Film Review: Breaker Morant (dir. by Bruce Beresford)


“They have to apologize for their damned war. They’re trying to end it now, so they need scapegoats.” — Harry Morant

The most disturbing thing about Breaker Morant isn’t that soldiers commit terrible acts during wartime. It’s how smoothly the people running the war can turn those soldiers into a problem to be disposed of. Bruce Beresford’s 1980 film looks at what happens when military necessity stops being a useful excuse and starts becoming a political embarrassment. It’s a courtroom drama, a war film, and a bitter examination of loyalty, held together by performances that keep its arguments from becoming abstract. What makes it compelling is the uncomfortable possibility that the men on trial are both responsible for their actions and being betrayed by their commanders.

Set during the Boer War, the story follows Harry “Breaker” Morant, Peter Handcock, and George Witton, three lieutenants facing a British military court over the killing of prisoners and a German missionary. Their defense is that they operated under orders that encouraged taking no prisoners, although those instructions conveniently lack the documentation needed to protect them. Assigned to defend them, Major J. F. Thomas finds himself fighting more than the prosecution’s evidence. He’s up against a military establishment whose political interests seem to require a particular outcome. The suspense comes less from discovering what happened than from wondering whether the court will acknowledge the circumstances surrounding it.

Beresford handles that material with an understated confidence. He doesn’t turn every exchange into a grand confrontation or bury the drama beneath swelling emotion. Instead, he lets the courtroom’s procedures become quietly suffocating. Questions, objections, and carefully phrased answers gradually reveal how much power rests with whoever controls the terms of the discussion. The flashbacks open up the film visually while complicating the testimony. Outside the courtroom, decisions emerge from exhaustion, anger, retaliation, and uncertainty. Inside it, those same decisions are discussed as though they occurred under conditions of perfect clarity. The contrast exposes the distance between fighting a war and explaining one afterward.

Edward Woodward gives Morant the combination of charisma and severity that the role needs. His Morant is articulate, proud, and capable of bitter humor, but there’s something stubbornly closed off about him too. Woodward never makes him so agreeable that the audience can comfortably overlook what he has done. At times, his confidence feels like courage; at others, it looks like a refusal to face the full meaning of his choices. That tension makes the performance work. We can sympathize with his predicament without being asked to believe that intelligence, charm, or mistreatment automatically makes someone morally right.

Bryan Brown’s Handcock is more openly irreverent, and his blunt humor gives the film some welcome breathing room. He has little patience for the court’s dignified performance of fairness, and Brown makes that contempt entertaining without removing the character’s darker edges. Lewis Fitz-Gerald brings a more exposed, youthful quality to Witton, emphasizing how differently the three men experience their situation. Jack Thompson, meanwhile, gives Thomas a decency that never feels sugary. His growing frustration becomes our way into the proceedings. He keeps searching for an argument that will make the court listen, even as it becomes increasingly doubtful that listening is the point.

The film’s central concern is the relationship between obedience and abandonment. Commanders demand that men finish the mission, crush resistance, and do whatever the situation supposedly requires. The practical message is that results matter more than restraint. But when those methods become difficult to defend publicly, the men carrying them out discover that their superiors’ expectations are much harder to prove than their own actions. In the film’s telling, the chain of command becomes a one-way arrangement: authority flows downward, but responsibility never travels back up. The soldiers are expected to understand what their commanders want without expecting those commanders to stand beside them afterward.

That betrayal is especially ugly because it exploits the loyalty military service depends on. Men are trained to trust their superiors and act decisively under pressure, yet afterward they may be judged as though they acted entirely independently. Breaker Morant captures the cruelty of that switch. The institution can encourage brutality through implication, tolerate it while it remains useful, and then present punishment as proof of its own moral seriousness. Discarding a few men allows everyone above them to look cleaner. Justice becomes less a full accounting of responsibility than a way of drawing a protective line around the people who still have power.

Still, the defense that the men followed orders cannot settle everything, and the film is most interesting when it leaves that discomfort intact. Killing prisoners doesn’t become acceptable because a superior encouraged it. Personal responsibility matters, even within a corrupt or hypocritical system. The troubling question is why that responsibility should stop with the men closest to the victims. Beresford makes a strong case that condemning individual crimes and examining command responsibility belong together. The defendants don’t need to be innocent for the proceedings to be compromised. Their guilt, where established, shouldn’t function as an excuse to stop asking who created the conditions in which they acted.

