If someone just five years ago told me that Ben Affleck would turn out to be a director whose work has been some of the better crime drama/thrillers of the past decade then I would declare shenanigans on that individual. Ben Affleck might have won an Oscar for helping write the screenplay for Good Will Hunting, but his career since could be labeled as being one of a joke (Gigli) interspersed with huge paycheck projects (Armageddon) that showed his range as an actor.
This is not to say that Affleck has no talent in front of the camera. I just believe that early in his career after winning his Oscar he got fooled into thinking that everything else since would be Easy Street paved in gold (financially and critically). To say that it hasn’t turned out to be that way (though he did make a ton of money) would be an understatement. But one thing happened while Affleck’s acting career was heading nowhere but down. He got behind the camera as a director and his very first time directing a feature-length film he would make one of 2007’s best films. I speak of his film adaptation of the Dennis Lehane crime drama, Gone Baby Gone. He didn’t just direct the life out of that film, but he also the screenplay with the help of Aaron Stockard.
The two of the them would collaborate once again on Affleck’s latest Boston-based crime drama, The Town. He wrote the screenplay and directed the film and pulled in some wonderful performances from an ensemble cast which included Jeremy Renner, Jon Hamm, Rebecca Hall, Blake Lively, Titus Welliver and Pete Postlethwaite. Fellow site writer Lisa Marie already reviewed the film in detail and her review pretty much put down into words exactly what I thought of the film. I will say that I would swerve slightly away from what she considered some of the flaws in the film.
The Town was adapted from Chuck Hogan’s novel, Prince of Thieves. I would consider the screenplay and dialogue as a major strength of the film. While at times it did seemed to follow the step-by-step and by-the-numbers heist thriller story the screenplay itself didn’t ring false. I liken this film to another heist film which shared some themes and similarities. Michael Mann’s Heat also dealt with the cops-and-robbers foundation. Where Mann’s film had a much larger and epic scope to its storytelling it still boiled down to two groups of determined men playing a dangerous game of cat-and-mouse. The women in both film were written just enough that they had distinct personalities, but in the end they were motivations for the men in the film.
Affleck shows that he doesn’t just know how to direct, but continues is reputation as being one very good screenwriter. One just has to be reminded that he is now 3-for-3 when it comes to screenplays he has written which have turned out to be great ones. While he doesn’t have the same flair for words as Tarantino or Mamet when it comes to the screenplay. What he does well was to create an efficient script which flowed from scene to scene. Tarantino’s screenplays are great, but at times he does allow himself to overindulge his inner-film geek and create dialogue that might be Sorkin-like in execution. What I mean is that as great as the dialogue sound there’s no way people really spoke like this to each other. Affleck’s screenplay for The Town felt very natural and even with Jon Hamm’s less than great performance the film had a natural and genuine sound to it’s dialogue.
That’s one flaw pointed out by Lisa Marie that I would disagree with her on. The other two I can see her point, but it bothered me none. Though if I ever took on a life of crime I would hope I find someone just like Rebecca Hall’s Claire. Now there’s a woman who stands by her man no matter what.
I think in the long run this film might just be seen as one of the best of 2010 and some critics have already dubbed it so. While it’s prospects come awards season time is still up in the air I wouldn’t be surprised if it ends up nabbing one of the ten Best Picture nominations when the Oscar nominations get announced. It would be well-deserved and would just prove that Affleck’s career in the film industry might just be hitting its stride. Who would’ve thought it would be as a writer-director and not as an actor.

I used to love to watch that old Project Greenlight show that used to be on HBO (and, for its third and final season, Bravo). Even though not one good film came out of Project Greenlight, you could still see some hints that Ben Affleck would turn out to be a talented director. (Of course, Affleck and Matt Damon would only appear in maybe three or four episodes a season.)
I wouldn’t go quite as far as to say that the Town belongs in the top 10 of the year but I could see an argument made for the Top 20. That said, 2010 has seen some excellent crime films released here in America — not just the Town but Winter’s Bone, Animal Kingdom, and A Prophet as well.
I was thinking about how disappointed I was in Jon Hamm’s performance this other night and it occured to me that his role would have been a good one for Matt Damon. Not only would Damon have given a much better performance but it would have also reunited the two of them for the first time outside of a Kevin Smith movie.
LikeLike
I think Jon Hamm, as you pointed out, may be those kind of actors who does their best work on TV. Acting on a feature-film seems to be different than acting on TV. For one, on feature’s scenes are not dne in order which could throw an actor off his performance. On TV its usually done in order so a performer can build their character’s motivations accordingly. I just have a feeling that Hamm may be one of those who is great on TV but can seem lost when doing stuff outside it.
As fot top ten…I shall stand by my pick. 🙂
Unless, something else comes along to blow me away to knock it down out of the 10. 😀
LikeLike
Here’s my top ten of the year so far (in other words, if Lisa Marie was solely in charge of the Oscar nominations and this was January 2011 as opposed to September, 2010, these are the films that would end up nominated for Best Picture). For now, I’m just going to list them in alphabetical order:
1) Animal Kingdom
2) Exit Through The Gift Shop
3) Fish Tank
4) The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
5) Inception
6) Please Give
7) A Prophet
8) Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World
9) Toy Story 3
10) Winter’s Bone
I wouldn’t be surprised to see The Town nominated for best picture however, especially if it does well at the box office. The Actor’s Branch is the largest branch in the Academy and they’ve shown a willingness to nominate “serious” films directed by actors in the past. (Good Night and Good Luck comes to mind.)
LikeLike
“I wouldn’t be surprised to see The Town nominated for best picture however, especially if it does well at the box office. The Actor’s Branch is the largest branch in the Academy and they’ve shown a willingness to nominate “serious” films directed by actors in the past. (Good Night and Good Luck comes to mind.)”
Which is why I picked it. There’s always one film every year where an actor either directed or had a help in producing/writing it. 🙂
This year we may have two with Clint Eastwood’s “Hereafter” getting major awards buzz. Which is appropriate since Eastwood’s career seems to be one many are now projecting Affleck’s own may go.
LikeLike