
“Who’s to say that a lie is always bad? And who’s to say that the truth is always good?” — Kahei the Pilgrim
Nobody in Akira Kurosawa’s The Lower Depths (1957) seems capable of minding their own business, partly because nobody has enough space to have any. Conversations become arguments, private disappointments become public entertainment, and anyone trying to preserve a little dignity risks attracting an audience. It’s a miserable arrangement, but a terrific foundation for an ensemble film. Kurosawa turns a shabby tenement into a place where people constantly watch one another while rarely feeling understood. The surprise is how much life he finds there: not inspirational resilience, exactly, but the stubborn, funny, occasionally ugly energy of people who still have something to say.
Adapted from Maxim Gorky’s play, the film moves its setting from Russia to Edo-period Japan. Kurosawa and co-writer Hideo Oguni retain the basic situation of society’s castoffs living together, but the setting feels inhabited rather than imposed on imported material. Poverty here has a daily routine. People haggle, drink, remember better times, invent better times, and complain about whoever happens to be nearby. Before anyone starts discussing whether life has meaning, we understand what it means to live somewhere that offers almost no room for change. Philosophy grows out of the circumstances rather than arriving as an intellectual decoration.
The location does much of that work. With the tenement sitting below more respectable buildings, its residents occupy the bottom of a social order made physically visible. The presence of a temple above this misery also invites an uncomfortable question about the distance between spiritual institutions and suffering bodies. Inside, posts divide the frame, bodies crowd doorways, and people lie within earshot of conversations they supposedly aren’t part of. There’s nowhere to retreat without remaining available for comment. The place is a shelter, technically, but it can also feel like a trap everyone has learned to furnish with familiar grievances.
For a film so closely tied to the stage, The Lower Depths is remarkably alert to what a camera can reveal. Kurosawa doesn’t simply photograph whoever is speaking and then cut to the response. He arranges several points of interest within a shot, allowing reactions and secondary business to complicate the main exchange. Someone making a declaration in the foreground may have their importance quietly dismantled by a bored listener behind them. We’re not just receiving dialogue; we’re watching people decide which words deserve attention. That makes the film’s arguments feel socially alive rather than neatly packaged for our consideration.
The lack of a clear central character takes some adjustment. A thief’s romantic entanglements provide a recognizable dramatic thread, but the film keeps drifting toward other residents and other troubles. An alcoholic actor clings to fragments of his former identity. A dying woman suffers while life carries on around her. Others maintain shaky claims to status or tell stories that make their circumstances sound less humiliating. At first, the shifting focus can seem like a refusal to get going. Eventually, it becomes the point: nobody experiences their suffering as a supporting role in someone else’s more important story.
Toshiro Mifune’s thief supplies some forceful energy, though the ensemble keeps him from taking over. His hope of leaving with the woman he loves sounds modest beside the grand ambitions movies usually give their heroes. He wants a different place and a different life. Yet even that becomes an enormous demand. The romantic plot reveals how difficult an ordinary fresh start can be when desire has no dependable material support. Wanting to escape doesn’t mean knowing how, and being sincere doesn’t protect anyone from jealousy, manipulation, or the consequences of a bad decision.
Then Kahei arrives, played by Bokuzen Hidari, and introduces a different way of dealing with people. The elderly pilgrim listens. In a room where vulnerability usually invites ridicule, that alone feels significant. Hidari gives him an unhurried gentleness that changes the rhythm of his scenes without making him entirely knowable. He comforts the dying woman and tells the actor about the possibility of treatment for his drinking. These exchanges have warmth, but Kurosawa leaves an uncomfortable space between the kindness of Kahei’s intentions and the reliability of what he promises.
That tension gives the film a distinctly Nietzschean dimension, although it makes more sense to treat this as a philosophical reading than a claim that Kurosawa is illustrating Nietzsche. Nietzsche questioned religious consolation that devalues earthly existence, while also recognizing the crisis that follows when inherited beliefs lose their authority. Nihilism, in this sense, isn’t simply being gloomy; it is the collapse of the values that make life seem purposeful. The tenement offers fertile ground for those questions. When the present is intolerable, a promised elsewhere—spiritual or otherwise—can become the only thing keeping someone going.
Kahei’s reassurance sits right inside that problem. Is he helping people endure life, or encouraging them to place their hopes beyond what they can actually do? His comfort to the dying woman has a religious dimension, while his promise of treatment gives the actor a more worldly version of salvation. Neither should be reduced to a simple fraud. His attention matters, and the relief he provides is real. Still, the film asks what happens when consolation becomes a substitute for change. The actor’s renewed hope briefly restores direction to his life, but it also gives disappointment a devastating new opening.
Importantly, the alternative isn’t presented as an easy victory for hardheaded realism. The residents who see through comforting stories aren’t necessarily freer, kinder, or better equipped to live. Exposing an illusion can leave a person with nothing to replace it. This is where the film’s nihilism becomes more unsettling than a general declaration that life is terrible. Belief may be unreliable, but disbelief offers no automatic foundation for dignity. Kurosawa keeps returning to that gap, asking what people can build together once neither religious reassurance nor cynical dismissal seems sufficient.
Fortunately, the film is often funny enough to keep these questions from turning airless. The residents interrupt, embellish, and needle one another with the precision that comes from prolonged proximity. Their humor isn’t merely a tasteful pause between tragedies; it is one of the main ways they occupy the world. Yet laughter can create fellowship or turn someone into a target, sometimes within the same exchange. A few arguments become repetitive, and the characters occasionally sound like competing philosophical positions. The performances usually pull them back toward messy individuality, where a clever observation can coexist with pettiness or genuine care.
By the final scene, the tenement has become familiar enough that its sudden pleasure feels almost welcome. That makes the interruption of the residents’ merriment by news of the actor’s suicide especially bitter, as does the complaint about the ruined fun. The ending leaves open whether laughter is a defense against meaninglessness or evidence of how little another life now matters. Kurosawa doesn’t settle the question for us. The Lower Depths stays with the uncomfortable distance between sharing a room and accepting responsibility for someone in it. There is plenty of company here, but comfort—and anything sturdy enough to call belief—is much harder to find.
Kurosawa-Mifune Collaborations