(I’m currently cleaning out my DVR and right now, I kinda suspect that a comic book movie might get a best picture nomination before I ever get finished. By that, I mean that this is taking forever! But, no matter! I’m having fun. Anyway, I recorded A Neighbor’s Deception off of Lifetime on April 8th.)
Welcome to the neighborhood!
And what a neighborhood it is. Big house, big yards, big SUVs, and … wait, where are all the people? Chloe (Ashley Bell) and Michael Anderson (Adam Mayfield) have just bought a new house in this neighborhood and everything should be perfect. Chloe has had her struggles and, from the first minute we see her, it’s obvious that she’s not exactly stable. She’s nervous and a bit too quick to smile. Michael feels that the new neighborhood will be perfect for Chloe.
While Michael goes to work during the day, Chloe runs and takes pictures. It’s a beautiful neighborhood, surrounded by wonderful scenery. And yet, there’s something off about it. The streets and sidewalks often seem to be strangely deserted The first time that Chloe sees her neighbor, he’s driving past her and he barely acknowledges her.
It’s not until later that Chloe and Michael finally meet their neighbors face-to-face. Gerald (Tom Amandes) and Cheryl Dixon (Isabella Hoffman) seems like their friendly enough but there are hints that everything may not be perfect with them. For one thing, Gerald is considerably more friendly than Cheryl. Gerald is also a retired psychologist and starts to counsel Chloe for free. He says he’s just doing it to be a good neighbor but are his motives truly pure?
That’s what Chloe being to wonder. It doesn’t help that she’s soon getting mysterious phone calls from a man who blames Gerald for the death of his sister. The man wants Chloe to investigate Gerald and his past. Chloe agrees but is her paranoia justified or, as Michael suggests, is she on the verge of having another breakdown?
Written by noted horror expert Adam Rockoff, A Neighbor’s Deception is a hundred times more creepy than the usual Lifetime film. Wisely, both the script and the direction puts the emphasis on atmosphere. That big and oddly empty neighborhood becomes as much of a character as Chloe, Michael, Gerald, and Cheryl. This is one of those films that seems to have literally been bathed in a tub full of existential dread. As we watch, we find ourselves wondering if the neighborhood is really as creepy as it looks or if maybe Chloe’s paranoia is rubbing off on us.
Chloe is played by Ashley Bell, who some will recognize as being the “possessed” girl in The Last Exorcism. Bell gives an excellent performance in this film. She’s immediately sympathetic but, at the same time, she plays the role with just enough a nervous edge that you’re always aware that she could be imagining things. (Bell is often framed in the scene so that she’s seen alone, reinforcing the feeling that Chloe is not quite living in the real world.) Also deserving of credit is Tom Amandes, who is all dapper menace as Gerald.
A Neighbor’s Deception ends with a twist that won’t necessarily take you by surprise but no matter. The journey makes it all worh it.