Film Review: Pork Chop Hill (dir. Lewis Milestone)


“The value of Pork Chop is that it’s worth nothing.” — Lieutenant Joe Clemons

Lewis Milestone’s Pork Chop Hill (1959) is the kind of war movie that makes taking an objective look a lot less impressive than surviving it. There is no beautiful prize waiting at the summit, just torn-up ground, exhausted soldiers, and the possibility of another attack. Starring Gregory Peck as Lieutenant Joe Clemons, the film follows an American company ordered to retake a Korean hill while armistice negotiations grind along elsewhere. Its central question is uncomfortable: what happens when military courage gets put to work defending something that matters mostly because neither side wants to admit it doesn’t?

What makes the movie stick is its refusal to separate the soldiers’ bravery from the futility of their situation. These men can perform extraordinary acts without making the larger operation seem sensible. Milestone doesn’t treat that contradiction as something a stirring speech can clear up. Instead, it hangs over the fighting, making every bit of progress feel provisional. You can admire the men struggling up the slope while wondering why anyone should have to climb it. That tension gives Pork Chop Hill its bite: respect for the people doing the fighting never requires unquestioning respect for the decisions keeping them there.

Peck is a strong choice for Clemons because his authority feels practical rather than flashy. He gives the film a steady center without turning the lieutenant into a superhero who can personally fix a collapsing operation. Clemons has to keep people moving, work out what is happening, and hold together a force being steadily worn down. The performance works best as a portrait of leadership reduced to immediate responsibilities. Grand strategy is somebody else’s department; keeping the next position from being overrun is his. Peck’s restraint fits a film interested less in heroic posing than in the exhausting work behind survival.

Woody Strode provides an especially valuable counterweight as Private Franklin, a soldier who has no interest in dying to prove a point about Korea. Strode gives Franklin’s resistance an angry, defensive edge that makes him more interesting than a stock soldier who loses his nerve. His physical presence makes the contrast striking: looking powerful does not mean feeling willing to sacrifice yourself. When Franklin confronts Clemons, the clash brings the movie’s larger questions down to a painfully personal level. Why should this particular man give his life for this particular hill? Strode makes that question feel urgent rather than abstract.

Franklin’s bitterness also carries a racial dimension. His reference to the conditions he lives in back home complicates any easy appeal to patriotism: he is being asked to risk everything for a country whose treatment of him gives him reasons to feel alienated. The film ultimately steers him toward solidarity with the other soldiers, and Clemons answers his objections by emphasizing their shared danger and hardship. That resolution is not entirely satisfying, since it moves past Franklin’s specific grievances rather quickly. Still, Strode gives the character enough wounded pride and frustration that his objections remain worth considering even after the story pushes him back into the fight.

Milestone’s handling of combat has a nuts-and-bolts quality. Movement, communication, reinforcement, and relief become matters of life and death rather than background details. Orders do not automatically produce results, and information moving away from the battlefield does not necessarily describe what is actually happening there. The film makes the gap between the front line and higher command feel dangerous in itself. A position can look secure to someone elsewhere while the men occupying it know they are barely hanging on. That disconnect is more unsettling than a straightforward story about one obviously foolish officer making one obviously disastrous decision.

Most importantly, Pork Chop Hill doesn’t flinch from the meat grinder. Its violence matters through accumulation: men disappear from the fighting strength, exhaustion builds, and holding the same battered ground becomes harder. This isn’t simply a matter of whether an older film shows enough blood for modern tastes. The horror comes from the sense that human beings are being fed into an argument that has no natural stopping point. The enemy loudspeaker adds another ugly layer, reminding the Americans that they may die for a position being debated by people safely removed from it. Psychological pressure becomes part of the battlefield’s machinery.

The trap extends to both sides, even though the film’s emotional viewpoint stays firmly with the Americans. Chinese troops are also being committed to a struggle whose importance comes from what possession supposedly proves. That distinction matters. The movie does not offer an equally intimate portrait of both armies, but its political framework suggests a shared predicament: soldiers must keep paying because their leaders cannot afford to look unwilling to pay. The hill becomes a test of determination, and every sacrifice helps create the justification for another. It is a brutal circular argument, carried out with artillery and infantry instead of words.

The ceasefire negotiations make that argument especially bitter. Rather than presenting the fighting and diplomacy as separate activities, the film shows how closely they are connected. Leaders understand that the hill’s importance is not really in the ground itself. What matters is whether surrendering it might weaken their position at the negotiating table or suggest that their willingness to fight has run out. Neither side wants to blink. Peace is being discussed while men are being asked to demonstrate that the war could continue, which gives the battle an almost unbearable absurdity. The prospect of an agreement does not stop the killing; it helps explain its immediate purpose.