The film does, however, lean so heavily toward the accused that the people they killed receive much less attention. Their suffering can become background to the more fully developed suffering of the defendants. That imbalance limits the film’s moral reach, even as it strengthens its emotional pull. Its account of disputed orders and political scapegoating also needs to be understood as a dramatic interpretation rather than an unquestionable historical verdict. Yet those reservations don’t diminish the skill of the filmmaking. They make it worth watching critically, recognizing both the force of its argument and the places where its sympathies narrow our view.

By the end, the courtroom’s formalities feel more chilling than reassuring. Everyone has a role, the procedures have been observed, and the machinery can keep moving once these particular men are gone. That is what gives Breaker Morant its lasting sting. Beresford doesn’t simply show soldiers discovering that war is cruel; he shows them discovering that their own side’s loyalty has limits they were never told about. With its measured direction and deeply felt performances, the film leaves behind a bitter question: when commanders demand dirty work but refuse to own the consequences, what exactly is the honor they claim to defend?

Man-Thing (2005, directed by Brett Leonard)


Kyle Williams (Matthew Le Nevez), the newly appointed sheriff of a Louisiana parish, wants to know why so many people have disappeared in the swamp. Oilman Frederick Schist (Jack Thompson) puts the blame on activist Rene LaRoque (Steve Bastoni), who lives in the swamp and has been vandalizing Schist’s oil rigs. Indigenous shaman Horn (Rawiri Paratene) suggests that the culprit is actually a legendary spirit that lives in and protects the swamp and is angry because Schist cheated the local Seminole chief out of his land.

Loosely based on one of Marvel’s most endearingly weird characters, Man-Thing had a modest budget, decent special effects, and an insanely detailed swamp. It also had a lot more gore and nudity than the usual comic-book adaptation. What it didn’t have was a decent script or a cast that could do much with what they were given. (The great Australian actor Jack Thompson is ludicrous in the role of Frederick Schist.) Considering how simple the plot is, Man-Thing has a lot of head-scratching moments. If the Man-Thing has been summoned to protect the swamp from the oil companies and the rednecks, why does it also kill a Native shaman? In the comic books, at least, the Man-Thing had once been a man before he was transformed into a swamp monster. In this one, there’s no real origin for the creature. This movie could just as easily have been called Plant-Thing.

Man-Thing was actually one of the most interesting characters introduced when Marvel started publishing horror comics in the 1970s. Formerly a biochemist named Ted Sallis, Man-Thing lived in the Everglades and could detect emotions. His touch could burn, but only if the person being touched was afraid of him. With no memory of his former life as a human, Man-Thing was the guardian of the Nexus of All Realities. When Man-Thing got his own series, writer Steve Gerber gave him an eccentric and colorful supporting cast, including Howard the Duck and teenage sorceress Jennifer Kale. The comic-book Man-Thing provided a lot of good material for a potential film, so it’s too bad that this version turned him into just another swamp monster.

Man-Thing was originally meant to be a theatrical release but was dumped onto the Sci Fi Channel instead. (It did get a brief theatrical release in a few international markets, including Spain, where it bombed.) In the later Marvel Cinematic Universe, the character played a supporting role in 2022’s Werewolf by Night, so who knows? Maybe he’ll get the film he deserves someday.

Horror Film Review: Wake In Fright (dir by Ted Kotcheff)


To be honest, it’s probably open for debate whether or not Wake In Fright is actually a horror film.

This 1971 Australian film, which tells the story of a school teacher who becomes stranded in a small town in the outback, doesn’t feature any ghosts or werewolves or vampires or zombies or anything else of a supernatural nature.  The school teacher meets a large number of people in town, the majority of whom are technically quite friendly.  They teach him how to gamble.  They take him on a hunt.  They give him shelter when he doesn’t have anywhere else to stay.  The word “mate” is tossed around so frequently that it soon becomes clear that every man — significantly, there’s only two women in the film and one of them only appears in the teacher’s memories — in the outback is considered to be one.

