Film Review: Pickup on South Street (dir. by Sam Fuller)


“So you’re a Red, who cares? Your money’s as good as anybody else’s.” — Skip McCoy

The best thing about Pickup on South Street is that its hero is a real pain in the neck. Skip McCoy does not want to save the country, help the police, or become a better man. He wants to know what is in it for him, preferably before anyone finishes explaining the danger. That stubborn selfishness gives Samuel Fuller’s 1953 thriller its bite. Under Sam Fuller’s direction, a story about stolen government secrets becomes a scrappy clash of personalities. The espionage matters, but the real attraction is watching people bargain, bluff, and occasionally discover feelings they would rather keep out of the deal.

Richard Widmark plays Skip, whose latest subway theft turns out to be considerably more complicated than expected. His target is Candy, played by Jean Peters, a woman carrying an envelope for her former boyfriend, Joey. Unknown to her, it contains microfilm meant for a Communist spy operation. Government agents are watching Candy when Skip steals her wallet, leaving both sides scrambling to recover something he initially regards as an ordinary score. Everyone wants the same object for different reasons. Skip’s refusal to accept anyone else’s priorities keeps the plot moving, while his growing awareness of its value makes him increasingly difficult to handle.

Fuller’s direction makes the opening theft an immediate grabber. Rather than explaining who everyone is, he draws our attention to faces, hands, and the opportunities created by a crowded subway car. Skip’s concentration is almost intimate, while Candy remains unaware of what his closeness means. The sequence makes watching feel active: we study the same movements he does, waiting to see whether anyone notices. Fuller establishes suspense through physical behavior before dialogue takes over. It is economical filmmaking, but it never feels merely efficient. The scene has a sly, uncomfortable energy that introduces the movie’s overlapping interests in desire, deception, and invasion of privacy.

Widmark makes Skip entertaining without pretending he is harmless. His smile has a taunting quality, as though he has already spotted the weakness in whatever argument someone is making. He particularly enjoys refusing people who expect obedience. That could become a performance built entirely around attitude, but Widmark gives the defiance a practical foundation. Skip protects himself by withholding information and trusting almost nobody. Fuller allows that unpleasantness to remain, resisting the temptation to make his leading man immediately lovable. We keep watching because Skip is unpredictable, not because the film promises that every selfish gesture conceals a heart of gold.

Candy has the difficult job of getting past those defenses, and Peters keeps her from becoming merely the woman assigned to soften the leading man. She gives Candy a mixture of determination and emotional weariness. Here is someone capable of standing her ground who nevertheless keeps investing her feelings in men who offer little security. Her involvement with Joey leaves her exposed, and her attraction to Skip hardly promises a peaceful alternative. Peters makes the contradiction believable. Candy can recognize danger without being immune to loneliness, and her toughness does not cancel out her need to believe another person might care.

Their relationship is the film’s most uneven element. Attraction develops amid suspicion and physical aggression, and the shift toward affection sometimes happens faster than the characters have earned. Fuller’s direction favors impact over delicacy here, which gives their encounters force but occasionally shortchanges their emotional development. Widmark and Peters nevertheless generate a charged, unsettled chemistry. Their scenes work best when affection seems to escape against their better judgment. They work less well when the screenplay appears to assume that rough handling can serve as romantic groundwork. The movie’s abrasive approach is part of its identity, but that does not make every choice equally convincing.

Thelma Ritter provides a different emotional register as Moe, a necktie seller who also earns money by passing information to the police. She knows the neighborhood’s crooks, understands their routines, and treats that knowledge as something she has every right to sell. Ritter makes her funny, observant, and exhausted, often within the same exchange. Moe’s determination to save for a decent burial initially sounds like colorful characterization. Gradually, it becomes the clearest expression of what she wants: some assurance that she will not disappear without dignity. Fuller gives Ritter room to let that fear emerge without turning it into an oversized appeal for sympathy.

His handling of Moe shows how much tenderness exists beneath the movie’s tough surface. Fuller does not soften her occupation or suggest that hardship automatically makes her noble. Instead, he lets practical self-interest coexist with affection and personal limits. Informing on someone can be part of an understood arrangement rather than evidence of complete moral emptiness. These characters exploit one another, but they still recognize differences between making a living and committing a deeper betrayal. The direction stays close enough to their individual concerns that those distinctions matter. What might have been a convenient supporting character becomes the person who gives the film its emotional weight.

Fuller is just as effective at making the settings express the characters’ circumstances. Skip’s waterfront shack offers independence without comfort or stability, an appropriate home for someone who prefers being difficult to reach. Elsewhere, tight framing and sudden movement make conversations feel like contests over territory. People lean in, crowd one another, and turn ordinary exchanges into confrontations. The Cold War plot adds urgency, but Fuller keeps returning to immediate, personal pressures. Skip’s indifference to patriotic appeals disrupts the expected moral certainty. National duty means little to someone accustomed to treating survival as an individual responsibility, and the film gets considerable mileage out of that friction.

By the end, the question is less whether Skip will become respectable than whether he can stop treating every human connection as a transaction. That is where Pickup on South Street finds its lasting appeal. Some of the romance remains unpersuasive, and the espionage villains are simpler than the people surrounding them. But Sam Fuller’s direction holds the mixture together through sharp visual storytelling, restless pacing, and a willingness to let sentiment surface without washing away the grime. Widmark supplies the insolence, Peters the vulnerability, and Ritter the ache that lingers afterward. For a movie driven by something stolen, its finest moments come when someone finally gives something freely.

4 Shots From 4 Films: Special 1953 Edition


4 Shots From 4 Films is just what it says it is, 4 shots from 4 of our favorite films. As opposed to the reviews and recaps that we usually post, 4 Shots From 4 Films lets the visuals do the talking!