There is an important historical qualification here. The film dramatizes the April 1953 fighting, not the later July battle that ended with American withdrawal. The battles became controversial because of the casualties incurred over terrain widely described as having little or no strategic or tactical value. Still, “worthless” needs a little unpacking: the hill could lack meaningful military value while acquiring symbolic importance in negotiations. That does not make the losses easier to justify. It explains how commanders could recognize the ground’s limited usefulness and nevertheless insist that abandoning it would carry consequences beyond the battlefield.

As a movie, Pork Chop Hill is strongest when it lets that contradiction emerge through the soldiers’ immediate problems. Its matter-of-fact approach can feel emotionally spare, and viewers looking for extensive personal histories may find its concentration on the operation limiting. But that narrowness also has force. The men’s lives have been compressed into getting forward, finding support, maintaining contact, and lasting long enough to be relieved. Strode’s scenes puncture that operational focus just enough to remind us that each soldier brings his own reasons for resisting or accepting what is demanded of him. These are people, not simply a dwindling number on a commander’s report.

For all its toughness, Pork Chop Hill never makes toughness look like much of a reward. What stays with you is the sheer effort required to get through another stretch of fighting, followed by the realization that surviving it may simply mean being available for the next attack. Peck’s grounded authority, Strode’s simmering resistance, and Milestone’s stripped-down approach make that experience compelling without making it inviting. It’s a gripping war film, but not a comfortable one to cheer along with. By the time it is over, who holds the hill feels less important than how many men have been used up proving that neither side will let it go.

Film Review: Moby Dick (dir. by John Huston)


“I’ll follow him around the Horn, and around the Norway maelstrom, and around perdition’s flames before I give him up.” — Captain Ahab

The most frightening thing in John Huston’s Moby Dick (1956) is not the enormous white whale. It is the certainty of a man who has decided that his suffering gives him the right to endanger everyone around him. That is what gives this seafaring adventure its bite. Beneath the harpoons, salt spray, and booming speeches is a story about a captain who turns personal pain into a collective mission. Huston gives Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick the scale of an old-fashioned Hollywood epic, but the film’s real strength is its uncomfortable understanding of how easily commanding leadership can slide into destructive obsession.

The story begins with Ishmael, played by Richard Basehart, looking for work and a little adventure at sea. He joins the crew of the Pequod expecting a whaling voyage, not a front-row seat to his captain’s unraveling. Captain Ahab has other plans. Having lost his leg to Moby Dick, he intends to hunt down the whale regardless of the danger or the ship’s actual business. The setup is straightforward, and that simplicity helps the movie. Even when the dialogue becomes grand and biblical, the central problem stays clear: everyone’s future rests in the hands of someone who no longer recognizes reasonable limits.

Gregory Peck makes that problem fascinating to watch. Ahab was a real change from the quiet, heroic roles Peck usually played, but he uses that familiar reserve rather than abandoning it. His captain has the upright bearing and controlled delivery of a man accustomed to being respected. What has changed is the purpose behind that authority. Despite working outside his usual screen personality, Peck plays an excellent Ahab, bringing quiet dignity to the simmering obsession eating away at him. There is something especially unsettling about watching an actor so associated with steadiness turn that quality into an expression of dangerous, immovable conviction.

Peck’s performance works best when he lets the anger sit beneath the surface. His stillness can suggest that Ahab has spent so long nursing his hatred that it no longer needs constant outward expression. When the speeches arrive, they feel like pressure finally escaping. The performance does have a theatrical edge, and some viewers may find his delivery too formal. For me, that formality mostly fits. Ahab is not simply having a bad voyage; he has built an entire identity around his grievance. Peck makes him seem like a man determined to maintain his grandeur even as his judgment falls apart.

Huston strengthens that impression by delaying Ahab’s full introduction. Before we properly meet the captain, we feel the uncertainty surrounding him, which gives his eventual appearance more weight. Meanwhile, Ishmael offers a welcoming way into the story. Basehart is not as commanding as Peck, but his openness serves a useful purpose: he lets us experience the voyage before Ahab’s will completely takes it over. The early scenes establish a working community with its own friendships, routines, and expectations. That matters because the crew must feel like people with lives of their own, not merely an audience for their captain’s speeches.

Leo Genn’s Starbuck provides the clearest challenge to Ahab’s thinking. He understands that a captain has responsibilities beyond satisfying his own anger, and his resistance gives the film an essential moral tension. This is not a simple contest between a brave man and a timid one. Starbuck’s caution requires its own courage, especially when Ahab can make his private revenge sound like a glorious shared purpose. Orson Welles also makes a memorable impression as Father Mapple. His sermon gives the opening a sense of spiritual danger, preparing us for a voyage in which pride and disobedience matter as much as wind and weather.

