Film Review: The Woman In Black (dir. by James Watkins)


Taking place in turn-of-the-century England, The Woman In Black tells the story of Arthur Kipps (played by Daniel Radcliffe), a young lawyer who is still struggling to recover from the death of his wife four years previously.  Arthur is sent to an isolated village to settle the estate of a woman named Alice Drablow.  Despite several warnings from the superstitious townspeople, Arthur goes to Alice’s decrepit old mansion and he soon finds himself haunted by fleeting glimpses of a woman in black who seems to be in the house with him.  With each sighting of the woman in black, another child in the village commits suicide.

Despite a few genuinely disturbing scenes (mostly involving children committing suicide), The Woman In Black is, ultimately, a pretty typical PG-13 horror film.  There’s a few good, if predictable, jump scenes (most of which involve the title character popping up in the background) and there’s all the usual Insidious-style tracking shots through the creepy old house.  However, any time that it seems like the film is about to become truly disturbing or scary, it runs smack into that PG-13 rating and it has to pull back.  The end result is that the film is creepy yet oddly bland, like something you might find playing on Chiller around one in the morning.

Of course, The Woman in Black is getting a lot of attention because this is Daniel Radcliffe’s first film since the end of the Harry Potter franchise.  How does Radcliffe do in his first adult role?  Well, he’s okay.  In fact, I would say that he’s better than okay.  He’s perfectly adequate.  I think the main issue I had with Radcliffe’s performance is that he sometimes seems to be trying too hard to make sure that we understand that he’s not playing Harry Potter.  For that reason, he doesn’t shave and he spends almost the entire film with a grim expression on his face.  Radcliffe’s a good actor and I think he’ll have a long career but he’s just miscast here.  Arthur Kipps is a man who has given up on life and Radcliffe is simply too exuberant of a performer to play defeated.  Oddly enough, Ciaran Hinds (who co-stars in this film) would have made the perfect Arthur.

I did enjoy spotting the various references to other horror films that were littered throughout The Woman in Black.  While the film obviously owes its existence to the success of the Paranormal Activity films, both the film’s overall plot and isolated village setting reminded me of Mario Bava’s masterpiece, Kill, Baby, Bill.  Furthermore, the film’s somewhat effective ending reminded me of the end of Lucio Fulci’s The House By The Cemetery.  I’m not sure if any of those homages were intentional but they were still fun to spot.

As a final note, The Woman in Black is the latest PG-13 rated horror film to be advertised with annoying infrared footage of people watching the movie and screaming.   Personally, I think it might be time for a new cliché.

4 responses to “Film Review: The Woman In Black (dir. by James Watkins)

  1. I saw this movie tonight!

    I think one of the reasons that movie gives a little bland impression after viewing is how the first two acts of the film are constructed. I actually hesitate to say anything more explicit because it’s spoiler-riffic, and might ruin the movie for people that are still planning to see it.

    Basically, the film can’t tell the audience too much about the nature of the ghost or the plot behind her until they’ve gotten all of their token scares in… because otherwise, the audience would be bored and would want to see the plot in motion.

    Incidentally: I loved the ending. To me, this was the film’s strongest point.

    Like

    • I agree with the ending, the more I think about it the more I like it. I think my problem with the rest of the film comes down to exactly what you said in your comment: so many of the scare scenes felt like token scares, like “This is a horror film so now we have to do the whole face-in-the-window thing.”

      Like

  2. Pingback: Horror Trailer: The Woman In Black — Angel of Death | Through the Shattered Lens

  3. Pingback: Film Review: The Woman In Black: The Angel of Death (dir by Tom Harper) | Through the Shattered Lens

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.