For the past seven days, I’ve been reviewing — in chronological order — fifty of the most memorable melodramas ever filmed. We started with a silent film from 1916 and now, we have reached the 80s. What better way to kick off the decade than by taking a look at the 1980 Best Picture winner, Ordinary People?
Directed by Robert Redford, Ordinary People tells the story of the upper middle class Jarrett family. On the surface, the Jarretts appear to be the perfect family. Calvin Jarrett (Donald Sutherland) has a successful career. Beth (Mary Tyler Moore) keeps a perfect home and appears to be the ideal suburban matriarch. However, one summer, their oldest son drowns in a sailing accident and their youngest son, sensitive Conrad (Timothy Hutton), attempts to commit suicide. After spending four months in a psychiatric hospital, Conrad come back home and the family struggles to put their lives back together. Even though he starts to see a therapist (Judd Hirsch) and starts dating his classmate Jeannine (Elizabeth McGovern), Conrad still struggles with his feelings of guilt over having survived. Beth’s struggle to maintain a facade of normalcy leads to several fights between her and Conrad with Calvin trapped in the middle.
Among my fellow film bloggers, there’s always going to be a very vocal group that is going to hate Ordinary People because it won the Oscar for best picture over challenging black-and-white films directed by Martin Scorsese (Raging Bull) and David Lynch (The Elephant Man). They always tend to complain that Ordinary People is a conventional film that tells a conventional story and that it was directed by a very conventional director. More than once, I’ve seen an online film critic refer to Ordinary People as being a “big budget Lifetime movie.”
Well, you know what?
I love Lifetime. Lifetime is the best network on television and to me, a big budget Lifetime movie would be the best Lifetime movie of all. And, at the risk of alienating all of my film-loving friends, if I had to choose between watching Raging Bull and Ordinary People, I’m going to pick Ordinary People every time. Raging Bull is visually stunning and features great performances but it’s also two hours spent watching an incredibly unlikable human being beating the crap out of anyone who is foolish enough to love him. Ordinary People may essentially look like a TV show but it’s also about characters that you can understand and that, as the film progresses, you grow to truly care about.
Yes, I do wish that the character of Beth had been given more of a chance to talk about her feelings and it’s hard not to feel that Ordinary People places too much blame on the mother. But, even so, the film still ends with vague — if unlikely — hope that Beth will eventually be able to move past her anger and reconnect with her family. The film may be hard on Beth but it never gives up on her. That’s what distinguishes Ordinary People for me. In many ways, it’s a very sad film. It’s a film that was specifically designed to make you cry and I certainly shed a few tears while I watched it. But, even with its somewhat ambiguous ending, Ordinary People is also a very optimistic movie. It’s a movie that says that, as much pain as we may have in our life,we can recover and life can go on and it’s okay to be sad and its also okay to be happy.
And that’s an important lesson to learn.
(That said, if I had been alive and an Academy voter in 1981, I would have voted for The Elephant Man.)
And, for all you Oscar lovers out there, here are clips of Timothy Hutton and Robert Redford winning Oscars for their work on Ordinary People.
The first time I saw Ordinary People was in my Freshman English class. It was one of those classes where the teacher was still living the 60’s and 70’s except this time he’s doing it while teaching an English course in a Catholic Prep School.
We had to get permission slips signed by parents to see this because it was going to have themes and scenes that were of an adult nature. I wasn’t too thriled about the film when it began but, as Lisa pointed out, I started to care for these characters.
The title is quite appropriate since Jarrett family could easily be any family. It’s their very normalcy and All-American nuclear family look that belies just how flawed even the perfect family were once you scratch beneath that layer of veneer.
You could’ve substituted a poor, urban family for the Jarrett’s and the film would’ve still been able to make its point.
LikeLike
Pingback: Back to School #75: The Spectacular Now (dir by James Ponsoldt) | Through the Shattered Lens
Loved you review! Respectfully request to read and sign my petition for Paramount and Sundance to remaster and release ORDINARY PEOPLE, ideally on a Criterion Blu-ray. https://www.change.org/p/paramount-pictures-sundance-institute-1980-best-picture-ordinary-people-blu-ray Thank you! 🙂
LikeLiked by 1 person
Thanks! I signed.
LikeLike
Pingback: Never Nominated: 16 Actors Who Have Never Been Nominated For An Oscar | Through the Shattered Lens
Pingback: Lisa Ranks Every Best Picture Winner From Best To Worst! | Through the Shattered Lens
Pingback: The Best Picture Race In Review: The 1980s | Through the Shattered Lens