelling story.  In the end, Peter Weir’s involvement is the main reason to watch The Cars That Ate Paris.  The film doesn’t really work but it does provide a chance to see an early effort from someone who would eventually become one of the most interesting directors of his time.

Jaws Meets Mad Max: Razorback (1984, directed by Russell Mulcahy)


Deep in the Australian outback, a young child named Scotty goes missing.  His grandfather, Jake (Bill Kerr), swears that a giant boar (“a razorback”) broke into his house and ran off with his grandson.  The locals don’t think it was a boar.  They don’t even think it was a dingo.  Instead, they charge Jake with killing his grandson but, because there’s not evidence to convict him, Jake goes free.

Two years later, a nosy American reporter named Beth Winters (Judy Morris) mysteriously vanishes shortly after arriving in the Outback to do a story on how kangaroos are being hunted to the point of extinction.  Women and children are vanishing in the Outback?  This sounds like a job for Lee Majors but the best this movie can do is Gregory Harrison.  Harrison plays Beth’s husband, Carl, who comes to Australia to search for her.  At first, he thinks that she may have been kidnapped by the moronic Baker brothers (Chris Haywood and David Argue) but then he meets Jake and a comely pig expert named Sarah (Arkie Whiteley).  Jake tells Carl about the razorback and later comes across Beth’s wedding ring in a pile of boar shit.

Razorback was probably pitched as being “Jaws meets Mad Max.”  Just as in Jaws, the authorities refuse to accept that people are being eaten by a giant boar and it is up to an inexperienced American, an old timer, and a scientist to try to stop it.  Also, like in Jaws, the boar is that star of the show even though it does not get much screen time.  When the boar does appear, it bears a distinct resemblance to Motorhead’s War-Pig.  Just as in Mad Max, every Australian in Razorback drives like a maniac.  Whenever the Baker brothers tear across the screen in their truck, it’s easy to imagine Max Rockatansky and Goose in hot pursuit.

Along with the boar, the other star of the film is the Australian outback itself, which the film treats as almost being an alien landscape:

If Razorback makes the Australian outback look like an 80s new wave music video, that might be because it was directed by Russell Mulcahy, who started his career directing videos for Duran Duran.  Before one boar attack, Duran Duran’s New Moon On Monday is even heard playing on a radio.  (Ironically, New Moon On Monday was one of the few early Duran Duran videos that Mulcahy did not direct.)  Both the boar and the film look great but all of the humans get overshadowed by the visuals.   Not that it matters, since they’re only there to serve as razorback food.

Despite the strong visuals and the amazingly cool monster, Razorback got only lukewarm reviews when it was first released.  Critics aside, it was a hit in Australia, where it won Australian Film awards for both editing and cinematography.  (Cinematographer Dean Semler later won an Oscar for his work on Dances with Wolves.)  It only found cult success in the United States.  One admirer was Steven Spielberg, who reportedly called Mulcahy to ask how he achieved some the film’s visual effects.  Two years after the release of Razorback, Mulcahy directed his best-known film, Highlander.

Flaws and all, Razorback is the best movie ever made about a wild boar eating people in Australia.