The film’s visual style reinforces that feeling without making every scene look like an obvious symbol. Cinematographer Oswald Morris gives the images a muted, weathered appearance that suits the roughness of the setting. This is not a sparkling ocean playground. The ship looks vulnerable against the water and sky, and even the beautiful views carry a hint of menace. Huston also understands the appeal of the practical details: ropes, boats, crowded decks, and men working together. Those textures keep the film grounded. The more convincing the ordinary labor becomes, the more disturbing it is when Ahab redirects that labor toward his own destructive goal.

As an adaptation, Moby Dick inevitably trades some of Melville’s range for dramatic focus. The screenplay, credited to Huston and Ray Bradbury, cannot accommodate all the novel’s digressions, shifting tones, and philosophical curiosity. Instead, it builds a clear line toward the confrontation between Ahab and the whale. That approach makes the film accessible, though it also narrows the experience. Ishmael becomes less of an expansive storytelling presence, while Ahab increasingly dominates everything. Still, the choice suits the movie’s central effect. We feel the voyage tightening around one man’s purpose until there seems to be very little room left for anyone else’s judgment.

The final hunt has moments when the effects show their age, particularly when the whale must function as a convincing physical creature. Yet the climax remains gripping because Huston has already established what is emotionally at stake. The important question is no longer whether the monster will look completely real. It is whether anyone can escape the consequences of Ahab’s certainty. That is why Moby Dick stays with me more as a tragedy than as a spectacle. Peck’s wounded dignity makes the captain worth watching, but never makes him right. By the end, the film has turned a thrilling pursuit into a bleak reminder that a leader’s strength means very little when he has lost the ability to turn back.

Horror Film Review: Cape Fear (dir. by Martin Scorsese)


“Every man… every man has to go through hell to reach paradise.” — Max Cady

There’s nothing subtle about the way Martin Scorsese’s Cape Fear gets under your skin. The music announces an approaching apocalypse, the camera seems unable to sit still, and Robert De Niro looks ready to chew through the scenery before anyone can stop him. Yet beneath all that noise is a nasty question: what happens when someone discovers the secret that makes your respectable life possible? This 1991 horror-thriller builds its terror around that vulnerability, turning a revenge story into a nightmare about being exposed. It’s wildly entertaining, even when its determination to overwhelm you becomes a little much.

A remake of J. Lee Thompson’s 1962 film of the same name, itself adapted from John D. MacDonald’s novel The Executioners, Cape Fear follows convicted rapist Max Cady after his release from prison. Cady, played by De Niro, has spent fourteen years nursing a grudge against his former defense attorney, Sam Bowden. Nick Nolte’s Sam withheld evidence that might have helped his client’s case, deciding that his disgust justified compromising Cady’s defense. Now Cady has come looking for him, and he isn’t satisfied with an apology. He wants to dismantle Sam’s life slowly enough that Sam understands exactly who is doing it.

Making Sam morally compromised is the remake’s smartest move. Rather than simply asking us to root for an innocent family against an evil outsider, Scorsese gives us a man whose professional betrayal has returned to haunt him. That doesn’t make Cady’s campaign remotely justified, but it complicates Sam’s position. He wants the protection of rules he previously decided didn’t apply to him. Every attempt to present himself as the reasonable, law-abiding party becomes harder to accept without qualification. The suspense comes partly from wondering what Cady will do next and partly from watching Sam struggle to maintain his version of himself.

Casting Nolte in the role previously played by Gregory Peck makes that shift especially convincing. Where Peck’s authoritative presence suited the original’s more upright protector, Nolte brings a battered, irritable quality that makes Sam’s respectability feel less secure. You believe this man may regret living in the law’s moral gray areas without having learned to stay out of them. When protecting his family means employing criminal methods, including arranging an assault on Cady, the decision feels like an extension of his character rather than a sudden reversal. Nolte makes the contradiction work: Sam wants to be decent, but he’ll use dirty resources when he decides the circumstances demand it.

De Niro makes those circumstances as uncomfortable as possible. His Cady is all tattoos, muscle, exaggerated politeness, and a Southern drawl that turns ordinary conversation into a threat. It’s a performance built around excess, and you can practically feel De Niro enjoying how far he can push it. That might sound like a criticism, but Cady is performing, too. He wants Sam to notice him, fear him, and recognize his control over the situation. Every appearance becomes a demonstration of power, with each smile suggesting he knows something everyone else would rather leave unspoken.

