Film Review: Bataan (dir. by Tay Garnett)


“We’re still here! We’ll always be here!” — Sergeant Bill Dane

The most effective thing about Tay Garnett’s Bataan (1943) is that it makes a small patch of ground feel like the entire world. There’s a bridge to keep destroyed, an enemy moving closer, and a group of men running out of ways to stay alive. That’s pretty much the movie, but Garnett gets plenty out of those ingredients. Rather than building excitement around where the soldiers will go next, he makes their inability to go anywhere the central problem. It’s a war film driven by waiting, and its best moments make that waiting feel almost unbearable.

Set during the American retreat in the Philippines, the story follows thirteen men assigned to demolish a bridge and stop Japanese forces from rebuilding it. Their mission is a delaying action, which immediately gives the usual military objective a troubling wrinkle. Completing the job doesn’t mean they’ll be rescued or even improve their own chances. It simply means somebody else might gain a little time. The film keeps bringing that uncomfortable bargain into focus. Every hour the men hold their position has value, but they’re the ones who have to pay for it.

Robert Taylor anchors the film as Sergeant Bill Dane, and his performance fits that emphasis on carrying on without much encouragement. Dane isn’t an especially complicated character on paper, but Taylor gives his toughness an increasingly strained quality. He looks like a man who understands that letting his exhaustion show could become everybody else’s problem. What works isn’t just his ability to bark orders or look determined. It’s the impression that maintaining authority takes effort. As the situation deteriorates, his leadership becomes less about having answers than about keeping the absence of answers from breaking the group.

Around him, the supporting players supply the personality that the narrow setting needs. Lloyd Nolan’s abrasive presence keeps the group from becoming too comfortably united, while Thomas Mitchell, Robert Walker, and Desi Arnaz help give the unit some variety. Not everybody gets enough material to become a fully rounded person, though. There are stretches when the characters feel assembled according to a familiar wartime formula, with individual traits standing in for deeper characterization. Still, those quick sketches have a practical purpose. Once the fighting starts reducing the group, we recognize who’s missing, and the position feels emptier in more than a numerical sense.

Garnett makes particularly good use of the jungle, even when it’s obviously a studio creation. The artificiality can be distracting if you’re looking for convincing outdoor realism, but it also gives the film a strangely enclosed atmosphere. Trees, shadows, and fog seem to mark the edges of a world the soldiers can’t escape. There’s no reassuring sense of geography, no broad view that lets us organize the danger. Instead, the surrounding space stays uncertain. The enemy might be approaching, watching, or already closer than anyone realizes. The setting keeps turning the simple act of looking into the distance into a source of tension.

That uncertainty matters because Bataan isn’t consistently fast-paced. At roughly 114 minutes, it gives plenty of room to stretches between attacks, and some of the dialogue feels more functional than revealing. A little tightening wouldn’t hurt. Even so, the slower passages aren’t merely obstacles between the exciting bits. They establish a rhythm of temporary relief followed by renewed dread. Exhaustion and malaria further undermine the idea that survival depends only on fighting well. These men can do what they’re supposed to do and still find their bodies failing them. The longer they remain in place, the less control they seem to have.

When violence does break out, its closeness makes it unpleasant rather than exhilarating. Bayonet fighting and sudden encounters strip away the comfortable distance that can make screen combat resemble a tactical exercise. The men aren’t moving neatly toward victory; they’re trying to get through the next confrontation with whatever strength remains. That’s also where the ensemble becomes important. The film’s racially mixed group, including a Black serviceman presented as a capable participant, gives its vision of collective effort some substance. Cooperation isn’t just a sentiment expressed in speeches. It’s something the assignment requires, regardless of the differences between the men carrying it out.

The limits of that vision are hard to miss, however. The Japanese largely exist as an anonymous threat, denied the individuality the film grants its American characters. That reflects its function as wartime propaganda, but it also narrows the drama. We’re encouraged to understand one group’s fear while treating the other primarily as its cause. The patriotic emphasis can become similarly blunt, especially when the movie pushes its message instead of trusting the situation to speak for itself. Still, its most persuasive passages don’t need much explanation. A depleted group, an exposed position, and another attack already tell us what endurance costs.

What stays with me about Bataan isn’t the promise that sacrifice will make everything worthwhile. It’s the uncomfortable distance between doing a necessary job and ever knowing what that job accomplished. The men can defend their position, follow orders, and support one another, but they can’t see the larger outcome their suffering is supposed to serve. That uncertainty gives the film weight beyond its rallying message. For all its familiar types and forceful patriotism, it understands something bleak about military duty: sometimes the task is clear, the price is enormous, and the people paying it never get to see the result.

Film Review: Lucy and Desi (dir by Amy Poehler)


If you were as disappointed with Being the Ricardos as I was but you still want to learn something about the lives and the marriage of Lucille Ball and Desi Arnaz, might I suggest checking out Lucy and Desi?

Directed by Amy Poehler, Lucy and Desi covers much of the same material as Being the Ricardos but it does so in a far more authentic way.  This is because Lucy and Desi is a documentary, one featuring actual interviews and recordings from Lucy, Desi, and the people who worked with them through the years.  As a result, we get to hear the story in their own words as opposed to Aaron Sorkin’s words.  I’m hardly the first person to point out that Aaron Sorkin is incapable of writing dialogue that doesn’t sound like something that Aaron Sorkin himself would say.  In Being the Ricardos, Lucy and her writers all spoke in Sorkinese and it all felt rather false.  Watching Lucy and Desi, you quickly realize that both Lucy and Desi were intelligent and articulate people.  Their own words are strong enough, without needing a polish from a screenwriter who, by his own admission, never found I Love Lucy to be all that funny.

Lucy and Desi covers the early lives of both Lucy and Desi as well as detailing how they first met, how they married, and how they went on to revolutionize television with I Love Lucy.  More than just being portrayed as being a talented but somewhat volatile couple, both Lucy and Desi emerges as fascinating individuals in their own right.  Both of them survived childhood difficulties, both of them remade themselves in Hollywood, and, most importantly, both of them had an instinctive understanding of what audiences wanted to see.

They were also very much in love, even after their divorce.  That love was missing from Being the Ricardos but it’s very much present in Lucy and Desi.  It was that love that led to the marriage that led to the partnership that made them a success but it was that same success that eventually led to the end of their marriage.  And yet, even after divorcing, Lucy and Desi remained close.  Their daughter, Lucie Arnaz, talks about the last few times that Lucy saw Desi before Desi’s succumbed to lung cancer.  They watched old episodes of I Love Lucy and they laughed together.  It’s an incredibly touching moment.

And if sentimentality isn’t your thing, Lucy and Desi also explores just how important their partnership was to the development of modern television.  I Love Lucy was the first “modern” sitcom but their company, Desilu Productions, had a hand in producing several other classic shows as well.  Star Trek was a Desilu production.  So were Mission Impossible and The Untouchables.  So much of what we take for granted about pop culture started with Lucy and Desi.

Perhaps the most shocking revelation in the Lucy and Desi documentary is that the J. Edgar Hoover story was true!  You may remember that, when I reviewed Being the Ricardos, I scoffed at the scene where Hoover called the studio and personally cleared Lucy of being a communist.  But apparently, this actually did happen!  I’m as stunned as anyone.

Lucy and Desi is a good and heartfelt tribute to Lucy and Desi, their talent and their love and their lasting influence.  It can be viewed on Prime.