Horror Review: The Walking Dead S3E02 “Sick”

“You think this is sick. You don’t want to know what’s outside.” — Daryl Dixon

[some spoilers]

There’s been an interesting pattern when it comes to The Walking Dead. The series has always had strong season opening (even mid-season returns) but the follow-up episode always seem to come up short. It happened with the second episodes of both first two season and even the episode which came after the mid-season return last season had some big stumbles throughout. It almost as if the writers (who at the time were still working under Frank Darabont’s directioneither as showrunner or the template he set up for the season) put everything they had into making the opening episode really strong and hoping the viewers would forgive them for not doing the follow-up episodes just as strong. Tonight’s season premiere follow-up looks to try and break that pattern. Time and reaction to tonight’s episode, titled “Sick”, will tell if it succeeded or not.

Tonight’s episode begins pretty much exactly where the season premiere left off with Rick and his group trying to save Hershel’s life who had gotten his leg bit during their attempt to clear out an adjoining cellblock. The premiere ended with Hershel minus his bit left ankle courtesy of Rick and his trusty axe and Daryl focusing the aim of his crossbow at the sudden appearance of a group of prisoners who happened to have survived almost a full year on their own in the prison cafeteria. It was this group’s reveal and how the two groups dealt with the knowledge that there were others who have survived just as long.

We learn much abouthow the time Rick and his group spent moving around the backwoods of Georgia between seasons. The episode doesn’t say what exactly happened during those months (a nice change for critics of the series who thought episodes after episodes during the first two season relied too much on exposition scenes to tell rather than show) but we see in the changes to the behavior and attitudes of the group members how those months were. It couldn’t have been a fun time for Rick and his group, but it looks to have made them much more harder and accepting of this new world’s harsh realities. Whether not letting her hopes up when it came to her father’s chances for survival after getting bit and having his bit leg chopped off to Carol becoming even more useful as a member of the group. In the season premiere we find out through a off-chance remark from Rick that she’s gotten quite good with the AK47 and tonight we find out that during their time in the Georgia backwoods Hershel had been teaching her how to perform first-aid and rudimentary battlefield medical work. The scene with Carol patching up Hershel actually gives some clues as to what Hershel’s backstory must be outside of being just a farmer.

Is there a chance that Hershesel could he have been in the military as a medic in his younger and wilder days or was he some sort of civilian emergency medical technician?

Tonight’s episode brought up such questions and without the characters sitting around explaining things that happened. This change in narrative style could be just temporary, but ever since Glen Mazzara took over as showrunner we get less and less exposition and more and more let the character’s actions convey the story. This less is more approach has made for a much more faster pace to the story even when there’s no killing of zombies. It also has made the actors much better in how they’re portraying their characters. Long scenes of quiet diaogue is always good, but in a show that tries to show that survival is a day-to-day or even an hour-to-hour task sometimes such long, extended scenes of just sitting around talking are luxuries that shouldn’t be used like they were a necessity.

There’s a chance that the show could slide back to what plagued the first two season, but for the time being Mazzara and his crew have done a great job with the first two episodes of season 3 to address some of the complaints fans and critics had with the show. We didn’t even have any scenes with Andrea and newcomer Michonne yet the writers avoided the temptation of trying to shoehorn scenes of them in tonight’s episodes which meant sacrificing some time in the prison. Tonight’s episode was all about Rick and Tomas butting heads to see who would end up being the alpha male of the two surviving groups.

We saw how the differences in how the two groups survived has affected them. Tomas and his group of inmate survivors did so almost by luck and having to depend on their prison-honed instincts to get them through. How they’ve managed to survive even with just the zombies in the prison and not knowing the full extent of the crisis would be seen by Rick as a miracle. Our main group on the other hand had to go through almost everything this new post-apocalyptic world could throw at them and they’ve survived. It’s this time out on the road, surviving day-to-day, supplies always on the verge of running out and not knowing if tomorrow might be their last day that has forged this group into hardened battlefield veterans. Make no mistake about it Rick and his group look and behave like war veterans still fighting to survive and having almost having learned an almost preternatural instinct to see danger lurking about.

