Katharine Hepburn was famous for both her relationship with Spencer Tracy and the films that she made with him.  They were such frequent co-stars and so associated with each other that “Hepburn-Tracy” became a film genre in and of itself, one that promised a bit of comedy, a bit of drama, and some sharp-witted romance.  That said, I have to admit that one of my favorite of Katharine Hepburn’s film is one that she made not with Spencer Tracy but instead with Fred MacMurray.  Alice Adams is a Tracy-Hepburn film without Tracy.

First released in 1935 and based on a novel by Booth Tarkington (who was quite a big deal back in the day even if, like Arrowsmith‘s Sinclair Lewis, he’s somewhat forgotten today), Alice Adams stars Hepburn as the title character.  Alice is the daughter of Virgil Adams (Fred Stone) and his wife, who is only referred to as being Mrs. Adams (Anne Shoemaker).  Virgil is a sickly man who has worked as a clerk at a glue factory for several years.  Despite living in a rather large house and having a maid named Malena (Hatti McDaniel), the Adams family is not wealthy.  However, Mrs. Adams desperately wants the family to be rich and Alice carries herself with the airs of a wealthy woman, despite the fact that everyone in town knows that she’s not.  Alice love her family and is loyal to them, even if her younger brother (Frank Albertson, who later played Sam “Hee Haw” Wainwright in It’s A Wonderful Life) appears to be addicted to gambling and her mother is constantly browbeating her father for not being more ambitious.  Her family may embarrass her but we know she wouldn’t trade them for all the money in the world.  That’s why we like Alice, even if she does sometimes act like a snob.

However, when Alice meets and falls for the wealthy Arthur Russell (Fred MacMurray), she lies about her social background and tries to present herself as being just as rich as him.  When she invites Arthur and his parents to her house for a dinner party, she frantically tries to keep up the charade of being wealthy.  Meanwhile, Virgil finds himself wrongly accused of stealing from his boss (Charley Grapewin) and, as a result, the family’s financial future is put in jeopardy.

Alice Adams is a mix of screwball comedy and social drama.  On the one hand, Alice’s desperate attempts to throw the perfect party are frequently very funny.  Katharine Hepburn was always at her best when she played a flighty character and the contrast between Alice’s sophisticated airs and Alice’s actual personality makes me laugh every time that I watch the film.  At the same time, there’s a definite undercurrent of melancholy to the film.  Alice and her mother are both so desperate to be rich that they’ve both been blinded to just how wonderful their lives really are.  Alice may like Arthur and Arthur definitely likes Alice but one never forgets that a part of Alice’s attraction to Arthur is that Arthur can give her the life to which she aspires.

Alice Adams features one of Hepburn’s best performances and it’s a rare Hepburn performance to which anyone watching should be able to relate.  At some point in our lives, we’ve all felt like Alice.  We’ve all been Alice, even if we don’t want to admit it.  Fred MacMurray’s natural likability serves him well as Arthur.  He comes across like a genuinely nice guy and we definitely want him and Alice to end up together.

Alice Adams was nominated for Best Picture but it lost to a much bigger production, Mutiny on the Bounty.  Bette Davis beat Katharine Hepburn for Best Actress.  Davis later said that she felt Hepburn should have won.