The people of town of Bundanyabba — or “The Yabba,” as they call it — are also very generous with their beer.  If they meet you for the first time, they expect you to have a beer with them.  If they see you for the first, second, or third time during the day, they expect you to have a beer with them.  They wake up in the morning drinking and they go to bed drunk.  When John Grant (Gary Bond) first shows up in the Yabba, he can barely handle two beers.  By the end of his stay, he’s drinking nonstop.

However, John also discovers that it dangerous to turn down those offers of beer.  Turn down a beer and you might get a strange look, if you’re lucky.  More likely, you’ll get yelled at.  Turn down a beer from the wrong person and you might even get attacked.  Everyone in the Yabba is friendly but everyone is also always on the verge of throwing the first punch.  Refuse a beer and you might be in trouble.  Refuse to enthusiastically take part in a savage and sadistic kangaroo hunt and your mates might starts to talk.  When John first arrives, he’s a bit amused by the town and what he sees as being its backwards ways.  It’s obvious that he looks down on the people around him and one can sense that they realize that.  Perhaps that’s why everyone around him seems to take such joy in watching John slowly lose his identity.

That’s horror at the heart of Wake in Fright.  It’s not the horror of the paranormal.  Instead, it’s the horror of the isolation.  There’s no way to fight the isolation and the madness it brings.  Your only choice is to either surrender to it or be destroyed by it.  The longer John spends in the Yabba, the more the bleakness of the outback gets to him.  It’s a world dominated by brutal men, none of whom are particularly impressed when they find out that John’s teacher and that he has a suitcase full of books.  They view John as being soft and, in order to prove that he’s not, John starts to sacrifice his identity.  He starts to become just as much of a brute as Dick (Jack Thompson) and Joe (Peter Whittle).

Having lost all of his money, John eventually ends up staying with Doc Tydon (Donald Pleasence).  Doc really is a doctor.  He’s also, as he cheerfully explains, an alcoholic.  When John says that he’s going to find some place else to stay, Doc makes it clear that John isn’t leaving.  The film makes good use of Pleasence’s eccentric screen presence.  Is Doc simply being friendly or does Doc have more sinister motives fueling his insistence that John stay with him?  When Doc gives John advice, is it to help him or is it to further degrade John?  Like John, Doc is an educated man and obviously smarter than those around him.  And yet, Doc seems very happy in the mad world of the Yabba, drinking, hunting, and gambling.  Is John destined to become Doc or can he escape?

John discovers that leaving the Yabba isn’t easy.  Every time he tries, he ends up back in town.  All roads seems to lead back to the Yabba.  In retrospect, perhaps the most frightening thing about Wake In Fright is that no one seems to be surprised by the sight of the increasingly disheveled and unstable John.  Even when he stumbles through town while carrying a rifle, no one gives him a second look.  He’s just another part of the scenery.

No, Wake In Fright is not a traditional horror film but it’s a horror film, nonetheless.  It’s about the horror of not only losing your identity but perhaps not being quite sure what your identity was in the first place.  As played by Gary Bond, John is an often frustrating character but you never stop caring about him.  It’s frightening to watch him lose himself, even while you wonder if he ever knew who he truly was in the first place.  Bond was a stage actor who only appeared in three films.  Wake in Fright was his final film and one of the huge reasons why it’s so effective is because Gary Bond is not an actor who we recognize from other films.  We don’t seen an actor when we look at him.  Instead, we see a person who, for the first time, is discovering just how unsettling life on the fringes can be.

It’s a powerful film and a controversial one.  When John is taken on a kangaroo hunt, footage from an actual hunt was included in the film and it’s a horrific sequence, one that’s made all the more disturbing by the fact that the hunters refuse to acknowledge just how horrific and unjust it all is.  Reportedly, when Wake In Fright was first released, someone in a Sydney theater stood up and shouted at the screen, “This is not us!”  Actor Jack Thompson, who made his film debut in Wake In Fright, was in the audience and shouted back, “It is us, mate!  Sit down!”