The character becomes more interesting, and less believable, as the film continues. Initially, Cady is a dangerous convict with a personal grudge and a talent for exploiting legal boundaries. Eventually, he resembles a boogeyman: impossibly resilient, seemingly everywhere, and almost impossible to keep out. Here the remake embraces more recent slasher-film tropes, moving beyond intimidation toward an unstoppable-killer nightmare. Practically speaking, that transformation gets ridiculous. Psychologically, though, it fits. Cady becomes a manifestation of Sam’s guilt, something that can be denied, attacked, or temporarily escaped, but never comfortably buried again. His persistence makes emotional sense even when his physical endurance strains credibility.

That idea connects the horror to the story’s Southern Gothic roots, which Scorsese emphasizes even more heavily than the original. Religious obsession, sexual menace, family dysfunction, and corruption beneath respectable surfaces create an overheated atmosphere. Cady treats revenge as a sacred mission, dressing cruelty in scripture and self-righteous declarations. Sam has his own history of deciding that moral certainty excuses misconduct. The men aren’t equivalent, but the echoes matter. Cady doesn’t introduce darkness into an innocent household so much as drag existing darkness into the open, where nobody can politely ignore it.

The Bowdens are already miserable enough to make that process convincing. Nolte gives Sam a prickly defensiveness, while Jessica Lange, as his wife Leigh, conveys the exhaustion of someone living with unresolved resentment. Their marriage feels strained before Cady applies pressure, making his interference more destructive. Occasionally, their hostility becomes so relentless that the family scenes feel almost as punishing as the stalking. Still, the performances ground the tension. These aren’t symbolic victims waiting to be threatened; they’re people whose existing problems make the threat harder to manage.

Juliette Lewis is especially good as their teenage daughter, Danielle, whose uncertainty makes her vulnerable to Cady’s attention. Their encounter at her school is the most unsettling sequence because it trades spectacle for something horribly intimate. Cady listens, flatters, and presents himself as someone who understands her better than her parents do. Lewis captures the mixture of curiosity, discomfort, and a teenager’s desire to appear older. The scene exposes the predatory calculation beneath Cady’s theatrical behavior. He doesn’t need physical force to gain control, which makes him scarier than his muscles ever could.

Scorsese surrounds these performances with filmmaking that rarely lets anyone breathe. Working with cinematographer Freddie Francis, he uses distorted perspectives, oppressive close-ups, lurid lighting, and restless camera movements to make ordinary surroundings threatening. Bernard Herrmann’s original score, adapted by Elmer Bernstein, adds an operatic sense of disaster. Sometimes the style shouts over an already effective scene, and restraint might have made certain moments sharper. But the commitment is impressive. By the storm-battered houseboat climax, everyday realism has disappeared, and the setting feels like an extension of the characters’ psychological collapse.

What makes Cape Fear stick isn’t simply whether the Bowdens can survive Cady. It’s the uglier possibility that survival won’t restore the comfortable story they once told about themselves. Scorsese pushes that idea through a thriller so outrageous that its moral complications occasionally get swallowed by spectacle. Nevertheless, Nolte keeps Sam’s contradictions recognizable beneath the chaos: a man who regrets crossing lines but remains willing to cross them again. Cady may become too indestructible to believe in as a person, yet he’s persuasive as the reckoning Sam cannot shut out. The locks were never going to be enough.

Brad ranks the nine J. Lee Thompson / Charles Bronson movies!


British director J. Lee Thompson was born on August 1, 1914. He directed some classics in the early 60’s, movies like THE GUNS OF NAVARONE (1961), where he received an Oscar nomination for Best Director, and the original CAPE FEAR (1962), which I personally consider superior to Scorsese’s 1991 remake. Gregory Peck, who starred in both films, once said there were only four directors he could trust to tell him whether or not he was faking his performance: Alfred Hitchcock, George Cukor, William Wyler and J. Lee Thompson. High praise indeed!

When the British film industry began caving in at the end of the decade, Thompson moved into Hollywood productions and continued to work steadily for the next couple of decades. He worked on films in all genres, like westerns (MACKENNA’S GOLD – 1968), science fiction (CONQUEST OF THE PLANET OF THE APES – 1972) and horror (HAPPY BIRTHDAY TO ME – 1981). After Thompson retired in 1989, he would sometimes lament that he had “sold out” his individual artistic desires in order to just keep working. But he would never be too hard on himself, because he enjoyed making movies and always brought professionalism and competence no matter the movie. 

The main reason I like J. Lee Thompson is because he would make 9 films with actor Charles Bronson from 1976 to 1989. With Thompson as director, you knew the film would always have a certain level of quality, and Bronson loved his fast, no-frills method of shooting. In celebration of Thompson’s 112th birthday in cinema heaven, I thought it might be fun to provide my ranking of those 9 films. So here we go! 

