Review: The Walking Dead (EP06) – “TS-19”


[Some Spoilers Within]

So, we’ve finally reached the season finale of a very short inaugural season of Frank Darabont’s tv adaptation of Robert Kirkman’s critically-acclaimed and very popular comic book series, The Walking Dead. AMC ordered an initial 6-episode for this season which made setting up the world for the non-fans of the comic book a top priority. This could be seen in the first five episodes as each one explained the rules of this new post-apocalyptic world and how it has changed how people have now begun to behave.

The tv series has stayed mostly loyal to its comic book source, but some divergence from the source material has caused some grumblings amongst the comic book’s legions of fans. It doesn’t matter to them that the comic book’s creator has been ok with the changes and actually an active participant with said changes. These changes have been somewhat minor in the show’s five episodes but as episode five rolled to an end we got a major departure to the source material. Rick has taken his band of survivors back to Atlanta where the CDC (Center for Disease Control) is headquartered at. This never happened in the comic book and it’s inclusion to the story has driven many a fan of the source material batshit crazy.

They ask why make the changes, both minor and major, to a story that was already full of story-arcs, subplots aplenty and enough characters down the line that new ones weren’t needed. I can’t blame them for asking such questions for I, too, are a major fan of the comics right from the very beginning. But these changes is exactly why the story being told by this tv adaptation look and seem fresh to me. The end of the last episode was such a major departure that I can now honestly say that I have no idea what Darabont and Kirkman have in store for Season Two. It’s that element of the unknown and the surprise of not knowing what’s around the corner why I don’t rail against these changes. If I wanted a page-by-page, panel-by-panel adaptation then I’d rather just bring out the comics and re-read them for the umpteenth time.

Now we get to the season finale and whether the major change will actually improve or just ruin the series.

I must say that I was guarded in my optimism about this major departure and the inclusion of the CDC. What I’ve liked about some of the best zombie stories ever put on film or on paper is that the zombie apocalypse never truly gets a definite explanation as to how it began or what caused it in the first place. This season finale episode titled “TS-19” seemed like Darabont’s attempt to try and explain the cause of the zombies and who or what let it loose in the first place. Very bad zombie stories try to over-explain and end up tripping over themselves in the process and thus ruining the experience.

With “TS-19” we get Dr. Edmund Jenner (Noah Emmerich), last surviving researcher in the CDC, give a brief explanation as to the process of when a person goes from living to dead to reanimated corpse. While the fancy computer-enhanced imagery seemed to explain much it really doesn’t. It just scientifically showed what everyone already knew. They still don’t know if it’s a viral or bacterial disease or if it’s even a disease at all. Even Jenner doesn’t discount Jacqui (one of those new characters added in that fans of the comics railed against) mentioning that it could be the wrath of God. The sequence even answers viewers’ question about how long it takes for a recently dead to return back as a “walker”. The answer to that is that they don’t know.

This episode highlighted how ineffectual the very institutions people depended on for help, security and safety when the zombie apocalypse finally hit critical stage. We see this in the show’s cold start prologue as we go back in time to see the final moments at the King’s County Hospital where a comatose Rick Grimes was being kept at for observations. Shane, his partner and best friend, sees the brutal solution the military has for those either infected but alive and/or unwilling to vacate the hospital as it began to be overrun by the “walkers”.

This sequence answered questions about why the military was so inefficient. It’s also a damning condemnation about the rigidity of such a major governmental institution unable to adapt to an ever-changing situation where the enemy didn’t sleep, didn’t stop to rest or wasn’t afraid about being fired on. This was an enemy that was conducting the true meaning of “total war” on a people who were already on the ends of their last rope. The fact that their solution only swelled the ranks of those they fought just showed how doomed the world is when something this apocalyptic occurs without warning and without a means to fully understand and combat.

Even Jenner doesn’t know what made the zombie apocalypse begin and the source of what scientists thought was something they could find a cure for. This ambiguity needed to be shown to stop question from the audience about the “why’s” and “how’s” and instead get the series back onto the road where survival and holding onto their humanity remains their ultimate struggle.

This episode does get them back onto that lonely road with some deciding to stay as the facility began a countdown towards a final decontamination. We get also get a nice scene between Jeffrey DeMunn’s Dale and Laurie Holden’s Andrea that should make fans of the comics happy. The same goes for showing just how ineffectual Rick has been as their leader as every decision he has made has put the group in danger. It shows Rick’s intractable belief in doing the right things and holding on to the vestiges of civilized behavior could be just a front to give his wife and son hope that things will be better. This episode shows Rick that what’s better is to stay for that final decontamination instead of going back on the road where only death and suffering will await him and his group. Jenner’s comment that was heard was like a prophetic announcement that Rick will regret going back out.

So, we finally end Season One of The Walking Dead and have a very long wait (hopefully AMC make the decision to air Season Two not on October but at least a month sooner, if not a couple of months.) til the series picks up again with the convoy of survivors headed to parts unknown. Parts unknown not just for the characters in the series but for fans of the comic book as well. Here’s to hoping that while Darabont and Kirkman uses the comic book as the main path for the series moving forward that they also deviate from it from time to time if there’s a good story to tell on those small paths and tributaries.

Extras

* “Dude, you are such a buzzkill.” – Glenn finally gets back his witty ways as he reacts to Shane’s questioning of Jenner during a celebratory dinner.