This doesn’t mean that Rick and his group have come out of their time out in the wilderness surviving fully unscathed. Carl has become more useful and capable of taking care of himself, but at the cost of his innocence and childhood wonder at the world. Even T-Dog has become a very integral part of the group (thank you writers) and has become not just the “red-shirt” waiting to be knocked off for expediency’s sake. The biggest change has been to Rick who seem to have lost whatever optimism he might have had about finding peace and quiet in this new world. He’s now all about keeping his people alive and if that means killing other humans who might pose a danger to him fulfilling that mission statement then he’ll do whatever it takes. We see this change in Rick not through some exposition (something the character loved to do in the first two season) but in how he dealt with Tomas and other prisoners. It will be interesting how Mazzara and his team of writers will deal with Rick and the Governor who, if they’re following the basic outline of the comic book character, had to do almost the same exact things to keep his town of survivors alive through the crisis.

With the episode ending with Rick firmly in control of not just his group, the prison and the rest of the surviving prisoners (not to mention Hershel looking to have survived his encounter with the walker bite and Rick’s axe) it looks like next week’s episode will be focusing on the adventures of Andrea and Michonne and what looks like the introduction of this season’s main villain in David Morrissey’s own brand of despotic ruler in Philip Blake aka The Governor.


  • Tonight’s episode was written by show newcomer Nichole Beattie and directed by show veteran Billy Gierhart.
  • Anyone who thought that Tomas and his group of prisoner will get through the episode unscathed can’t be blamed for that assumption. If this was season two there’s a chance they would’ve lasted intact for half the first half of the season. New regime looks to avoid that and keep the number of survivors from spiraling out of control to the show’s detriment.
  • Sarah Wayne Callies has done a very good job in a tough role that only seems to get tougher. I don’t think she’ll ever become a sympathetic character for the fans of the show, but then again not everyone on the show needs to be sympathetic.
  • Then she blows up at Carl for putting himself in danger even though what he did probably saved Hershel’s life for the  moment.
  • Kudos to all Glen Mazzara and his team of writers for actually making a follow-up episode to the season premiere not have such a huge drop in quality. Tonight’s episode was a strong one.
  • The change in how the two Greene sisters acted in tonight’s episode reversed the role Maggie and Beth had while at the Farm. Maggie Green has become hardered by the intervening months between Season 2 and 3 while Beth has become much more optimistic.
  • The prisoners were all very interesting but kudos for the writers for not lingering too much in exploring the group’s dynamic with Rick’s own group.
  • Love how Daryl’s completely in Rick’s corner now and even willing to do the dirty work for him if and when Rick gives him the signal. Show’s that for all his faults in the early goings with the group Daryl understands that it was with Rick and not Shane that the group had the best chance of surviving. Rick may be doing the very same things Shane was advocating in the first two seasons, but Rick does so with a clear head and focus that Shane never really had.
  • The show may never have the Tyrese character from the comic book, but having Daryl Dixon in Rick’s corner more than makes up for it.
  • Killing other survivors still doesn’t sit well with Rick, but he looks to have learned that outside the group itself everyone else is expendable. He may not like murdering other people but he will if it keeps his group alive. This may be an ongoing theme for this season.
  • With the show having deviated from the comic book’s narrative it’s interesting to see how the show’s writers are starting to mine particular scenes from issues and storylines that happens much later in the comics to use in the show.
  • The relationship between Rick and Lori looks to be even more broken in the show than it as in the comic book. The question now is whether the writers will find a balance in keeping their relationship from being too broken. I do like how Rick at the end doesn’t seem ready to break the iceberg between her and Lori or if he ever wants to.
  • It’s good to see Lori admitting it on-screen just how much of a bad wife she has been since Rick returned. Her character has always been the one who was in real denial of her situation especially when it came to Rick and Shane now with the months leading up to this season it looks like Rick’s arctic attitude towards her has finally settled in her mind as to who really put the conflict between Rick and Shane into it’s violent end.
  • The zombie effects tonight wasn’t as extensive as the season premiere but Greg Nicotero and his men at KNB EFX still did a great job as usual.
  • Zombie Kill Count for tonight’s episode: between 20-25.