Messenger of Death

Coming in at #9 is MESSENGER OF DEATH (1988). Thompson is at his best during the incredibly tense and vicious opening sequence, but the script ultimately can’t keep the momentum going, and it’s one of Bronson’s more boring films. On some positive notes, it’s a different kind of movie for Bronson, more of a whodunnit than a straight action film. It has a strong cast, filled with veterans like John Ireland, Jeff Corey, and Trish Van Devere. It also has some beautiful Colorado scenery. 

Cabo Blanco

Next up at #8 is CABO BLANCO (1980). After years of poor video releases, Kino Lorber released the film on a special edition Blu-ray in 2016, which highlights how Thompson was able to capture the natural beauty of the Mexican locations. Bronson gives a committed performance as Giff Hoyt. The casting of legends like Jason Robards and Fernando Rey, in a fantastically corrupt turn, are a big plus as well. Unfortunately, the film’s script and story never really come together and the end doesn’t make much sense. 

Kinjite: Forbidden Subjects

Coming in at #7 is KINJITE: FORBIDDEN SUBJECTS (1989). This would be Thompson’s final film, and he goes out with a slick and sleazy thriller. In my opinion, KINJITE contains one of Bronson’s stronger Cannon performances, but the subject matter is particularly dark and ugly, with themes of child exploitation, human trafficking, sexual violence, and prejudice. I think it’s a good film, but you definitely need a bath afterwards. Juan Fernandez is odd and memorable as the villainous pimp, Duke. 

Death Wish 4: The Crackdown

For #6, I’m going with DEATH WISH 4: THE CRACKDOWN. After the bonkers outrageousness of DEATH WISH 3, Thompson took the reins from Michael Winner for this entry, and delivered a much more straightforward action film. There is so much action in DEATH WISH 4, and the oilfield shootout contains some of Bronson’s more iconic imagery of the 80’s. The film was a huge renter at the video store, the most successful of the entire franchise in that department. John P. Ryan is also gleefully over the top as the bad guy. 

The White Buffalo

At #5, I’m going with THE WHITE BUFFALO (1977). This western has grown on me over the years. Thompson is able to pull strong performances out of Charles Bronson and Will Sampson in the lead roles of Wild Bill Hickok and Crazy Horse. Combined with John Barry’s musical score, he’s able to give the film an eery, otherworldly quality with each appearance of the white buffalo. The film may have bombed at the box office, but it’s pretty darn good movie. 

The Evil That Men Do

At #4, I’m going with THE EVIL THAT MEN DO (1984). I’m especially appreciative of Thompson for his work on Bronson’s final badass hitman film. The original director, Fielder Cook, was fired and Thompson was brought in at the last minute with very little prep time. He was still able to deliver a violent, brutal thriller. This one has its rough moments, but I’ve always liked Bronson as the amoral instrument of justice. And his down-low takedown of the giant sexual predator in the slimy Mexican bar is one of the more memorable scenes in any action film!

St. Ives

Heading into the top 3, I’m going with ST. IVES (1976) at #3. In Thompson’s first movie with Bronson, he delivers a fun, little mystery thriller. I particularly enjoy Bronson’s performance as Ray St. Ives. He seems to always have a smile on his face as he makes his way through the various Los Angeles locations. With definitely less action than your average Bronson film, I enjoy the change of pace as well as the excellent supporting cast of veteran actors like John Houseman, Jacqueline Bisset, Maximillian Schell, Harry Guardino, Harris Yulin, Dana Elcar and Michael Lerner. Heck, Jeff Goldblum and Robert Englund even show up as some henchmen. This is Bronson at the peak of his movie stardom. 

Murphy’s Law

At #2, I make an extremely personal choice with MURPHY’S LAW (1986). While the film is definitely an 80’s Cannon time capsule, this is one of two movies that kicked off my lifelong obsession with Charles Bronson, with the other being DEATH WISH 3. Thompson keeps the action moving efficiently from one set piece to another as Jack Murphy and Arabella McGee (Kathleen Wilhoite) try to figure out who is framing him for the murder of his stripper ex-wife. Carrie Snodgress is enjoyably nuts as the bad lady. Not only have I watched this movie dozens of times, I have been blessed to meet the film’s composer (Val McCallum) and interview Murphy’s partner (Robert F. Lyons). This movie is just special to me in ways that critical analysis can never capture. 

10 To Midnight

And at #1 in my list of Bronson-Thompson collaborations, I choose the 1983 tough cop/slasher hybrid TEN TO MIDNIGHT. Charles Bronson is particularly strong as Leo Kessler, the veteran detective and dad who will go to any length to bring down a vicious, impotent killer of women, played brilliantly by Gene Davis. It has one of the best and most controversial endings of Bronson’s career. I give credit to Thompson for delivering an entertaining thriller that would appeal to an audience outside of Bronson’s normal fanbase. 10 TO MIDNIGHT would be a major player on premium cable channels like HBO. When I met my wife, she didn’t know who Bronson was, but she knew the film and loved it. Even though he was already an aging action star, the success of this movie propelled Bronson’s theatrical leading man career to the end of the 80’s. 

