In 1957, the Commission — the governing board that regulated organized crime in America — seemed like it was on the very of collapsing. Bugsy Siegel was dead. Lucky Luciano had been exiled to Sicily. Meyer Lansky was more concerned with running his casinos in Cuba than with keeping track of who was angry with who in America. The ruthless Vito Genovese was moving in on everyone’s business and was suspected of being behind the assassination of Albert Anastasia and the shooting of Frank Costello.
Genovese, looking to solidify his control and perhaps bring some peace to the warring factions, called for a summit in upstate New York, at the estate of Joseph Barbara. Bosses from across the country gathered in Apalachin, New York. It started out as a nice weekend, with stories being told and fish being grilled. But then, suddenly, the cops showed up and 50 of the country’s most powerful mobsters made a run for it. Many of them ducked into the woods, where they were subsequently rounded up by the cops.
In the end, several mobsters were arrested and convicted of various crimes. All of those convictions were overturned on appeal. However, the arrests revealed to America that the Mafia wasn’t just an urban legend. Up until the bust at Apalachin, FBI director J. Edgar Hoover insisted that there was no such thing as the Mafia. After the bust, Hoover not only acknowledged that the Mafia existed but he also started a special division of the FBI to deal with it.
(Not that it did much good, of course. Being exposed still didn’t stop the Mafia from fixing the vote in Illinois during the 1960 presidential election.)
The 2019 film Mob Town details the events leading up to the Apalachin Conference. Robert Davi is properly intimidating as the ruthless Vito Genovese. The film’s director, Danny A. Abeckaser, plays Joseph Barbara while Jami-Lyn Sigler plays Barbara’s wife, tasked with putting together a dinner for a growing list of guests. Josephine Barbara goes from being happy about her husband working his way up the ranks of the mob to growing increasingly frustrated as the number of expected bosses rises from 30 to 50 and I have to say that I could very much relate to Josephine. Finally, David Arquette plays Edgar Croswell, the New York state trooper who figured out that something big was happening at the Barbara place. Croswell spends most of the film trying to get people to take him seriously. At the end of the film, he gets a congratulatory call from President Eisenhower. I’m enough of a history nerd that I appreciate any film that ends with a congratulatory call from President Eisenhower.
Mob Land was obviously made for a low-budget and it doesn’t always move as quickly as one might like. When Croswell isn’t trying to expose the mob, he’s pursuing a romance with Natalie (Jennifer Esposito) and Arquette’s permanently dazed expression doesn’t always make him the most convincing state trooper. It’s an uneven movie that traffics in almost every mob cliche but I can’t be too critical of it. Robert Davi was a more convincing Genovese than Robert De Niro was in Alto Knights. I appreciated the scenes of the Barbaras trying to get their place ready for the meeting. That was mob action to which I could relate.
Through the Shattered Lens 