* “Man, I’m going to get shitfaced drunk, AGAIN.” – Daryl’s reaction to Jenner’s news that there may be no one left anywhere.

* I found it quite ironic that of all the people to hold out the longest as the rest of the world gave up it would be the French.

* There was quite the Lost In Translation moment towards the end as Jenner whispers something into Rick’s ear before the group bolted to escape. Theories on what already has odds on Lori’s physical situation after the tests Jenner gave the group.

* As a military nut I smiled at the use of the acronym H.I.T. to literally mean a hit of a high-impulse thermobaric high explosive. That’s what I call a hit.

* Scene as Rick tries to plead with Jenner to let them go one can see Daryl still axing away at the blast doors.

* “The world runs on fossil fuel. How stupid is that!” – Jenner pointing out that places still doing research to find a solution failed because the power grids which run on fuel stopped due to lack of it.

* “This is what takes us down. This is our extinction event.” – Jenner finally voicing what everyone in the show has been avoiding and should give a clue as to the true meaning of the show’s title.

* The episode ends with a Bob Dylan song, Tomorrow Is a Long Time, that was very appropriate.

5 responses to “Review: The Walking Dead (EP06) – “TS-19”

  1. If the TV show was just a literal translation of the comic book than what would be the point of reading the book? Or whatching the TV show? I think what’s more important is whether or not the TV show can capture the “feel” of its source material as opposed to whether or not it follows it to the exact letter.

    I think The Walking Dead had a great first season. It was a little uneven as first seasons often are. It takes a while for a show to find its tone. I’ll be interested to see what happens during the 2nd season. Traditionally, it’s during the 2nd season that a TV show either clicks into place or else it doesn’t.

    Like

    • Exactly. I understand why people want it to be a literal translation, but enjoyment of seeing such a series and knowing how each scene plays out can get boring. The way they’ve dealt with this by changing things up doesn’t change the tone of the story and actually expands on some of the story’s themes.

      I think season two should really be called Season 1B. Combining this one and next one really should be a first season for most shows. It’s really the only complaint have about the show. Too short to really get the show’s writing squared away and following one voice. But for so short a season I think they did rather well.

      Like

    • [Queue slurry-bracer nerdrage voice]

      “But I want it EXACTLY like the comix! I want it to be verbatim, awesome, shot-for-panel, and I especially want to be surprised every step of the way. Every. Step. Of. The. Friggin’. Way.”

      I agree with you guys. You have to make it fresh if you plan on it lasting. This isn’t a book adaptation, this is a long-running series getting started. As long as it is handled well and not a clear filler sub-plot the fans of the comics shouldn’t be bothered. Might just be a few of them crying out that their ‘little’ comic is now ‘selling out to the man’ and thus anything they offer has to be a bad decision to only make more money. And I too think six episodes is far too short. Though! As you mentioned it starting back up in October, this season did so to collect bonus viewers on Halloween night. If the season is twice as long, hopefully it starts twice as early. Or actually half as early. …You get what I mean XD

      Like

  2. I think this was a very good “season” closer. As with all the previous episodes, it was matter-of=fact – nothing silly, and nothing presented in an overblown way.

    I liked the exploration of the reanimation process, as shown by the imaging footage. The desire and effort to understand the phenomenon is realistic. I like movies and shows wherein certain supernatural phenomena are discussed or questioned directly by the characters. A variation on this was presented in “Let The Right One In” (sorry for going back to the same well for an analogous reference), when the boy asked the vampire what would happen if she entered a home uninvited. We actually saw the consequences. That brings the concept out from the mythology, and into the “reality “of the characters’ world.

    And as Arleigh said, we don’t rally learn the cause. But we see an interesting demonstration of the effect. And that which it does reveal is consistent with what the behavior characters have observed, and with what, I think, most zombie fans would prefer – these creatures are truly walking (and eating) dead. I thought this part of the episode was well-handled.

    As for faithful transposition of the comic book story and mythology, I would say that the majority of viewers have not read the comic book, the many who have notwithstanding. One of the main goals of the writers has to be to make the show appealing to as many viewers as possible, while still being faithful to the genre concept. They have, thus far, succeeded in making a compelling and unconventional drama that is not cheesy.

    And, I liked the ending, with the characters having to make a fateful decision – choosing between a certain but quick and (hopefully) painless death, and a somewhat less certain but still probable and much more horrible one. Kind of like the ending of…oh, I don’t know…say, “The Mist”. Everyone knows how great that film is…

    I say “The Walking Dead” has been an artistic success. Genre fans have gotten no small amount of what they like, non-genre viewers have likely been creeped and grossed out, but also pulled into the story and its dilemmas. Six episodes was not a fair shot, but I think Darabont, et al have pulled off a successful launch, nonetheless. I hope we don’t have to wait until next Halloween, but, then again, it would once again provide one more thing to look forward to on October 31st.

    Like

    • “Kind of like the ending of…oh, I don’t know…say, “The Mist”. Everyone knows how great that film is…”

      /facepalm

      Arleigh and Lisa just reacquired the blog back from us and you just had to go ahead and mention ‘that’ [air quotes] “movie” and it’s ending to be precise. For shame.

      Shame, says I!

      Like

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.