Thanks for all the memories, J. Lee. Your films have been an endless source of entertainment for me for over 40 years! Rest in peace, sir

J. Lee Thompson

American Images, Part Four


The Rat Pack by Phil Stern

We’re only a few hours away from America’s 250th birthday!  And what would an American birthday party be without some American celebrities of the present and the past?

Joan Crawford by Ruth Harriet Louise

Bobby Darin and Sandra Dee by Leo Fuchs

Marlon Brando by Leo Fuchs

Mary Badham and Gregory Peck by Leo Fuchs

Natalie Wood by Alan Grant

Marilyn Monroe and Jack Benny by Phil Stern

James Dean by Phil Stern

John Wayne by Phil Stern

Bruce Conner, Toni Basil, and Teri Garr by Dennis Hopper

Paul Newman by Dennis Hopper

Tuesday Weld by Dennis Hopper

Robert Downey, Jr. by Mary Ellen Mark

Meryl Streep by Mary Ellen Mark

Johnny Depp by Mary Ellen Mark

Scenes That I Love: Gregory Peck and Audrey Hepburn at The Mouth of Truth in Roman Holiday


Given how much I love the 1953 film, Roman Holiday, I’ve probably shared this scene before but that’s okay.  It’s an incredibly charming scene and hey, April is the birth month of both Gregory Peck and Audrey Hepburn!

Brad reviews SHOOT OUT (1971), starring Gregory Peck & Robert F. Lyons! 


After serving a stretch at the Canon City penitentiary, Clay Lomax (Gregory Peck) gets out with only one thing on his mind… revenge on his former partner Sam Foley (James Gregory), who shot him in the back during a bank robbery, leaving him to take the rap. Foley isn’t a fool, though, so he’s hired a trio of young punks, Bobby Jay (Robert F. Lyons), Skeeter (John Davis Chandler), and Pepe (Pepe Serna) to surveil Lomax and let him know if he’s heading to his home in Gun Hill with payback on his mind. These guys are about as crazy as it gets, and they make two major mistakes. First, they kill Lomax’s friend Trooper (Jeff Corey) who lets him know where Foley is with his dying breath. Second, they kidnap the prostitute Alma (Susan Tyrell) just because they want to treat her like crap and have fun with her, which turns out to be a dumb move. Interrupting Lomax’s quest for revenge, he finds himself being forced to care for a young child named Decky (Dawn Lyn), who just may be his daughter with a lady back in Kansas City who used to be his “friend.” Looking after Decky, and then meeting and falling for the widow Juliana Farrell (Patricia Quinn), Lomax is soon facing off against his most dangerous foe, the crazed Bobby Joe, as he attempts to protect all these new people that he loves so he can move on with his life. But is it all too late?!!

I love westerns, but I must admit that I’m not the biggest fan of director Henry Hathaway’s SHOOT OUT. Hathaway has directed some of my favorite actors and movies, like Charles Bronson’s debut film with Gary Cooper, YOU’RE IN THE NAVY NOW (1951), along with the Jimmy Stewart film CALL NORTHSIDE 777 (1948) and John Wayne’s Oscar winning TRUE GRIT (1969). Unfortunately, it seems his best years are behind him, and he would only direct one more film after this, the less than excellent black action film HANGUP (1974). This isn’t exactly Gregory Peck’s best work either. Coming nine years after his Oscar winning performance in TO KILL A MOCKINGBIRD (1962), this is definitely not even close to that kind of level. Don’t get me wrong, I do enjoy his turn as Lomax when he’s the wronged outlaw looking for revenge, but I don’t really care at all for his part as the reluctant father figure trying to deal with the six-year-old Decky. I found Dawn Lyn to be more annoying than cute in the role, and this storyline distracted me from the revenge plot that I actually enjoyed. As a co-host of the “This Week in Charles Bronson Podcast,” we had the opportunity to interview Robert F. Lyons, who plays the bad guy, Bobby Jay Jones. I specifically asked him about this film and what it was like working with Gregory Peck. While he enjoyed working with Peck, his response about the film itself was telling…. “The work in there is not my work.” If you’ve watched much of the excellent actor’s work before, you can immediately understand what he means. Lyons goes so over-the-top as the spying outlaw Bobby Jay Jones, that his performance is inconsistent with the bulk of his career. Lyons told us that his performance was orchestrated by Hathaway in a way that he disagreed with, and he essentially disowns his work in the film. You can see a similar vibe with his “gang” that includes the actors John Davis Chandler and Pepe Serna. 

