Flight Risk, Mel Gibson’s first directorial effort since the Oscar-nominated Hacksaw Ridge, opens with Winston (Topher Grace) being arrested by Madolyn (Michelle Dockery), a U.S. Marshal.

Winston is an accountant, one who moved around a lot of money for the Mafia and who arranged for a lot of bribes to high-ranked officials.  That said, Winston is not a particularly dangerous or even cunning fugitive.  If anything, he’s extremely neurotic.  He worries about the safety of his mother.  He tells Madolyn (and the audience) way more than anyone could possibly need to know about his bathroom habits.  He’s on the run because the government wants him to testify against his former employers.  Winston is far more frightened of the Mafia than he is of the government and with good reason.  The Mafia wants him dead.  The government still needs him alive.

After Winston is arrested in Alaska, Madolyn arranges for them to be flown to Anchorage by a Texas-born bush pilot named Darryl Booth.  When a man claiming to be Darryl (Mark Walhberg) shows up, Madolyn and Winston promptly get on the plane.  From the minute Wahlberg started speaking, I was rolling my eyes.  Wahlberg’s Texas accent was perhaps the worst that I’ve ever heard in a modern movie and that’s saying something.  Fortunately, it turned out that Wahlberg’s accent was deliberately bad.  The man calling himself Darryl Booth is not actually Darryl Booth.  He’s not from Texas.  He’s not a professional pilot.  Instead, he’s a hitman who has been sent to kill both Winton and Madolyn.  Unfortunately, Madolyn and Winston don’t realize that until the plane has already taken off.

Flight Risk starts out as an enjoyably silly movie but it’s ultimately done in by the limitations of its plot.  Nearly the entire film takes place in that cramped and nondescript airplane and neither Madolyn nor Darryl are really compelling enough to hold onto your interest over the entire course of the film’s 90 minute running time.  Winston, on the other hand, is actually a compelling character and Topher Grace shows, once again, that he deserves a bigger film career than the one he has.  Unfortunately, Winston spends the majority of the film incapacitated.  He’s either in handcuffs and stuck in the back of the plane or he’s sitting up front and freaking out but he never gets to do as much as one might wish.  Instead, the entire film comes down to Darryl taunting his targets and Madolyn struggling to figure out how to fly the plane.  To be honest, the film actually makes flying look pretty easy.  I mean, Madolyn has no experience as a pilot and she somehow still manages not to crash.  How difficult could it be?

Of the three main actors, Topher Grace gives the best performance, managing to give a fully-rounded performance even when Winston is incapable of moving.  For the first thirty minutes or so of the film, Mark Wahlberg is enjoyably over-the-top but then his character just becomes a standard talkative villain.  Michelle Dockery is stuck playing a boring character and she never brings much life to her flat dialogue.  If anything, she’s outacted by an unseen Leah Remini, who provides the voice of Madolyn’s partner and proves that she can still curse like a champ.

Flight Risk continues the pattern of scripts that rank high on Hollywood’s “black list,” (that is, the annual list of the most popular unproduced scripts in Hollywood), being turned it into disappointing films.  At least it’s slightly more fun than Cedar Rapids.