For a long time, it was impossible to see Wake In Fright.  Only one known print was known to exist and it was a badly damaged one.  Fortunately, in 2002, another print was found in Pittsburgh and Wake In Fright was rereleased and rediscovered.  When it was first released in 1971, the film’s violence and downbeat atmosphere were both controversial and it struggled at the Australian box office.  (Many Australians, like that theatergoer in Sydney, initially viewed the film as being a bit of a personal attack.)  Rereleased in 2003 and championed by Martin Scorsese, Wake In Fright was embraced by a new generation of critics, many of whom declared it to be one of the greatest and most important Australian films ever made.

Wake In Fright is a powerful and unsettling film, a portrait of a place that seems to be fueled by toxic masculinity and self-destruction.  It’s a disturbing film and not easy to watch.  But if you do watch it, it will stick with you and leave you thinking long after the final credits roll.

A Movie A Day #352: Mad Dog Morgan (1976, directed by Philippe Mora)


Though he may not be as internationally well-known as Ned Kelly, Dan “Mad Dog” Morgan was one of the most infamous bushrangers in 19th century Australia.  Much as with the outlaws of American west, it is sometimes difficult to separate the fact from the legend when it comes to Mad Dog Morgan but it is agreed with Morgan has one of the most violent and bloodiest careers of the bushrangers.  Whether Morgan was a folk hero or just a ruthless criminal depends on which source you choose to believe.

In Mad Dog Morgan, Dennis Hopper plays Morgan as being the ultimate outsider.  Though the real Morgan was believed to have been born to Irish immigrants in New South Wales, the film presents Morgan as being the immigrant, an Irishman who ends up in Australia searching for gold and who is disgusted when he sees the way that the colonial authorities run the country.  Addicted to opium and angered by the casual brutality and corruption that he sees all around him, Morgan fights back and soon ends up in prison where he spends years being abused and raped.  It is all intended to break his spirit but, instead, Morgan comes out of prison even more determined to seek revenge on any and all figures of authority.  Working with a fellow outsider, an Aborigine named Billy (David Gulpilil, from Nicolas Roeg’s Walkabout), Morgan blazes a bloody and self-destructive trail across Australia.

Mad Dog Morgan was made long before Hopper cleaned up his act and became on of America’s favorite character actors.  This is Hopper back when he was still one of the most unpredictable and dangerous actors around.  By many accounts, Hopper was in the throes of drug-induced psychosis during the filming of Mad Dog Morgan, which makes it all the more remarkable that Hopper still gave one of his best performances as the legendary bushranger.  (For proof of how authentic Hopper feels in the role, compare his performance to Mick Jagger’s in Ned Kelly.)  Hopper was an outlaw playing an outlaw and his full commitment to the role is obvious from the start.  Featuring brutal action and a cast of talented Australian character actors, (Jack Thompson, Bruce Spence, Bill Hunter, and Hugh Keays-Byrne all have roles) Mad Dog Morgan is an essential film for fans of both Australian cinema and Dennis Hopper.

Trailer: Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark


I love films, all films, in general but if there’s one particular film genre that really floats my boat then it would be in the horror category. This summer will see the release of a title that I’ve been anticipating since I heard about it at last year’s San Diego Comic-Con. The film I speak of is the remake of the 1973 tv horror film of the same name: Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark.

While Troy Nixey takes the director’s chair for this film he’s working on a story written by Guillermo Del Toro who’s been known to dabble in the horror genre (Cronos, The Devil’s Backbone). Del Toro promised a horror film that would bring back horror the way it’s meant to be and that’s with genuine scares and not horror predicated on torture and extreme use of gore. Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark will be a throwback to the atmospheric, almost gothic horror, that reached it’s peak during the late 70’s before the slasher boom hit.

The film has been delayed several times as Miramax Films was sold by Disney and the restructuring of the studio after it’s owners finalized it’s purchase put the film on the backburner. It now has an official August 26, 2011 release and it looks like the film got an R-rating from the MPAA for “pervasive scariness”. While Del Toro, Nixey and the rest of the film crew were hoping for a PG-13 rating the one given by the MPAA who seemed to really enjoy said “pervasive scariness” recommended it go out as an R-rated horror (one with little to no gore).

So, we have an upcoming horror film by an upcoming filmmaker handpicked by Del Toro. A film written by Del Toro himself and one which just got an R-rating which made Del Toro as happy as a clam. Plus, it’s a horror film that relies on genuine scares and not gore. My answer to that is August 26, 2011 cannot come sooner.