While I’m not a huge fan of the overall direction of the storyline or the focus of some of the main performances in SHOOT OUT, I am appreciative of the genre and the classic western stars that Hathaway cast in supporting roles. I especially enjoy seeing Jeff Corey in the small but pivotal role as the wheelchair bound Trooper, Paul Fix as the train brakeman who delivers Decky and a stack of cash to Lomax, and Arthur Hunnicutt as the ranch owner who barters with Lomax over the price of a pony. Hunnicutt is a particular favorite of mine although his role here is very small. Nominated for an Oscar for his performance in Howard Hawks’ THE BIG SKY (1952), Hunnicutt is from the small town of Gravelly, Arkansas, which is not far from where my own family is from. He even attended the same college that I graduated from, the University of Central Arkansas, which was known as the Arkansas State Teachers College when he (and my dad) went there. And then there is the setup of the revenge scenario at the beginning and the final showdown at the end, classic staples of the western genre. These are enjoyable and satisfying moments as Lomax settles his scores and the bad guys get their comeuppance.

Overall, SHOOT OUT is best enjoyed by fans of old school westerns and star Gregory Peck. It veers aways from the best storylines of the genre and wastes a lot of time with uninteresting melodrama, but it does offer us another chance to see some of our great character actors doing what they do. That means something to me. 

I’ve included our podcast episode with Robert F. Lyons below. He discusses SHOOT OUT at around the 1:00:30 mark.

Duel In The Sun (1946, directed by King Vidor)


After her father is executed for killing her mother and her mother’s lover, “half-breed” Pearl Chavez (Jennifer Jones) is sent to live with her father’s second cousin, Laura Beth McCanles (Lillian Gish).  Laura is the wife of rancher, politician, and all-around racist Senator Jackson McCanles (Lionel Barrymore).  Worried that Pearl’s beauty and uninhibited manner will get her into trouble, Laura arranges for Pearl to meet with a minister known as The Sinkller (Walter Huston) who instructs Pearl on how to be a “good” girl.

Wanting to make Pearl bad and his, Lewton “Lewt” McCanles (Gregory Peck) becomes obsessed with Pearl and is soon forcing himself on her on a regular basis.  When the good McCanles brother, Jesse (Joseph Cotten), leaves the ranch despite being in love with Pearl, Pearl tries to find a good husband in the form of Sam Pierce (Charles Bickford).  Lewt responds by gunning Sam down and then goes on the run.  It all leads to an overwrought duel in the sun as the two doomed lovers take aim at each other.

Duel In The Sun is credited to veteran director King Vidor and there are a few shots of the western landscape that do feel typical of Vidor’s work.  However, Duel In The Sun’s true auteur was its producer, David O. Selznick.  Still looking to recapture his earlier success with Gone With The Wind and eager to make his future wife, Jennifer Jones, into an even bigger star than she was, Selznick obsessed over every detail of Duel In The Sun, pushing Vidor and a host of other directors (including Josef von Sternberg, William Dieterle, William Cameron Menzies, Otto Brower, and Sidney Franklin)  to make the film more steamy, more melodramatic, more violent, and more visually epic.  Reportedly, while Video was trying to shoot the film’s titular duel, he had to call cut several times when Selznick ran into the scene with a water bottle to spray more “sweat” onto Jones and Peck.  Today, the stiff Peck seems miscast as the black sheep of the family, the reserved Jones is even more miscast as a mestiza, and the plot is clearly too simplistic to carry the film’s epic ambitions.  A few impressive shots aside, Duel In The Sun is just boring,  In the 40s, though, the film’s relative openness about sex generated enough controversy to make Duel In The Sun into a box office hit.  It was one of the two top-grossing westerns of the 40s, beating out Red River, My Darling Clementine, Fort Apache, The Ox-Bow Incident, and several other films that were actually good.

Unlike Jones, Peck, and even usually reliable stalwart like Lionel Barrymore and Walter Huston, Joseph Cotten at least emerges from this film with his dignity intact.  Playing the good brother, Cotten gets to underplay while everyone else is overplaying and it turns out to be the right approach for him.  Surviving Duel In The Sun was no easy feat but Cotten pulled it off.

Scenes That I Love: Gregory Peck in To Kill A Mockingbird


108 years ago today, the actor Gregory Peck was born in San Diego, California.  With his deep voice and his Lincolnesque profile, Peck was always best cast as a man of integrity who was willing to take a stand, even if it meant going against the majority.  That made him ideal for the role of attorney Atticus Finch in 1962’s To Kill A Mockingbird.

Today’s scene that I love comes from that film.  In this scene, Atticus makes his closing statement in the murder trial of Tom Robinson.  While Atticus is speaking to the jury, Gregory Peck is speaking to the audience in the theater (and later, in front of the television).  Reportedly, Peck only needed one take to perfectly deliver his speech.

