Brady Sutton (Philip Carey) used to be one of the most feared members of the Hole in the Wall Gang. He robbed banks with Butch Cassidy (Gene Evans) and the Sundance Kid (William Bishop) and he developed a reputation for being a ruthless outlaw. But that’s in the past. Brady has spent three years in prison and now, he’s ready to return home, marry Nancy (Martha Hyer), and go straight. Though most of the townspeople don’t trust Brady, he’s managed to find a sponsor in newcomer Charlie Veer (Douglas Kennedy), who has given Brady the money to open his own blacksmith shop.
Unfortunately, Brady might be done with the Hole in the Wall Gang but they’re not done with him. When Brady spots some members of the gang in town, he realizes that they’re casing the bank. Despite Brady’s attempts to warn the sheriff, the town assumes that Brady must be in on the plot. Brady grows so frustrated that he finds himself tempted to go back to his old ways. Meanwhile, Charlie is suddenly very interested in being introduced to the infamous Butch Cassidy himself.
Wyoming Renegades is a straight-forward, B-western. The plot is nothing special but Philip Carey and Douglas Kennedy both give good Western performances and Gene Evans is memorably evil as Butch Cassidy. For those who only know the characters as Paul Newman and Robert Redford’s performances in Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid, the most interesting thing about Wyoming Renegades will be seeing Cassidy and Sundance portrayed as being sadistic and humorless villains. The truth about Cassidy and his gang is probably somewhere in-between the fun-loving rogues played by Newman and Redford and the unforgiving bastards presented in Wyoming Renegades. In reality, it’s said that Butch Cassidy always tried to avoid killing people while Sundance rarely hesitated to draw his gun and start firing.
As for Wyoming Renegades, the ending does feature an unexpected twist, with Nancy proving herself to be more than just a docile love interest. Fans of classic television will want to keep an eye out for a young Aaron Spelling, playing a loathsome outlaw named Petie Carver.