Earlier today, I had the misfortune to sit through the just released movie The American.
The title character, as played by George Clooney (who also produced the film), is an aging assassin. He’s done some bad, bad things and, as a result, he has some bad, bad people after him. So, he hides out in an isolated, Italian village. He makes friends with the local priest, engages in some shady business of some sort with a mysterious woman (Thekla Reuten), and of course falls in love with the proverbial hooker with a heart of gold (Violante Placido). The whole time, the American is aware that his days are numbered and that he can trust no one.
And who really cares?
Director Anton Corbijn appears to be trying to do an homage to the noir-influenced French New Wave of the late 50s and 1960s but he seems to have forgotten that Jean-Luc Godard’s and Francois Truffaut’s films were usually as entertaining as they were intellectually stimulating. (This, of course, is something that Godard forgot as well.) As a result, The American often feels like a parody of an art film. Every scene drips with great importance and all the actors play their roles like they’re in a passion play but, in the end, it’s just a lot of pretension that ultimately adds up to nothing.
As a movie, the American is pretty to look at but I lost interest in it fairly early. Corbijn tries to create an atmosphere of ennui but the end result is simply dull. Clooney attempts to give a restrained performance full of self-loathing and paranoia but he’s miscast in the part. George Clooney the producer doesn’t seems to realize that Clooney’s essential shallowness is the key to his appeal. George Clooney comes across as the perfect one-night stand, the epitome of fun-while-it-lasted but nothing to regret once he’s gone. Whenever Clooney attempts to suggest anything suggesting any greater depth — like in this film — he simply seems lost.
Speaking of lost, so was I as I watched this dull, boring movie. I’m sure some will embrace this film but for me, I’ll pass.

I see we now have two films we’ll be disagreeing on. 🙂
While I didn’t think the film was one of the greats this year I thought it was well done. Almost minimalistic in execution. I like to think of the film as being in the mind of a character whose whole being has been inured to the life of an assassin that everything he does and senses goes towards keeping himself alive.
I will admit that the scenery was also great. Italy does make for a beautiful setting.
As for Clooney’s work I thought it was quite good and I wouldn’t be surprised if he nabs an award or two for it. I definitely liked him better in this role than the one he had for “Up in The Air”.
Now you will need to replace Avatar with this for the rest of the year. 😀
LikeLike
See, I prefered Clooney in Up In the Air. lol. 🙂
For me, the best part of The American was the minute or so of Once Upon A Time In The West that showed up about halfway through. 🙂
And the whole hooker with a heart of Gold subplot … bleh. Seriously, movies love their fantasy hookers. 🙂
LikeLike
See, I like it better when my lead characters are a tad more dour and fatalistic. Yeah, that scene was quite good.
Don’t get me wrong, I liked Up in The Air enough to put it on my top 10 for 2009, but it definitely has lost some of its luster since. Plus, I’m growing to think of Jason Reitman the way you think of James Cameron. 😀
LikeLike
Pingback: The 10 Worst Films of 2010 « Through the Shattered Lens