Lisa Reviews An Oscar Nominee: Spellbound (dir by Alfred Hitchcock)


The 1945 Best Picture nominee, Spellbound, tells the story of Dr. Constance Petersen (Ingrid Bergman), a psychoanalyst at a mental hospital in my least favorite state, Vermont.

Constance has fallen in love with a man (Gregory Peck) who she believes to be Dr. Anthony Edwardes, the newly appointed director of the hospital.  Dr. Edwardes is youngish and handsome and idealistic and authoritative …. well, he’s Gregory Peck.  However, he also has an intense phobia about seeing any set of parallel lines.  Curious to discover the reason for Edwardes’s phobia, Constance does a little digging on her own and discovers that Dr. Anthony Edwardes is not a doctor at all!  Instead, he’s a guilt-stricken amnesiac who is convinced that he murdered Dr. Edwardes and took his place!

Constance, however, doesn’t believe that the Amnesiac is a murderer.  She thinks that he is suffering from some sort of deep-rooted guilt that had led him to believe that killed the doctor.  She wants a chance to psychoanalyze him and discover the truth about his background.  Unfortunately, the police do think that the Amnesiac is a murderer and their determined to arrest him.

Constance and the Amnesiac go on the run, heading to the home of Constance’s mentor, Dr. Alexander Brulov (Michael Chekhov, the nephew of Anton Chekhov).  With Brulov’s help, Constance analyzes a dream that the Amensiac had, one involving curtains decorated with eyes, the faceless proprietor of a casino, and a man falling off a mountain.  Can Constance and Brulov solve the mystery of the Amnesiac’s identity before the police take him away to prison?

Spellbound was the last of the four Hitchcock best picture nominees and it was also the last film that Hitchcock made for producer David O. Selznick.  Selznick was quite a fan of psychoanalysis and he insisted that Hitchcock not only make a movie about it but that he also use Selznick’s own therapist as a technical advisor on the project.  Hitchcock, for his part, was able to bring in the surrealist Salvador Dali to help design the Amnesiac’s dream sequence but Selznick felt that the 20-minute sequence was too long and too weird and, as a result, it was cut down to two minutes for the final film.  All this considered, it’s not a surprise that, despite the fact that Spellbound was a hit with critics and audiences, Hitchcock himself didn’t care much for it and considered it to be more of a Selznick film than a Hitchcock film.  And it is true that the film’s total faith is psychoanalysis feels more like something one would expect to hear from a trendy producer than from a director like Hitchcock, who was known for both his dark wit and his rather cynical attitude towards anyone in authority.

For a film like Spellbound to truly work, there has to be some doubt about who the Amnesiac is.  For the suspense to work, the audience has to feel that there’s at least a chance, even if it’s only a slight one, that the Amnesiac actually could be a murderer, despite the attempts of Constance and Brulov to prove that he’s not.  And Spellbound is full of scenes that are meant to leave the audience wondering about whether or not the Amnesiac should be trusted.  However, because the Amnesiac is played by Gregory Peck, there’s really no doubt that he’s innocent.  Hitchcock was not particularly happy with Gregory Peck as his leading man.  Peck projected a solid, middle-American integrity.  It made him ideal for heroic and crusading roles but made him totally wrong for any role that required ambiguity.  It’s difficult to believe that the Amnesiac is suffering from a guilt complex because it’s difficult to believe that Gregory Peck has ever done anything for which he should feel guilty.  Cary Grant could have played the Amnesiac.  Post-war Jimmy Stewart could have done an excellent job with the role.  But Peck is just too upstanding and stolid for the role.  In a role that calls from neurosis, Peck is kind of boring.

That said, the rest of the cast is fine, with Ingrid Bergman giving one of her best performance as Constance and Michael Chekhov bringing some needed nuance to a role that could have turned into a cliché.  Leo G. Carroll has a small but pivotal role and he does a good job keeping the audience guessing as to his motivation.  Even at a truncated two minutes, the Dali dream sequence is memorably bizarre and the famous shot of a gun pointed straight at the camera still carries a kick.  This is a lesser Hitchcock film but, that said, it’s still a Hitchcock film and therefore worth viewing.

As I mentioned previously, this was the last of Hitchcock’s films to be nominated for Best Picture.  Ironically, his best films — Rear Window, Vertigo, and Psycho among them — were yet to come. Spellbound was nominated for six Oscars but only won for Miklos Rozsa’s score.  (Ingrid Bergman was nominated for Best Actress that year, not for her role in Spellbound but instead for The Bells of St. Mary’s.)  The big Oscar winner that year was Billy Wilder’s The Lost Weekend.