Today, we take a look at a classic cinematic year.  It’s time for….

4 Shots From 4 1953 Films

From Here To Eternity (1953, dir by Fred Zinnemann, DP: Floyd Crosby and Burnett Guffey)

Fear and Desire (1953, dir by Stanley Kubrick, DP: Stanley Kubrick)

Pickup on South Street (1953, dir by Samuel Fuller, DP: Joseph MacDonald)

The War of the Worlds (1953, dir by Byron Haskin, DP: George Barnes)

4 Shots From 4 Films: Special Sam Fuller Edition


4 Or More Shots From 4 Or More Films is just what it says it is, 4 shots from 4 of our favorite films. As opposed to the reviews and recaps that we usually post, 4 Shots From 4 Films lets the visuals do the talking!

On this date, 110 years ago, Samuel Fuller was born in Massachusetts.  Before he became a filmmaker, Fuller was a crime reporter and a pulp novelist.  His films were often melodramatic and unapologetically sordid.  They were also often dismissed when they were initially released but almost all of them were subsequently rediscovered by audiences who appreciated Fuller’s striking visuals and the often subversive subtext to be found underneath the surface of his genre films.

Today, we celebrate Fuller’s legacy with….

4 Shots From 4 Sam Fuller Films

Pickup on South Street (1953, dir by Samuel Fuller, DP: Joseph MacDonald)

Shock Corridor (1963, dir by Samuel Fuller, DP: Stanley Cortez)

The Naked Kiss (1964, dir by Samuel Fuller, DP: Stanley Cortez)

The Big Red One (1980, dir by Samuel Fuller, DP: Adam Greenberg)

44 Days of Paranoia #23: Pickup On South Street (dir by Samuel Fuller)


For today’s entry in the 44 Days of Paranoia, let’s take a look at Sam Fuller’s 1953 film noir, Pickup on South Street.

Pickup On South Street opens with Candy (Jean Peters) on a subway.  In her purse, she’s carrying an envelope that’s been given to her by her boyfriend, the rather shady Joey (Richard Kiley).  Candy is delivering the envelope to friends of Joey.  What Candy doesn’t know is that Joey and his friends are communists and that the envelope contains top secret micro-film.  She also doesn’t know that she’s being followed by both the FBI and Skip Martin (Richard Widmark), a professional pickpocket.

Skip picks Candy’s purse and, without realizing it, steals the microfilm that everyone wants.  With the help of professional informant Moe (Thelma Ritter, a great character actress who gives a great performance here), both Candy and the police track down Skip and try to get him to return the microfilm.  Skip, however, has figured out what he’s stolen and announces that he’ll give the microfilm to whichever group is the first to pay him $25,000.  When the FBI make the mistake of trying to appeal to his patriotism, Skip merely smirks and asks, “Are you waving the flag at me?”

In his introduction to Sam Fuller’s autobiography A Third Face: My Tale of Writing, Fighting, and Filmmaking, Martin Scorsese writes, “(I)f you don’t like the films of Sam Fuller, then you just don’t like cinema.”  Now, I really can’t say whether that’s true or not because, while I love cinema, I’ve only seen three of the films that Sam Fuller directed over the course of his long career: The Naked Kiss, Shock Corridor, and now Pickup On South Street.  However, I can say that I loved all three of those films.  The Naked Kiss I loved because I happen to love old films that expose the secrets of small town America.  As Arleigh can tell you, I fell in love with Shock Corridor the minute that the film’s hero said, “NYMPHOS!”  As for Pickup On South Street, I love it because it’s truly a great film and one of the best B-movie ever made.

And make no mistake about it — Pickup On South Street is a B-movie, a melodramatic, wonderfully sordid, and terrifically entertaining B-movie.  It’s a thriller that both embraces and subverts the conventions of the genre and, as a result, it tells a story that manages to be both over-the-top and subtle at the same time.  By focusing on those on the margins of society, the Skips and the Moes of the world, Fuller also forces us to confront just how little the ideology of a government means to those of us who live on the margins of society.

This is certainly made clear by Thelma Ritter’s poignant performance as Moe, one of the weary inhabitants of the margins who has been reduced to just hoping that she’ll have enough money when she dies to be buried in a decent plot.  One watches Pickup on South Street and realizes that, regardless of which side ultimately end up with the microfilm, people like Moe are still most likely going to end up getting buried in an pauper’s grave.

Watching Pickup On South Street, it’s easy to see why Martin Scorsese had such high praise for Fuller.  Fuller’s camera literally never stops moving, nervously darting through the urban landscape and occasionally zooming in for a close-up of either a desperate face or Richard Widmark’s smirk.  And make no doubt about it — Richard Widmark’s charming but infuriating smirk tells you everything that you need to know about both the character Skip McCoy and Pickup On South Street as a film.  It’s a smirk that lets us know that both the character and the film are a lot more intelligent than they initially let on.

Pickup on South Street is a film that every lover of cinema must see.  And, after you’ve seen it, why not get a copy of Fuller’s autobiography?  It’s an interesting read.

Other Entries In The 44 Days of Paranoia 

  1. Clonus
  2. Executive Action
  3. Winter Kills
  4. Interview With The Assassin
  5. The Trial of Lee Harvey Oswald
  6. JFK
  7. Beyond The Doors
  8. Three Days of the Condor
  9. They Saved Hitler’s Brain
  10. The Intruder
  11. Police, Adjective
  12. Burn After Reading
  13. Quiz Show
  14. Flying Blind
  15. God Told Me To
  16. Wag the Dog
  17. Cheaters
  18. Scream and Scream Again
  19. Capricorn One
  20. Seven Days In May
  21. Broken City
  22. Suddenly