Poor Amy Fisher!
In the 1993 made-for-TV movie, Amy Fisher: My Story, Amy Fisher (played by Noelle Parker) is an insecure teenager growing up on Long Island. She goes to high school. She has a boyfriend. She has lots of girl friends. She has a part-time job. She has a car. Everything should be perfect but it’s not. For one thing, her creepy father (played by veteran Canadian character actor Lawrence Dane) likes to come into her room while she’s trying to sleep and sit on the edge of her bed. Her mother (Kate Lynch) refuses to believe that there’s anything strange about the way her husband treats their daughter.
When Amy and her father take her car to the local auto body shop, she meets the handsome and slick Joey Buttafuoco (Ed Marinaro). Amy is polite to Joey but Joey takes one look at Amy and he smiles in a way that immediately lets us know that he’s not to be trusted. Soon, he’s going out of his way to spend time with Amy and eventually, he seduces her in the house that he shares with his wife, Mary Jo (played by Check It Out‘s Kathleen Laskey). Soon, Joey and Amy are checking into cheap motels together. Amy think that she’s in love with Joey and Joey says that he loves her (though only when he wants her to do something).
Joey eventually coerces Amy into becoming an escort, enjoying the stories of her spending time with other older men. And yet, when Amy follows his orders and gets a gym membership, Joey freaks out when she attracts the attention of a man who is close to her own age. For her part, Amy starts to wonder whether she and Joey will ever truly be together. Joey insinuates that his wife would have to die before he could even think of marrying Amy Fisher. Amy happens to have a friend who has a gun….
Amy Fisher: My Story largely plays out in flashbacks and is narrated by Amy as she sits in her jail cell. It’s based on the same true story that inspired Casualties of Love, with the main difference being that this is Amy’s version of the story. And it must be said that Amy’s version, with Amy as an insecure and abused teenager being groomed by a manipulative sociopath, feels considerably more plausible than Casualties of Love‘s portrayal of Joey Buttafuoco as being the misunderstood Saint of Long Island. Working to Amy Fisher: My Story‘s advantage is that it doesn’t let Amy off the hook. Ultimately, she’s the one who decides to knock on Mary Jo’s front door and then shoot her when she answers. Amy is not portrayed as being a saint but she’s not a one-dimensional psycho either. Instead, she’s a naive and emotionally damaged girl who is so desperate to feel loved that she allows Joey to push her over the edge.
Amy Fisher: My Story is a well-done look at a sordid story. Ed Marinaro is appropriately sleazy and macho as Joey. Noelle Parker gives a quiet but strong performance as Amy Fisher, playing her as someone who knows that she’s being manipulated but who still finds herself clinging to the smallest shred of hope that she’s not. While the film never quite transcends its tabloid origins, it still provides a worthy reminder that there’s always a human behind the headlines.