17 responses to “Horror Review: The Walking Dead S3E02 “Sick”

  1. There were a couple of very brutal and graphic killings of “living live” people in this episode. It was pretty shocking to view, but probably less so, after witnessing dozens of walker choppings, stabbings, and shootings during the first two seasons. When seeing walkers dispatched violently, I think one feels some level of insulation from experiencing the violence vicariously, due to the fact that the “victims” were already dead, such as they are supposed to be. (Stated with acknowledgement of the depiction of the nasty deaths suffered by some characters at the teeth of zombies.) Having depicted so many gory scenes of assaults on the undead may have emboldened the writers and director to do so with survivors. If such scenes had been included in the first two episodes of the series, I think it would have made the series even more controversial. I wonder if the producers, already out on a limb with an unusual and graphic TV series venture, would have dared do such a thing at that time, had the idea occurred to them.

    I am a bit concerned about the addition of the Michonne character. The series has been all nuts and bolts thus far – in the midst of the seemingly supernatural reanimation of the dead, all of the characters have been more or less believable, and the show gritty. The cryptic and mystical initial presentation of this new character in last season’s finale, along with her posturing with her sword in this season’s opening episode (was she trying to impress the zombies?), makes the character seem incongruous at best, and perhaps just silly. This, of course, remains to be seen. I haven’t read the comic book, but from this early vantage point, she seems like a character that should not have been transposed into the television adaptation of this mythology.

    You are familiar with the comic book, Arleigh. Is Michonne an over-the-top character? Could she fit in this series, with or without some modification, without impairing its credibility, as it were?

    Also, what is the deal with her armless zombie “dogs” (which don’t seem to help the character’s potential ridiculosity effect)? Are we supposed to have discerned the purpose of that, or will it be explained in subsequent episodes?


    • The chained zombies actually make sense when you look back at the episode “Guts”.

      As for the character of Michonne she may look like an over-the-top character but she also represents the sort of character the show has been lacking during the first two season and that is a true survivor. I know some fans of the show say that Shane was a true survivor. He wasn’t a true survivor since all his posturing has always been to hide the fact that he’s trying to prove to Lori that he made for a better husband, father and protector than Rick. Michonne is much closer in terms of characterization with Daryl Dixon. Two individuals who have adapted quite fast to the zombie apocalypse. She just happens to wield a katana with expertise the way Daryl does with a crossbow.

      The trick for the writers now is to try and keep Michonne from turning out to be too fantastical in a series that’s trying for gritty realism (though a show aout a zombie apocalypse should be given some leeway in this regard).


      • I considered the idea that the chained zombies could provide some olfactory camouflage. It would preferable to a wearing a rotting flesh suit. But as portrayed in the series, and in most films, the zombies don’t stop trying to eat, no matter the lever of dismemberment or damage, until the brain is destroyed. So the zombies should be constantly lunging at Michonne, instead of cooperatively stumbling ahead of her. Unless we are supposed to believe that they smell each other, and therefore, do not detect Michonne’s live scent. Which is a nice idea, but would present a whopping inconsistency. That concept would be intensified multifold in a zombie mob – they should not be able to detect the scent of survivors because of the overwhelming “fragrance” they would collectively produce. But okay. It’s only a TV show. About a zombie apocalypse. I’ll give them some leeway in that regard, as well. 🙂


  2. I caught the armless part. I didn’t notice the jaws specifically, though. I guess I figured it was just general decomposition disfigurement. But unless the flawed smell rmisdirection theory is accepted, they should still be attacking her, even if they looked like undead woodpeckers in the process. 🙂


    • They’re pretty much useless and harmless without arms and jaws. I think in the comic and some behind-the-scenes for the show have the pets also missing part of their nose and nasal passages.


  3. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E06 “Hounded” | Through the Shattered Lens

  4. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E07 “When the Dead Come Knocking” | Through the Shattered Lens

  5. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E08 “Made to Suffer” | Through the Shattered Lens

  6. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E09 “The Suicide King” | Through the Shattered Lens

  7. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E10 “Home” | Through the Shattered Lens

  8. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E11 “I Ain’t no Judas” | Through the Shattered Lens

  9. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E12 “Clear” | Through the Shattered Lens

  10. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E13 “Arrow on the Doorpost” | Through the Shattered Lens

  11. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S3E14 “Prey” | Through the Shattered Lens

  12. Pingback: Review: The Walking Dead S2E15 “This Sorrowful Life” | Through the Shattered Lens

  13. Pingback: Through the Shattered Lens

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.